[TC-MF-1.4] DUT abort in SendReportData function when Second Controller Commissions and read attribute

[praveenCY]

Problem

DUT aborts in SendReportData function when Second Controller completes commissioning and read attribute like FabricsList.

Steps:
[TC-MF-1.4] Node Behavior using BCM [DUT - Commissionee]

1. TH_CR1 starts a commissioning process with DUT_CE

2. If (PICS_MF_BCM) TH_CR1 opens a commissioning window on DUT_CE using a commissioning timeout of PIXIT_COMM_WIN seconds using BCM
   zcl AdministratorCommissioning OpenBasicCommissioningWindow 12344321 0 0 commissioningTimeout=500

3. TH_CR1 writes and reads the Basic Information Cluster’s NodeLabel mandatory attribute of DUT_CE
   zclwrite Basic UserLabel 12344321 0 0 TE5New
   zclread Basic UserLabel 12344321 0 0

4. TH_CR2 starts a commissioning process with DUT_CE
   connect -ip 192.168.1.111 20202021 12345678

5. TH_CR1 reads the list of Fabrics on DUT_CE
   zclread OperationalCredentials FabricsList 12344321 0 0

6. TH_CR2 reads the list of Fabrics on DUT_CE
   zclread OperationalCredentials FabricsList 12345678 0 0 ==> This fails and DUT abort happens

Logs : DUT_abort_log.txt

Proposed Solution

[mrjerryjohns]

Can you please provide full logs from both the DUT and and the controller?

[praveenCY]

Can you please provide full logs from both the DUT and and the controller?
is this not enough ? https://github.com/project-chip/connectedhomeip/files/7375918/DUT_abort_log.txt

[praveenCY]

Detailed log from Controller: LOCK-TC-MF-1.4.txt

[yunhanw-google]

I try this in master branch, and cannot reproduce this issue, what is the commit you are using?

[praveenCY]

I try this in master branch, and cannot reproduce this issue, what is the commit you are using?
Running on test_event_6 branch for TE6

commit 82bcd4e (HEAD -> test_event_6, origin/test_event_6)
Author: Damian Królik [email protected]
Date: Thu Sep 30 03:23:48 2021 +0200
[clusters] Fix scheduled actions in clusters (#10001)

One thing I noticed is that during this issue "new session is created during Fabricslist read" in Controller Side

[1634855905.718853][3320:3328] CHIP:IN: New secure session created for device 0x0000000000000385, key 4!!

[yunhanw-google]

I also cannot reproduce this in TE6 branch, any build option during compilation have you used?

[yunhanw-google]

TH_CR1 and TH_CR2 are residing in two different machine node? I am using two different node for testing.

[praveenCY]

Setup details
Two Raspberry Pi4 with TE6 image from https://drive.google.com/file/d/1HWF8JAQ8HEPTi-Hx3Ds9CFiPTUCYvX6x

• First pi4 Commission with chip-device-ctrl -n 9999 (chip-device-ctrl is pre-built and available with this Pi4)
  ubuntu@matter-te-6:~$ which chip-device-ctrl
  /home/ubuntu/.local/bin/chip-device-ctrl

• Second Pi4 with chip-device-ctrl -n 8888 (same location as above)

[praveenCY]

Tried the same TC with master branch

commit edc22bd (HEAD -> master, origin/master, origin/HEAD)
Author: Vivien Nicolas [email protected]
Date: Wed Oct 27 22:02:31 2021 +0200

Logs: LOCK-TC-MF-1.4-MasterFailureLog.txt

[praveenCY]

Closing this as this is not seen with master branch and open #11092 for the issue seen with master branch