bug in 120 beats per minute, 1/12 beat value

[smurata]

@pikurasa
@walterbender

I tried 120 beats per minute, 1/12 beat value in the Japanese version.
The performance is not right.

https://youtu.be/R8KNPxm7VeM

[smurata]

@pikurasa
@walterbender

Sorry. The link above doesn't work.
Please try this.

https://youtu.be/R8KNPxm7VeM

[walterbender]

Can you please share the project itself. Would make debugging easier

[smurata]

bug test. BPM block.08.26.2019.zip

[pikurasa]

I did some tests (on Abrowser 65.0.1, 64 bit, Trisquel 8.0, Japanese Mode) and noticed the following:

(@smurata first I put all the action blocks into a instrument clamp to simplify the code)

2019-08-27.zip

1. Some notes, even in my simplified version do not play the specified instrument, "synthesizer" (シンセサイザー). It seems like ソ and the last シ are problematic. Actually, those notes are the longest notes, too.
2. Choosing 1/8 instead of 1/12 does not cause the issue in number 1 above
3. Choosing a different instrument, such as piano or guitar does not cause the same issue.

I suspect that the synthesizer sound is not being called for any note value greater than 1/12 for meter of 120 and beat value equal to 1/12. Some initial tests seem to prove this to be the case.

Hope that helps.

[walterbender]

I am able to play this with no problems. Are you sure you are using the version with my recent patch?

[walterbender]

What synth causes the problem?

[smurata]

@pikurasa
@walterbender

I opened the newest Music Block @pikurasa made. It is published on 'planet'. I downloaded it from there.

The denominator numbers of both beat value and note value cannot be changed.
The number of BPM cannot be changed.

Here is the demonstration.

https://youtu.be/NYkh_CCl9n8

[walterbender]

I don't know anything about "Devin's" version of Music Blocks. Please test with the master version. Also it would be helpful if you included console log output in your bug reports.

…

On Tue, Aug 27, 2019, 10:03 AM smurata ***@***.***> wrote: @pikurasa <https://github.com/pikurasa> @walterbender <https://github.com/walterbender> I opened the newest Music Block @pikurasa <https://github.com/pikurasa> made. It is published on 'planet'. I downloaded it from there. The denominator numbers of both beat value and note value cannot be changed. The number of BPM cannot be changed. Here is the demonstration. https://youtu.be/NYkh_CCl9n8 — You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#1842?email_source=notifications&email_token=AA6PXYO2VH6U7N35MLBTGWDQGUX3PA5CNFSM4IP2KYY2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOD5H27VQ#issuecomment-525316054>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AA6PXYJOZE6SHGMQO4CXFCTQGUX3PANCNFSM4IP2KYYQ> .

[pikurasa]

I don't know anything about "Devin's" version of Music Blocks.

@walterbender I do not have a separate version. I have a page that links to rawgit. Since the URL for rawgit is hard to memorize, I often send people to my page with the links, so that they can find the rawgit version easily.

If you see the URL at 21 seconds through Sachiko's video, you will see that she is testing from the Rawgit master.

Next time I test, I will copy the console.

[pikurasa]

Next time I test, I will copy the console.

The console is not working for me (yes, I know Shift-Ctl-J -- it just is not working in this version of Abrowser, which is the browser I use to test Japanese)

At any rate, it seems I put the wrong file for the "simplified version" above. Here is the simplified version (all action blocks contained within a single instrument block):

bug test. BPM block.08.26.2019-devin-simple.html.zip

I get the same results as Sachiko describes. Remember, it must be in Japanese mode.

[walterbender]

I tried in Japanese. Works fine for me. Is there a particular synth that triggers the issue?

My console log, FWIW:

c major
js/logo.js:8689 notes to play: C4 1/12
2js/utils/musicutils.js:93 c major
js/logo.js:8689 notes to play: D4 1/12
2js/utils/musicutils.js:93 c major
js/logo.js:8689 notes to play: E4 1/12
2js/utils/musicutils.js:93 c major
js/logo.js:8689 notes to play: G4 1/4
2js/utils/musicutils.js:93 c major
js/logo.js:8689 notes to play: A4 1/12
2js/utils/musicutils.js:93 c major
js/logo.js:8689 notes to play: G4 1/12
2js/utils/musicutils.js:93 c major
js/logo.js:8689 notes to play: F4 1/12
2js/utils/musicutils.js:93 c major
js/logo.js:8689 notes to play: B4 1/12
2js/utils/musicutils.js:93 c major
js/logo.js:8689 notes to play: G4 1/12
2js/utils/musicutils.js:93 c major
js/logo.js:8689 notes to play: B4 1/12

[walterbender]

Please reopen if this still happens. I cannot reproduce it.