Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Shared with me: Bad discoverability #7551

Closed
tbsbdr opened this issue Aug 30, 2022 · 10 comments
Closed

Shared with me: Bad discoverability #7551

tbsbdr opened this issue Aug 30, 2022 · 10 comments
Labels

Comments

@tbsbdr
Copy link

tbsbdr commented Aug 30, 2022

Steps to reproduce

  1. Albert is looking for the folder Video Archive 2017 which was shared with him by Marie, but he can't find the file in his Windows Explorer
  2. Albert opens Shares -> Shared with me and sees:

Screenshot 000356@2x

  1. Albert is overwhelmed by the 3 sections Pending shares, Accepted shares and Declined shares and does not understand what accept and decline mean.
  2. Albert finally finds the file Video Archive 2017 within "Pending shares" but cant open it

Expected behaviour

  • 1 List: Show only 1 single list as Albert expects this from other views
  • Replace Pending, Accept and Decline: Don't talk about pending, accepted or declined shares but just show all visible shares in the list
  • Action Hide share / Unhide share  Add option to hide shares so that irrelevant shares can get hidden; Hidden shares are not shown in the initial list.
  • Just open all files: All files can get opened regardless if they are hidden or not
  • Option Show hidden shares: Shows only hidden shares in "Shared with me"
  • Grouping: is currently a custom feature at CERN - proposal how it could be aligned with the Chip-style
StatusCurrentlyProposal oCISProposal oc10Desktop Client
Pending share"Pending shares""Shared with me" (like auto-accept)Legacy - use classic UI*Synced (default: VFS; fallback: selective sync)
Accepted share"Accepted shares""Shared with me""Shared with me"Synced (default: VFS; fallback: selective sync)
Declined share"Declined shares""Show hidden shares""Show hidden shares"not synced

* if "Automatically accept new incoming local user shares" is disabled, click on "Shared" (=sharing jail) navigates to "shared with me" in the classic ui

Initial view:

Hidden shares:

Actual behaviour

  • Concept of Pending / Accepting / Declining shares is hard to understand
  • 3 sections Pending shares, Accepted shares and Declined shares
  • unaccepted shares can't get viewed

--
Issue was first brought up / related: #7435 and was also reported by @elizavetaRa , @diocas - created a new issue to make it actionable.

@tbsbdr
Copy link
Author

tbsbdr commented Sep 6, 2022

update:

Discussed today with @hodyroff @kulmann @pmaier1 and others - there where no objections against removing the pending status in ocis. wording for the former "decline" action needs more research.

@diocas
Copy link
Contributor

diocas commented Sep 6, 2022

@tbsbdr I really like your mockups! But can we have the hide/unhide show in the quick actions in the row? Currently there are no actions (as opposed to your mockup), because users don't want to share from the share with me, I guess, but having the hide/unhide there would make it clear they can clean up.

@tbsbdr
Copy link
Author

tbsbdr commented Sep 7, 2022

It could be right to have "hide" in the quickactions but tbh I'm not sure if "hide" is amongst the ~ top 5 and most often used actions and thus should take a front seat in the quickactions (It is for your users as you say - but from a product perspective I'm currently 50/50 ). I'd like to decide this as soon as I got enough feedback on the new concept.

@diocas
Copy link
Contributor

diocas commented Sep 7, 2022

Since you have 0 other quick actions in this list, having 1 automatically makes it to the top 5 :)
It's more for discoverability, I believe users would benefit from knowing that the option exists.
just my 2cents

@dragotin
Copy link

dragotin commented May 5, 2023

AFAIK we agreed that we postpone this topic for now in favor of the collapsible tables PR (#8443) - so I will remove it from the project board.

@tbsbdr
Copy link
Author

tbsbdr commented Jun 12, 2023

relates to 11ad6f4
depends on owncloud/ocis#4834
also see elizas presentation august 2022

@tbsbdr
Copy link
Author

tbsbdr commented Jun 16, 2023

Cern: Hide ~ reject share

@tbsbdr tbsbdr added the Category:Enhancement Add new functionality label Jun 16, 2023
@tbsbdr
Copy link
Author

tbsbdr commented Jun 28, 2023

Question to @elizavetaRa
what happens, if you receive a share ex. 10GB - does the desktop client then sync the 10GB immediately?

@elizavetaRa
Copy link
Member

Here as in our mockups: there should be s "sync" button for each share, default of the share is not synced. The size is shown, so it's up to user to sync or not

@tbsbdr
Copy link
Author

tbsbdr commented Aug 3, 2023

closing in favour of more actionable ticket
Duplicate of #9531

@tbsbdr tbsbdr closed this as completed Aug 3, 2023
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

4 participants