-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 4
DellRAID
Our RAID disks are really Just a Bunch of Disks (JBOD) as it is easier to manage disks from the file system. ZFS and Linux RAID want to talk to the disks directly, and it's easier to move such disks around.
We've encapsulated all the m620 setup code
in idrac-m620-setup.sh, which is a sequence of
functions you can selectively execute, including idrac
.
RAID And Storage Configuration using RACADM Commands in iDRAC7 is a simple manual documenting the raid commands. RACADM Command Line Reference Guide for iDRAC7 1.50.50 and CMC 4.5 (p106) is the complete reference.
We first have to reset the RAID config:
$ idrac 1 storage resetconfig:RAID.Integrated.1-1
$ idrac 1 jobqueue create RAID.Integrated.1-1 -r pwrcycle -s TIME_NOW -e TIME_NA
After this completes, we'll follow ThornLabs instructions:
$ for p in $(idrac 1 raid get pdisks); do
idrac 1 raid createvd:RAID.Integrated.1-1 -rl r0 -wp wt -rp nra -ss 64k "-pdkey:$p"a
done
$ idrac 1 job RAID.Integrated.1-1
This sets up all the physical disks (pdisks) as independent virtual disks with RAID0 (r0), write through (wt), no read ahead (nra), and 64k strip size (seems what people recommend for SSDs).
Wait a bit and verify that the vdisks have been created:
$ idrac 1 raid get vdisks -o
Disk.Virtual.0:RAID.Integrated.1-1
Status = Ok
DeviceDescription = Virtual Disk 0 on Integrated RAID Controller 1
Name = Virtual Disk 0
RollupStatus = Ok
State = Online
OperationalState = Not applicable
Layout = Raid-0
Size = 931.00 GB
SpanDepth = 1
AvailableProtocols = SATA
MediaType = SSD
ReadPolicy = No Read Ahead
WritePolicy = Write Through
StripeSize = 64K
DiskCachePolicy = Enabled
BadBlocksFound = NO
Secured = NO
RemainingRedundancy = 0
EnhancedCache = Not Applicable
T10PIStatus = Disabled
BlockSizeInBytes = 512
See Issue 142 for detailed disussion.
Summary:
- H310 (non-RAID) controller is 20% faster than an S110 (motherboard).
- SSD performance varies wildly (2x)
- Luks and mdadm don't move the needle much
References on performance of hardware RAID vs madam:
- https://serverfault.com/a/685328
- http://en.community.dell.com/support-forums/servers/f/906/t/19475037
- https://delightlylinux.wordpress.com/2016/05/24/motherboard-raid-or-linux-mdadm-which-is-faster/
- https://linuxaria.com/pills/how-to-properly-use-dd-on-linux-to-benchmark-the-write-speed-of-your-disk
- https://romanrm.net/dd-benchmark
- https://linuxaria.com/pills/how-to-properly-use-dd-on-linux-to-benchmark-the-write-speed-of-your-disk
- https://www.dell.com/community/PowerEdge-HDD-SCSI-RAID/PE-T320-and-S110-RAID-10-Server-2012-Abysmal-Disk-Subsystem/td-p/4220489