es6-promise is not a safe polyfill to recommend in your readme

[nilliams]

es6-promise's strict spec handling of uncaught exceptions (by not doing so at all) is a footgun. I don't feel like it should be the default recommendation of polyfill, and personally is the reason I've kept my team away from fetch() for months. Here are examples why:

• http://requirebin.com/?gist=8f13d5147c1c252ab1691115bfa8b7c5
• http://requirebin.com/?gist=06e8c85fcaca56c9651c6aabd0d91476

Bluebird, however does the right thing:

• http://requirebin.com/?gist=43a3858fa57d9b94c00b2b454722c15d

I'm not saying Bluebird should be what you suggest instead, as I haven't dug into relative sizes/support/practicalities of that. I just feel that recommending people use es6-promise is going to cause a lot of people pain.

[ysmood]

I came from stefanpenner/es6-promise#70 (comment)

Maybe you could give Promise lib yaku a try.

Features

• The minified file is only 4.1KB (1.8KB gzipped)
• Supports "uncaught rejection" and "long stack trace", [Comparison][docs/debugHelperComparison.md]
• Designed to work on IE5+ and other major browsers
• 100% statement and branch test coverage
• Much better performance than the native Promise
• Well commented source code with every Promises/A+ spec

[nilliams]

Yaku looks excellent, and ticks all my personal boxes, thank you! I love the fact it's small and has passing test coverage too, seems like a good fit for alternative polyfill recommendation here!

I've been trying to pin this down even more, because when I actually hit it I felt it was way worse than I've actually demonstrated so far. And I remembered that even when you .catch() and re-throw, es6-promise does NOT surface the error/exception.

To me this is the most concrete example, where the developer is absolutely doing all the right things, and the error is STILL swallowed:

http://requirebin.com/?gist=9c59be0170fa7691a534705daf6b765d

And (now using Yaku as alternative), here's how you do it right:

http://requirebin.com/?gist=8e1d11f8754e58afd271a994760bb0c4

[ysmood]

If you have any problem with Yaku, please feel free to issue me. The project is quite active to user feedbacks now.

[ysmood]

Sad story.
On Sat, 22 Oct 2016 at 4:15 AM Nick Williams [email protected]
wrote:

To make matters even worse the author has now closed that issue thread, so
it's not even visible to people now that it's an issue:
stefanpenner/es6-promise#70
stefanpenner/es6-promise#70

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
#111 (comment),
or mute the thread
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABWZQLp0R61aNwevzCqx_ZT5o5rHv0ACks5q2R1wgaJpZM4Kbj6l
.

[developit]

I would recommend looking at promise-polyfill. I tested a bunch of polyfills and it's the smallest and I don't think it has that footgun.

[matthew-andrews]

This repo no longer recommends any polyfill.