Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Bug: Useless and "null" attributes left in the SVG source when exporting #76

Closed
AndroidDeveloperLB opened this issue Feb 29, 2016 · 6 comments
Labels

Comments

@AndroidDeveloperLB
Copy link

I've noticed that the output always has a border.

Here's an example of what I got :

<svg width="476" height="476" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
 <!-- Created with SVG-edit - http://svg-edit.googlecode.com/ -->
 <g>
  <title>Layer 1</title>
  <ellipse ry="198.5" rx="198.5" id="svg_3" cy="238" cx="238" stroke-linecap="null" stroke-linejoin="null" stroke-width="0" stroke="#000000" fill="#f3f3f3"/>
 </g>
</svg>

When converting it to Android-file (using this tool: http://inloop.github.io/svg2android/ ) , I can see the border clearly

@codedread
Copy link
Member

Are you saying that in SVG-edit you see the border? Just tried your file on Chrome OSX and I don't see a border at all.

Could this be a border with the Android Drawables converter because we still have the stroke="#000000" attribute in there?

On the other hands, having those "null" values and stroke values that are not needed are not a great idea. We should clean that up when doing the final sanitizing upon export...

@codedread codedread changed the title Bug: cannot have no-border for circles Bug: Useless and "null" attributes left in the SVG source when exporting Feb 29, 2016
@AndroidDeveloperLB
Copy link
Author

by removing all stroke related things here, and then converting the file, I got the border removed.
I think a color of "#000000" is black. not transparent.
And maybe the other values don't mean anything there. I'm not an expert in SVG and VectorDrawable (which is relatively very new).

@AndroidDeveloperLB
Copy link
Author

I think that if the stroke-width is set to 0, it should remove any stroke related attribute.

@codedread
Copy link
Member

Agreed - feel free to send along a patch :)

@AndroidDeveloperLB
Copy link
Author

I know (almost) nothing about HTML5 and SVG. Sorry.
That's why I wrote about this issue here...

@codedread
Copy link
Member

No worries and no pressure. That's just the standard open source response for "acknowledged bug, but don't have time to work on it right now" :-)

@brettz9 brettz9 added the bug label May 31, 2018
cuixiping added a commit to cuixiping/svgedit that referenced this issue Jan 17, 2020
jfhenon added a commit that referenced this issue Mar 5, 2021
* #issue-fix The new menu will ask if you want to erase the current content but it will ignore the answer

* #issue-fix  dialog needs to be closer than the original

* #issue-fix main menu alignment changes

* #issue_fix double click and opensvg issue fixed

* #issue-fix process_cancel change to seConfirm

* #issue-fix review how the top toolbar display when many buttons are displayed

* #issue-fix unwanted css reoved

* #issue-fix BOTTOM TOOLS Make sure all features of the bottom toolbar are working

* #issue-fix IMPORT IMAGE menu open issue fixed

* #issue-fix alert dialog overwrite style

* #issue-fix lint issue fixed

* npm update + associated fixes

* #36 look of opacity button should like the zoom button (without the dropdown button)

* #37 Clicking anywhere on the bottom bar (for example below the opacity button is displaying the “color popup”.)

* #38 The opacity button does not update with the current element

* #42 When you import an image, it works well but the dialog should disappear automatically

* Fixes #53: 4th option for the background display fixed

* Fixes #53: 4th option for the background fixed

* #49 the x button does not work

* Fixes #41: Alignment fixes in bottom bar

* fix test scenario

* #39 opacity button/stroke size/radius button don’t allow the 0 value

* #41 The look and alignment of stroke size and stroke style should be consistent with the rest of the bottom bar.

* #44 Text font dropdown is broken

* #52 Fix the export

* Fixes #44: Text font dropdown fixed

* Fixes #44: Text font dropdown fixed

* Fixes #44: Text font dropdown fixed

* Fixes #44: Text font dropdown fixed

* Update index.html

* update husky

* fixes

* moves from index.html to js

* fix #66

* fix #48 first set of new icons

* Reorganize tools in left panel to be more intuitive

* Update button styles to adapt to new icons

* Fix #48 new set of icons for alignments

* Variabilisation of icon bkgd colors
Update of color choice to fit new icons design

* Update canvas and rulers colors

* Improve layer handle design

* Modernize SVG Logo but keeping original spirit

* Fix #48 continue improve icons

* Continue to reorganise left panel

* Update right panel handle for layers

* Fix #48 new set of icons for main menu

* Improve main menu design

* Rework menu organisation

* Rework menu organisation

* Update input element design

* New icons

* Improve Zoom Module

* Improve Color Picker Module

* New icons

* New icons

* #65 restore the feature of start/end marker lines partially did

* #64 The export dialog needs to include the quality options (except for PDF)

* #39 opacity button/stroke size/radius button don’t allow the 0 value

* #39 eslint changes

* #69 menu button style overwrite

* #65 restore the feature of start/end marker lines

* #43 With a small window, the look of the top toolbar is broken

* #43 tool top alignment revert

* #46 Move this jQuery component to a web component  for graduate and picker components

* #46 Move this jQuery component to a web component

* remove some non standard lint rules

* #46 picker convert as pure javascript changes

* #46 jquery plugin convert to pure javascript

* #46 jquery plugin change to pure javascript

* #46 jquery remove and convert to pure javascript

* #46 slider issue fixed

* #46 ColorValuePicker and js convertion

* #46 globals $ remov from slider class

* #46 jquery convert pure javascript changes

* #46 jquery to js convertion changes

* #46 paintbox and current element color set issue fixed

* #46 unwanted files removed

* #46 $.extend modify changes

* #46 extend modifiey changes

* #46 $.extend change to pure javascript

* #46 extend and data changes

* #46 jquery removed

* #45 These buttons don't work and dropdown is broken

* #45 These buttons don't work and dropdown is broken

* #45 These buttons don't work and dropdown is broken commit reverted

* #43 With a small window, the look of the top toolbar is broken

* Update jQuery.jPicker.js

* #76 draggable modification changes

* #76 jquery-ui-1.8.17.custom.min.js removed from editor

* #76 jquery ui file removed

* npm update

* #77 console issue fixed

* #77 <SVG> button issue fixed

* #77 shortkey issue fixed

* #77 jquery hotkeys plugin changes

* #77 hotkey plugin related changes

* #78 hotkey related code comment.

* #78 js-hotkeys/jquery.hotkeys.min.js file removed from svgedit.js

* #51 Rewrite the color palette without elix

* #81 unwanted files removed

* #81 folder name renamed

* #81 folder rename changes

* #81 jquery-ui  folder renamed

* #81 jquery modify changes

* #81 globals $ removed

Co-authored-by: Agriya Dev5 <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: mathieucura <[email protected]>
jfhenon added a commit that referenced this issue Mar 14, 2021
* #issue-fix The new menu will ask if you want to erase the current content but it will ignore the answer

* #issue-fix  dialog needs to be closer than the original

* #issue-fix main menu alignment changes

* #issue_fix double click and opensvg issue fixed

* #issue-fix process_cancel change to seConfirm

* #issue-fix review how the top toolbar display when many buttons are displayed

* #issue-fix unwanted css reoved

* #issue-fix BOTTOM TOOLS Make sure all features of the bottom toolbar are working

* #issue-fix IMPORT IMAGE menu open issue fixed

* #issue-fix alert dialog overwrite style

* #issue-fix lint issue fixed

* npm update + associated fixes

* #36 look of opacity button should like the zoom button (without the dropdown button)

* #37 Clicking anywhere on the bottom bar (for example below the opacity button is displaying the “color popup”.)

* #38 The opacity button does not update with the current element

* #42 When you import an image, it works well but the dialog should disappear automatically

* Fixes #53: 4th option for the background display fixed

* Fixes #53: 4th option for the background fixed

* #49 the x button does not work

* Fixes #41: Alignment fixes in bottom bar

* fix test scenario

* #39 opacity button/stroke size/radius button don’t allow the 0 value

* #41 The look and alignment of stroke size and stroke style should be consistent with the rest of the bottom bar.

* #44 Text font dropdown is broken

* #52 Fix the export

* Fixes #44: Text font dropdown fixed

* Fixes #44: Text font dropdown fixed

* Fixes #44: Text font dropdown fixed

* Fixes #44: Text font dropdown fixed

* Update index.html

* update husky

* fixes

* moves from index.html to js

* fix #66

* fix #48 first set of new icons

* Reorganize tools in left panel to be more intuitive

* Update button styles to adapt to new icons

* Fix #48 new set of icons for alignments

* Variabilisation of icon bkgd colors
Update of color choice to fit new icons design

* Update canvas and rulers colors

* Improve layer handle design

* Modernize SVG Logo but keeping original spirit

* Fix #48 continue improve icons

* Continue to reorganise left panel

* Update right panel handle for layers

* Fix #48 new set of icons for main menu

* Improve main menu design

* Rework menu organisation

* Rework menu organisation

* Update input element design

* New icons

* Improve Zoom Module

* Improve Color Picker Module

* New icons

* New icons

* #65 restore the feature of start/end marker lines partially did

* #64 The export dialog needs to include the quality options (except for PDF)

* #39 opacity button/stroke size/radius button don’t allow the 0 value

* #39 eslint changes

* #69 menu button style overwrite

* #65 restore the feature of start/end marker lines

* #43 With a small window, the look of the top toolbar is broken

* #43 tool top alignment revert

* #46 Move this jQuery component to a web component  for graduate and picker components

* #46 Move this jQuery component to a web component

* remove some non standard lint rules

* #46 picker convert as pure javascript changes

* #46 jquery plugin convert to pure javascript

* #46 jquery plugin change to pure javascript

* #46 jquery remove and convert to pure javascript

* #46 slider issue fixed

* #46 ColorValuePicker and js convertion

* #46 globals $ remov from slider class

* #46 jquery convert pure javascript changes

* #46 jquery to js convertion changes

* #46 paintbox and current element color set issue fixed

* #46 unwanted files removed

* #46 $.extend modify changes

* #46 extend modifiey changes

* #46 $.extend change to pure javascript

* #46 extend and data changes

* #46 jquery removed

* #45 These buttons don't work and dropdown is broken

* #45 These buttons don't work and dropdown is broken

* #45 These buttons don't work and dropdown is broken commit reverted

* #43 With a small window, the look of the top toolbar is broken

* Update jQuery.jPicker.js

* #76 draggable modification changes

* #76 jquery-ui-1.8.17.custom.min.js removed from editor

* #76 jquery ui file removed

* npm update

* #77 console issue fixed

* #77 <SVG> button issue fixed

* #77 shortkey issue fixed

* #77 jquery hotkeys plugin changes

* #77 hotkey plugin related changes

* #78 hotkey related code comment.

* #78 js-hotkeys/jquery.hotkeys.min.js file removed from svgedit.js

* #51 Rewrite the color palette without elix

* #81 unwanted files removed

* #81 folder name renamed

* #81 folder rename changes

* #81 jquery-ui  folder renamed

* #81 jquery modify changes

* #81 globals $ removed

* remove licence-badger (breaks ci)

* build

* fix tests

* fix folder spelling

* skip accessibility for now

* Update onpush.yml

* use npm dragmove

* #82 jquery convertion changes

* #82 javascript convertion changes

* #82 workarea related javascript convertion changes

* #82 javascript convertion cahnges

* #82 ungroup button added changes

* #82 menu unwanted code removed and button changes

* Update .gitignore

* refactor with Panel classes

* add MainMenu class

* move handlers

* fix lint

* fix test

Co-authored-by: Agriya Dev5 <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: mathieucura <[email protected]>
jfhenon pushed a commit that referenced this issue Mar 14, 2021
jfhenon pushed a commit that referenced this issue Mar 14, 2021
jfhenon added a commit that referenced this issue Mar 14, 2021
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

4 participants