-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 224
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
feat!: turn TypeIsMorePrivateThenItem into an error #6953
Conversation
Execution Report
|
Compilation Report
|
Compilation Memory Report
|
Execution Memory Report
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
LGTM!
By the way there are some Noir tests that access private members of structs defined in Noir, giving warnings. Are they going to be considered errors soon, or already?
Soon! Though accessing private members of structs is done a lot in Aztec-Packages, and maybe in other external repos, we'll see, but I'm sure that's going to be the toughest one to move forward. |
I'll just push another commit to document this visibility behavior. |
🚀 Deployed on https://677d0864d0ce776613b9ab64--noir-docs.netlify.app |
FYI @noir-lang/developerrelations on Noir doc changes. |
) feat: `--pedantic-solving` flag (noir-lang/noir#6716) feat!: update `aes128_encrypt` to return an array (noir-lang/noir#6973) fix: wrong module to lookup trait when using crate or super (noir-lang/noir#6974) fix: Start RC at 1 again (noir-lang/noir#6958) feat!: turn TypeIsMorePrivateThenItem into an error (noir-lang/noir#6953) fix: don't fail parsing macro if there are parser warnings (noir-lang/noir#6969) fix: error on missing function parameters (noir-lang/noir#6967) feat: don't report warnings for dependencies (noir-lang/noir#6926) chore: simplify boolean in a mul of a mul (noir-lang/noir#6951) feat(ssa): Immediately simplify away RefCount instructions in ACIR functions (noir-lang/noir#6893) chore: Move comment as part of #6945 (noir-lang/noir#6959) chore: Separate unconstrained functions during monomorphization (noir-lang/noir#6894) feat!: turn CannotReexportItemWithLessVisibility into an error (noir-lang/noir#6952) feat: lock on Nargo.toml on several nargo commands (noir-lang/noir#6941) feat: don't simplify SSA instructions when creating them from a string (noir-lang/noir#6948) chore: add reproduction case for bignum test failure (noir-lang/noir#6464) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6949) feat(test): Enable the test fuzzer for Wasm (noir-lang/noir#6835) chore: also print test output to stdout in CI (noir-lang/noir#6930) fix: Non-determinism from under constrained checks (noir-lang/noir#6945) chore: use logs for benchmarking (noir-lang/noir#6911) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6944) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6943) fix: Show output of `test_program_is_idempotent` on failure (noir-lang/noir#6942) chore: delete a bunch of dead code from `noirc_evaluator` (noir-lang/noir#6939) feat: require trait function calls (`Foo::bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6882) chore: Bump arkworks to version `0.5.0` (noir-lang/noir#6871)
feat: `--pedantic-solving` flag (noir-lang/noir#6716) feat!: update `aes128_encrypt` to return an array (noir-lang/noir#6973) fix: wrong module to lookup trait when using crate or super (noir-lang/noir#6974) fix: Start RC at 1 again (noir-lang/noir#6958) feat!: turn TypeIsMorePrivateThenItem into an error (noir-lang/noir#6953) fix: don't fail parsing macro if there are parser warnings (noir-lang/noir#6969) fix: error on missing function parameters (noir-lang/noir#6967) feat: don't report warnings for dependencies (noir-lang/noir#6926) chore: simplify boolean in a mul of a mul (noir-lang/noir#6951) feat(ssa): Immediately simplify away RefCount instructions in ACIR functions (noir-lang/noir#6893) chore: Move comment as part of #6945 (noir-lang/noir#6959) chore: Separate unconstrained functions during monomorphization (noir-lang/noir#6894) feat!: turn CannotReexportItemWithLessVisibility into an error (noir-lang/noir#6952) feat: lock on Nargo.toml on several nargo commands (noir-lang/noir#6941) feat: don't simplify SSA instructions when creating them from a string (noir-lang/noir#6948) chore: add reproduction case for bignum test failure (noir-lang/noir#6464) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6949) feat(test): Enable the test fuzzer for Wasm (noir-lang/noir#6835) chore: also print test output to stdout in CI (noir-lang/noir#6930) fix: Non-determinism from under constrained checks (noir-lang/noir#6945) chore: use logs for benchmarking (noir-lang/noir#6911) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6944) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6943) fix: Show output of `test_program_is_idempotent` on failure (noir-lang/noir#6942) chore: delete a bunch of dead code from `noirc_evaluator` (noir-lang/noir#6939) feat: require trait function calls (`Foo::bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6882) chore: Bump arkworks to version `0.5.0` (noir-lang/noir#6871)
* master: (51 commits) feat!: type-check trait default methods (#6645) feat: `--pedantic-solving` flag (#6716) feat!: update `aes128_encrypt` to return an array (#6973) fix: wrong module to lookup trait when using crate or super (#6974) fix: Start RC at 1 again (#6958) feat!: turn TypeIsMorePrivateThenItem into an error (#6953) fix: don't fail parsing macro if there are parser warnings (#6969) fix: error on missing function parameters (#6967) feat: don't report warnings for dependencies (#6926) chore: simplify boolean in a mul of a mul (#6951) feat(ssa): Immediately simplify away RefCount instructions in ACIR functions (#6893) chore: Move comment as part of #6945 (#6959) chore: Separate unconstrained functions during monomorphization (#6894) feat!: turn CannotReexportItemWithLessVisibility into an error (#6952) feat: lock on Nargo.toml on several nargo commands (#6941) feat: don't simplify SSA instructions when creating them from a string (#6948) chore: add reproduction case for bignum test failure (#6464) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (#6949) feat(test): Enable the test fuzzer for Wasm (#6835) chore: also print test output to stdout in CI (#6930) ...
* master: feat!: type-check trait default methods (#6645) feat: `--pedantic-solving` flag (#6716) feat!: update `aes128_encrypt` to return an array (#6973) fix: wrong module to lookup trait when using crate or super (#6974) fix: Start RC at 1 again (#6958) feat!: turn TypeIsMorePrivateThenItem into an error (#6953) fix: don't fail parsing macro if there are parser warnings (#6969) fix: error on missing function parameters (#6967)
) feat: `--pedantic-solving` flag (noir-lang/noir#6716) feat!: update `aes128_encrypt` to return an array (noir-lang/noir#6973) fix: wrong module to lookup trait when using crate or super (noir-lang/noir#6974) fix: Start RC at 1 again (noir-lang/noir#6958) feat!: turn TypeIsMorePrivateThenItem into an error (noir-lang/noir#6953) fix: don't fail parsing macro if there are parser warnings (noir-lang/noir#6969) fix: error on missing function parameters (noir-lang/noir#6967) feat: don't report warnings for dependencies (noir-lang/noir#6926) chore: simplify boolean in a mul of a mul (noir-lang/noir#6951) feat(ssa): Immediately simplify away RefCount instructions in ACIR functions (noir-lang/noir#6893) chore: Move comment as part of #6945 (noir-lang/noir#6959) chore: Separate unconstrained functions during monomorphization (noir-lang/noir#6894) feat!: turn CannotReexportItemWithLessVisibility into an error (noir-lang/noir#6952) feat: lock on Nargo.toml on several nargo commands (noir-lang/noir#6941) feat: don't simplify SSA instructions when creating them from a string (noir-lang/noir#6948) chore: add reproduction case for bignum test failure (noir-lang/noir#6464) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6949) feat(test): Enable the test fuzzer for Wasm (noir-lang/noir#6835) chore: also print test output to stdout in CI (noir-lang/noir#6930) fix: Non-determinism from under constrained checks (noir-lang/noir#6945) chore: use logs for benchmarking (noir-lang/noir#6911) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6944) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6943) fix: Show output of `test_program_is_idempotent` on failure (noir-lang/noir#6942) chore: delete a bunch of dead code from `noirc_evaluator` (noir-lang/noir#6939) feat: require trait function calls (`Foo::bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6882) chore: Bump arkworks to version `0.5.0` (noir-lang/noir#6871)
feat: `--pedantic-solving` flag (noir-lang/noir#6716) feat!: update `aes128_encrypt` to return an array (noir-lang/noir#6973) fix: wrong module to lookup trait when using crate or super (noir-lang/noir#6974) fix: Start RC at 1 again (noir-lang/noir#6958) feat!: turn TypeIsMorePrivateThenItem into an error (noir-lang/noir#6953) fix: don't fail parsing macro if there are parser warnings (noir-lang/noir#6969) fix: error on missing function parameters (noir-lang/noir#6967) feat: don't report warnings for dependencies (noir-lang/noir#6926) chore: simplify boolean in a mul of a mul (noir-lang/noir#6951) feat(ssa): Immediately simplify away RefCount instructions in ACIR functions (noir-lang/noir#6893) chore: Move comment as part of #6945 (noir-lang/noir#6959) chore: Separate unconstrained functions during monomorphization (noir-lang/noir#6894) feat!: turn CannotReexportItemWithLessVisibility into an error (noir-lang/noir#6952) feat: lock on Nargo.toml on several nargo commands (noir-lang/noir#6941) feat: don't simplify SSA instructions when creating them from a string (noir-lang/noir#6948) chore: add reproduction case for bignum test failure (noir-lang/noir#6464) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6949) feat(test): Enable the test fuzzer for Wasm (noir-lang/noir#6835) chore: also print test output to stdout in CI (noir-lang/noir#6930) fix: Non-determinism from under constrained checks (noir-lang/noir#6945) chore: use logs for benchmarking (noir-lang/noir#6911) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6944) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6943) fix: Show output of `test_program_is_idempotent` on failure (noir-lang/noir#6942) chore: delete a bunch of dead code from `noirc_evaluator` (noir-lang/noir#6939) feat: require trait function calls (`Foo::bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6882) chore: Bump arkworks to version `0.5.0` (noir-lang/noir#6871)
Upstream have added a new compiler option flag called "pedantic-solving". We took it into account and modified `nargo prove` and `nargo trace` accordingly. In PR noir-lang#6953 upstream have made type privacy more strict. In result some of our tests started failing because we were using a private structure in a public function. Therefore we changed our tests to fit better with the newly provided standards.
fix: Do not emit range check for multiplication by bool (noir-lang/noir#6983) fix: do not panic on indices which are not valid `u32`s (noir-lang/noir#6976) feat!: require trait method calls (`foo.bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6895) feat!: type-check trait default methods (noir-lang/noir#6645) feat: `--pedantic-solving` flag (noir-lang/noir#6716) feat!: update `aes128_encrypt` to return an array (noir-lang/noir#6973) fix: wrong module to lookup trait when using crate or super (noir-lang/noir#6974) fix: Start RC at 1 again (noir-lang/noir#6958) feat!: turn TypeIsMorePrivateThenItem into an error (noir-lang/noir#6953) fix: don't fail parsing macro if there are parser warnings (noir-lang/noir#6969) fix: error on missing function parameters (noir-lang/noir#6967) feat: don't report warnings for dependencies (noir-lang/noir#6926) chore: simplify boolean in a mul of a mul (noir-lang/noir#6951) feat(ssa): Immediately simplify away RefCount instructions in ACIR functions (noir-lang/noir#6893) chore: Move comment as part of #6945 (noir-lang/noir#6959) chore: Separate unconstrained functions during monomorphization (noir-lang/noir#6894) feat!: turn CannotReexportItemWithLessVisibility into an error (noir-lang/noir#6952) feat: lock on Nargo.toml on several nargo commands (noir-lang/noir#6941) feat: don't simplify SSA instructions when creating them from a string (noir-lang/noir#6948) chore: add reproduction case for bignum test failure (noir-lang/noir#6464) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6949) feat(test): Enable the test fuzzer for Wasm (noir-lang/noir#6835) chore: also print test output to stdout in CI (noir-lang/noir#6930) fix: Non-determinism from under constrained checks (noir-lang/noir#6945) chore: use logs for benchmarking (noir-lang/noir#6911) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6944) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6943) fix: Show output of `test_program_is_idempotent` on failure (noir-lang/noir#6942) chore: delete a bunch of dead code from `noirc_evaluator` (noir-lang/noir#6939) feat: require trait function calls (`Foo::bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6882) chore: Bump arkworks to version `0.5.0` (noir-lang/noir#6871)
fix: Do not emit range check for multiplication by bool (noir-lang/noir#6983) fix: do not panic on indices which are not valid `u32`s (noir-lang/noir#6976) feat!: require trait method calls (`foo.bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6895) feat!: type-check trait default methods (noir-lang/noir#6645) feat: `--pedantic-solving` flag (noir-lang/noir#6716) feat!: update `aes128_encrypt` to return an array (noir-lang/noir#6973) fix: wrong module to lookup trait when using crate or super (noir-lang/noir#6974) fix: Start RC at 1 again (noir-lang/noir#6958) feat!: turn TypeIsMorePrivateThenItem into an error (noir-lang/noir#6953) fix: don't fail parsing macro if there are parser warnings (noir-lang/noir#6969) fix: error on missing function parameters (noir-lang/noir#6967) feat: don't report warnings for dependencies (noir-lang/noir#6926) chore: simplify boolean in a mul of a mul (noir-lang/noir#6951) feat(ssa): Immediately simplify away RefCount instructions in ACIR functions (noir-lang/noir#6893) chore: Move comment as part of #6945 (noir-lang/noir#6959) chore: Separate unconstrained functions during monomorphization (noir-lang/noir#6894) feat!: turn CannotReexportItemWithLessVisibility into an error (noir-lang/noir#6952) feat: lock on Nargo.toml on several nargo commands (noir-lang/noir#6941) feat: don't simplify SSA instructions when creating them from a string (noir-lang/noir#6948) chore: add reproduction case for bignum test failure (noir-lang/noir#6464) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6949) feat(test): Enable the test fuzzer for Wasm (noir-lang/noir#6835) chore: also print test output to stdout in CI (noir-lang/noir#6930) fix: Non-determinism from under constrained checks (noir-lang/noir#6945) chore: use logs for benchmarking (noir-lang/noir#6911) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6944) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6943) fix: Show output of `test_program_is_idempotent` on failure (noir-lang/noir#6942) chore: delete a bunch of dead code from `noirc_evaluator` (noir-lang/noir#6939) feat: require trait function calls (`Foo::bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6882) chore: Bump arkworks to version `0.5.0` (noir-lang/noir#6871)
Automated pull of development from the [noir](https://github.com/noir-lang/noir) programming language, a dependency of Aztec. BEGIN_COMMIT_OVERRIDE feat: impl Default for U128 (noir-lang/noir#6984) fix: Do not emit range check for multiplication by bool (noir-lang/noir#6983) fix: do not panic on indices which are not valid `u32`s (noir-lang/noir#6976) feat!: require trait method calls (`foo.bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6895) feat!: type-check trait default methods (noir-lang/noir#6645) feat: `--pedantic-solving` flag (noir-lang/noir#6716) feat!: update `aes128_encrypt` to return an array (noir-lang/noir#6973) fix: wrong module to lookup trait when using crate or super (noir-lang/noir#6974) fix: Start RC at 1 again (noir-lang/noir#6958) feat!: turn TypeIsMorePrivateThenItem into an error (noir-lang/noir#6953) fix: don't fail parsing macro if there are parser warnings (noir-lang/noir#6969) fix: error on missing function parameters (noir-lang/noir#6967) feat: don't report warnings for dependencies (noir-lang/noir#6926) chore: simplify boolean in a mul of a mul (noir-lang/noir#6951) feat(ssa): Immediately simplify away RefCount instructions in ACIR functions (noir-lang/noir#6893) chore: Move comment as part of #6945 (noir-lang/noir#6959) chore: Separate unconstrained functions during monomorphization (noir-lang/noir#6894) feat!: turn CannotReexportItemWithLessVisibility into an error (noir-lang/noir#6952) feat: lock on Nargo.toml on several nargo commands (noir-lang/noir#6941) feat: don't simplify SSA instructions when creating them from a string (noir-lang/noir#6948) chore: add reproduction case for bignum test failure (noir-lang/noir#6464) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6949) feat(test): Enable the test fuzzer for Wasm (noir-lang/noir#6835) chore: also print test output to stdout in CI (noir-lang/noir#6930) fix: Non-determinism from under constrained checks (noir-lang/noir#6945) chore: use logs for benchmarking (noir-lang/noir#6911) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6944) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6943) fix: Show output of `test_program_is_idempotent` on failure (noir-lang/noir#6942) chore: delete a bunch of dead code from `noirc_evaluator` (noir-lang/noir#6939) feat: require trait function calls (`Foo::bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6882) chore: Bump arkworks to version `0.5.0` (noir-lang/noir#6871) END_COMMIT_OVERRIDE --------- Co-authored-by: Michael J Klein <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Michael Klein <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Tom French <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Tom French <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Charlie Lye <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: ludamad <[email protected]>
Automated pull of development from the [noir](https://github.com/noir-lang/noir) programming language, a dependency of Aztec. BEGIN_COMMIT_OVERRIDE feat: impl Default for U128 (noir-lang/noir#6984) fix: Do not emit range check for multiplication by bool (noir-lang/noir#6983) fix: do not panic on indices which are not valid `u32`s (noir-lang/noir#6976) feat!: require trait method calls (`foo.bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6895) feat!: type-check trait default methods (noir-lang/noir#6645) feat: `--pedantic-solving` flag (noir-lang/noir#6716) feat!: update `aes128_encrypt` to return an array (noir-lang/noir#6973) fix: wrong module to lookup trait when using crate or super (noir-lang/noir#6974) fix: Start RC at 1 again (noir-lang/noir#6958) feat!: turn TypeIsMorePrivateThenItem into an error (noir-lang/noir#6953) fix: don't fail parsing macro if there are parser warnings (noir-lang/noir#6969) fix: error on missing function parameters (noir-lang/noir#6967) feat: don't report warnings for dependencies (noir-lang/noir#6926) chore: simplify boolean in a mul of a mul (noir-lang/noir#6951) feat(ssa): Immediately simplify away RefCount instructions in ACIR functions (noir-lang/noir#6893) chore: Move comment as part of #6945 (noir-lang/noir#6959) chore: Separate unconstrained functions during monomorphization (noir-lang/noir#6894) feat!: turn CannotReexportItemWithLessVisibility into an error (noir-lang/noir#6952) feat: lock on Nargo.toml on several nargo commands (noir-lang/noir#6941) feat: don't simplify SSA instructions when creating them from a string (noir-lang/noir#6948) chore: add reproduction case for bignum test failure (noir-lang/noir#6464) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6949) feat(test): Enable the test fuzzer for Wasm (noir-lang/noir#6835) chore: also print test output to stdout in CI (noir-lang/noir#6930) fix: Non-determinism from under constrained checks (noir-lang/noir#6945) chore: use logs for benchmarking (noir-lang/noir#6911) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6944) chore: bump `noir-gates-diff` (noir-lang/noir#6943) fix: Show output of `test_program_is_idempotent` on failure (noir-lang/noir#6942) chore: delete a bunch of dead code from `noirc_evaluator` (noir-lang/noir#6939) feat: require trait function calls (`Foo::bar()`) to have the trait in scope (imported) (noir-lang/noir#6882) chore: Bump arkworks to version `0.5.0` (noir-lang/noir#6871) END_COMMIT_OVERRIDE --------- Co-authored-by: Michael J Klein <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Michael Klein <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Tom French <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Tom French <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Charlie Lye <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: ludamad <[email protected]>
Description
Problem
Resolves #6936
Summary
In addition to turning the warning into an error, it turned out this program incorrectly gave a warning:
The reason is that we consider all trait methods to be public, but in reality (and according with Rust) they should have the same visibility as the trait they belong to. So this is changed in this PR.
Then, trait methods weren't correctly checked. When calling a trait method on a primitive, some logic regarding primitive methods were checked instead of checking the trait visibility, so this PR fixes that too.
Additional Context
Documentation
Check one:
PR Checklist
cargo fmt
on default settings.