Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

[share-dialog-redesign] III: Rename permissions #8751

Closed
hurradieweltgehtunter opened this issue Mar 30, 2023 · 0 comments · Fixed by #8876
Closed

[share-dialog-redesign] III: Rename permissions #8751

hurradieweltgehtunter opened this issue Mar 30, 2023 · 0 comments · Fixed by #8876
Assignees

Comments

@hurradieweltgehtunter
Copy link
Contributor

hurradieweltgehtunter commented Mar 30, 2023

This is a sub-task of #8743

This is mostly due to the german translations and the attempt for gender-neutral wording. It is quite hard to find a gender-neutral term representing permissions:

  • Bearbeiter/-in: looks clumsy
  • Bearbeiter / Bearbeiterin: too long
  • Bearbeitende Person: too long, not universally usable

There are multiple ideas and proposals. Here's what I collected so far.

Intermission

While collecting the permissions I stumbled upon the permission "Internal". This raised some questions which are explained in detail here: #8752

Proposal 1: Use verbs as describers

The idea is not to use person-focused but action-focused describers. This would circumvent the need for gender-neutral/gender-specific terms.

Pros

  • self-explanatory
  • future-proof
  • variable usage
  • ?

Cons

  • Adds (a little bit) more length to descriptors
  • ?

Sections

Folder - Share with people

Current english proposed new english current german new german new german subtitle
Viewer can view Betrachter kann betrachten Kann keine Änderungen vornehmen
Editor can edit Bearbeiter kann ändern Kann Änderungen vornehmen
Invite with custom permissions custom Mit benutzerdefinierten Rechten einladen Individuell

Folder - Share via link

Current english proposed new english current german proposed new german new german subtitle
Internal ? Intern ?
Viewer can view Betrachter kann betrachten Kann keine Änderungen vornehmen
Contributor can contribute Bearbeiter kann hinzufügen Kann betrachten und neue Inhalte hinzufügen
Editor can edit and delete Bearbeiter kann bearbeiten und löschen Kann Änderungen vornehmen
Uploader can upload Nur hochladen kann hochladen Kann nur hochladen

File - share via link

Current english proposed new english current german proposed new german new german subtitle
Internal ? Intern ?
Viewer can view Betrachter kann betrachten Kann keine Änderungen vornehmen
Editor can edit and delete Bearbeiter kann bearbeiten und löschen Kann Änderungen vornehmen

Spaces - Invite member

Current english proposed new english current german proposed new german new german subtitle
Viewer can view Betrachter kann betrachten Kann keine Änderungen vornehmen
Editor can edit and delete Bearbeiter kann bearbeiten und löschen Kann Änderungen vornehmen
Manager can manage Manager kann verwalten Kann administrative Änderungen vornehmen

Proposal 2: Use abstract describers

This proposal comes from a customer. The idea behind is to avoid using gender-specific terms.

Pros

  • gets rid of gender-specific terms
  • ?

Cons

  • adds another abstract layer in naming
  • names are not self-explanatory
  • ?

Sections

Share via link

Current english proposed new english current german proposed new german
Viewer Standard Betrachter Standard
Contributor Extended Beitragende Person Erweitert
Editor Custom Bearbeitende Person Individuell
Uploader Mailbox nur hochladen Briefkasten

grafik

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

2 participants