Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
Restructure Documentation pt. 2 (#1659)
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
* making new files

* editing physics content and moving images

* error fixes and writing content

* basic spectrum and pyplot filepath

* more content and hyperlink fixes

* [build docs]

* making basic principles in terms of photons and fixing headings in propagation

* [build docs]

* [build docs]
  • Loading branch information
isaacgsmith authored Jun 23, 2021
1 parent d2bab39 commit 05f759a
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Showing 21 changed files with 356 additions and 192 deletions.
7 changes: 7 additions & 0 deletions docs/physics/est_and_conv/convergence.rst
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
.. _convergence:

***********
Convergence
***********

Coming soon.
25 changes: 24 additions & 1 deletion docs/physics/est_and_conv/index.rst
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -4,6 +4,29 @@
Estimators and Convergence
**************************

As light travels through a real plasma, it has effects on the properties of the plasma due to light-matter
interactions as well as the presence of extra energy from the light. Additionally, as :ref:`previously discussed
<propagation>`, properties of the plasma affect how light travels through it. Things like this (where two things
both affect each other on different ways) frequently occur in physics. The solution is finding a steady-state for
the plasma properties; that is, the actual plasma will be in a state such that the plasma state will not change as
light propagates through it, because the effects of the light on the plasma and the effects of the plasma on the
light have been "balenced out."

One of TARDIS's main goals is to determine this plasma state (as we need the actual plasma properties in order to
get an accurate spectrum). This is done in an iterative process. After each :ref:`Monte Carlo iteration
<montecarlo>` (which sends light through the supernova ejecta), TARDIS uses objects called estimators to determine
how the propagating light affects the plasma state, after which the plasma state is updated (as will be demonstrated
in the eatimators page linked below). We do this many times, and attempt to have the plasma state converge
to the steady-state we are looking for. In fact, all but the last Monte Carlo iteration is used for this purpose
(after which TARDIS will have the needed plasma state for its last iteration which calculates the spectrum).

.. note::
For all but the last iteration, TARDIS uses the number of Monte Carlo packets specified in the
:ref:`configuration file <montecarlo-config>` under the ``no_of_packets`` argument. This is because
a different number of packets may be necessary to calculate the spectrum as opposed to calculate the
plasma state.

.. toctree::

estimators
estimators
convergence
File renamed without changes
145 changes: 123 additions & 22 deletions docs/physics/montecarlo/basicprinciples.rst
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -4,25 +4,126 @@
Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer - Basic Principles
*************************************************

Radiative transfer describes how the properties of the electromagnetic
radiation field change as it propagates through an ambient material. Due to the
complex coupling induced by the many interactions the photons which constitute
the radiation field may perform with the surrounding material, solving the
radiative transfer problem is in most astrophysical cases only possible by
means of numerical calculations. While there are many different numerical
techniques available to tackle this, Monte Carlo techniques have become a
successful and elegant tool particularly for radiative transfer problems in
supernovae.

Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer methods are probabilistic techniques and draw
inspiration from the microscopical interpretation of how photons propagate
through and interact with the ambient material. A sufficiently large number of
representative "machine photons" are considered and their propagation history
solved in a stochastic process. The initial properties of these photons are
randomly (in a probabilistic sense) assigned in accordance with the macroscopic
properties of the radiation field (see :ref:`Energy Packets <initialization>`)
and in a similar manner the decisions about when, where and how the machine
photons interact with the surrounding material are made (see :ref:`Propagation
<propagation>`). If this process is repeated for a large enough number of machine
photons, the ensemble behaviour and thus the macroscopic evolution of the
radiation field is recovered (see :ref:`Estimators <estimators>`).
Radiative transfer describes how electromagnetic radiation (light) propagates through a medium. Since there are
a large number of light-matter interactions that have the possibility of affecting the light propagation, solving
the radiative transfer problem is in most astrophysical cases only possible by means of numerical calculations.
While there are many different numerical techniques available to tackle this, Monte Carlo techniques have become a
successful and elegant tool particularly for radiative transfer problems in supernovae.

Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer methods track a sufficiently large number of photons (light particles) as they
propagate through the supernova ejecta. The initial properties of these photons are randomly (in a probabilistic
sense) assigned in accordance with the macroscopic properties of the radiation field (see :ref:`initialization`)
and in a similar manner the decisions about when, where and how the photons interact with the surrounding material
are made (see :ref:`Propagation <propagation>`). Given a large enough sample, these photons behave as a microcosom
of all of the light traveling through the ejecta -- that is, based on the behavior of these photons, we can draw
conclusions about the propagation of light through the ejecta as a whole. This is eventually used to determine the
actual steady-state plasma properties (see :ref:`est_and_conv`) and the emitted spectrum (see :ref:`spectrum`).


.. _randomsampling:

Random Sampling Basics
======================

During both the initialization of these photons and their propagation through the ejecta are modeled through
probabilistic processes. This involves assigning probabilities to the occurrence of certain events or properties.
For example, during isotropic scattering, finding a photon scattering into any given direction is equally likely.
During the Monte Carlo simulation, assignments
according to these probabilities have to be frequently performed. For this purpose, so-called Random
Number Generators are available. These produce (pseudo-) random numbers
:math:`z` uniformly distributed on the interval :math:`[0,1]`. The challenge
now lies in using these numbers to sample any physical process involved in the
Radiative transfer calculation. From a probability theory point of view, this
just implies finding a mapping between the probability distribution governing the
physical process and the one underlying the Random Number Generator. This
process is typically referred to as random sampling.

Inverse transformation method
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.. note::
This is a very superficial and sloppy description of Random sampling. More
detailed and rigorous accounts are found in the standard literature, for
example in :cite:`Kalos2008`.

The simplest and most-used technique in Monte Carlo radiative transfer
applications is referred to as the inverse transformation method and involves
the cumulative distribution function. In general, a random process captured by
the random variable :math:`X` is governed by a probability density
:math:`\rho_X(x)` (the continuous counterpart to discrete probabilities), with
:math:`\rho_X(x) \mathrm{d}x` describing the probability of the variable taking
values in the interval :math:`[x, x+\mathrm{d}x]`. The cumulative distribution
function in turn describes, as the name suggests, the probability of the
variable taking any value between :math:`-\infty` and :math:`x`:

.. math::
f_X(x) = \int_{-\infty}^x \mathrm{d}x \rho_X(x)
Since the probability density is by definition always positive, the cumulative
distribution function is monotonically increasing. This constitutes the basis
for the inverse transformation function. Consider two random variables,
:math:`X` and :math:`Y`. A mapping between those may be established by equating
their cumulative distribution functions. Numbers :math:`y` distributed
according to one of the probability densities (in this case :math:`\rho_Y(y)`)
may then be used to sample the other process by

.. math::
x = f_X^{-1}\left(f_Y(y)\right).
For the Random Number Generators described above, the cumulative distribution
function is trivial, namely :math:`f_Z(z) = z`. However, the inverse
distribution sampling method relies on finding the analytic inverse function of
the cumulative distribution function governing the physical processes to be
sampled. If this is not possible, other sampling methods, such as von-Neumann
rejection sampling techniques, have to be used.

Examples
^^^^^^^^

A few examples are provided to illustrate the random sampling process using the
inverse transformation technique.

Isotropic Scattering
--------------------

Consider the case of an isotropic scattering.
Here, all scattering angles are equally likely. Thus, the corresponding
(normalized) probability density and the cumulative distribution function are given by

.. math::
\rho_{\mu}(\mu) &= \frac{1}{2}\\
f_{\mu}(\mu) &= \frac{1}{2} (\mu - 1).
This leads to the sampling rule

.. math::
\mu = 2 z - 1.
Next Interaction Location
-------------------------

The probability of a photon interacting after covering an optical depth
:math:`\tau` is given by (see :ref:`propagation`)

.. math::
\rho_{\tau}(\tau) &= \exp(-\tau)\\
f_{\tau}(\tau) &= 1 - \exp(-\tau).
With the inverse transformation method, the optical depth to the next interaction location may then be sampled by

.. math::
\tau = - \mathrm{ln}(1 - z)
which is equivalent to

.. math::
\tau = - \mathrm{ln}z.
14 changes: 9 additions & 5 deletions docs/physics/montecarlo/index.rst
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -4,6 +4,12 @@
Monte Carlo Iteration
*********************

After setting up the simulation, TARDIS runs the simulation using the ``.run()`` method. This runs several Monte
Carlo iterations (which will be described in the links below), corresponding to the number of iterations specified
in the :ref:`Monte Carlo Configuration <montecarlo-config>`. As will be decribed in :ref:`est_and_conv` and
:ref:`spectrum`, most of these iterations will eventually be used to calculate the steady-state plasma properties,
with the last iteration being used to determine the spectrum.

The following pages provide a very basic introduction to Monte Carlo radiative
transfer techniques as they are used in TARDIS. All the information listed here
can also be found in various papers by L. Lucy and in the main TARDIS publication
Expand All @@ -12,11 +18,9 @@ can also be found in various papers by L. Lucy and in the main TARDIS publicatio
:cite:`Kerzendorf2014`).

.. toctree::
:maxdepth: 2

basicprinciples
initialization
propagation
lineinteraction
estimators
virtualpackets
sourceintegration
randomsampling
lineinteraction
6 changes: 3 additions & 3 deletions docs/physics/montecarlo/initialization.ipynb
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -20,7 +20,7 @@
"metadata": {},
"source": [
"While it is instructive to think about tracking the propagation history of\n",
"photons when illustrating the basic idea behind Monte Carlo radiative transfer\n",
"individual photons when illustrating the basic idea behind Monte Carlo radiative transfer\n",
"techniques, there are important numerical reasons for using a different\n",
"discretization scheme. Instead of thinking in the photon picture, it brings\n",
"significant advantages to follow the idea of <strong data-cite=\"Abbott1985\">[]</strong> and\n",
Expand All @@ -29,7 +29,7 @@
"are commonly referred to as \"energy packets\" or simply \"packets\", and are composed of many photons with the same frequency.\n",
"\n",
"During a Monte Carlo calculation, $N$ (a large number) packets, all with a certain\n",
"energy $\\varepsilon$, are created at the inner boundary of the computational domain (as will be discussed in [Packet Propagation](propagation.rst)) known as the photosphere. Currently, the photosphere is modeled as a spherical blackbody with a radius $R_\\mathrm{phot}$ and temperature $T_\\mathrm{phot}$. In TARDIS, all packets are assigned identical energies, and the total energy of the packets is 1 erg (and thus each packet has an energy of $\\frac{1}{N}$ ergs).\n",
"energy $\\varepsilon$, are created at the inner boundary of the computational domain (which is discussed in [Model of Supernova Domain](../setup/model.rst)) known as the photosphere. Currently, the photosphere is modeled as a spherical blackbody with a radius $R_\\mathrm{phot}$ and temperature $T_\\mathrm{phot}$. In TARDIS, all packets are assigned identical energies, and the total energy of the packets is 1 erg (and thus each packet has an energy of $\\frac{1}{N}$ ergs).\n",
"\n",
".. note:: The indivisible energy packet scheme does not require that all packets have the same energy. This is just a convenient and simple choice adopted in TARDIS.\n",
"\n",
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -329,4 +329,4 @@
},
"nbformat": 4,
"nbformat_minor": 5
}
}
2 changes: 1 addition & 1 deletion docs/physics/montecarlo/lineinteraction.rst
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -96,5 +96,5 @@ shows the situation in the resonant scatter mode, the middle one for the
downbranching scheme and the right one the macro atom results.

.. image::
images/scatter_downbranch_ma.png
../images/scatter_downbranch_ma.png
:width: 700
Loading

0 comments on commit 05f759a

Please sign in to comment.