Test case: Support creating a zpool in a zpool #3484
Labels
Component: Test Suite
Indicates an issue with the test framework or a test case
Comments
This is, unfortunately, a known problem. You can't create a Z pool on/inside a(nother) Z pool. Cause is unknown as far as I know. There should be other issues regarding this 'somewhere'. |
|
OK, well, the zfs-tests seem to use it too, for example, it breaks on zfs-tests/tests/functional/cli_root/zpool_create/zpool_create_006_pos - (these are the Linux flavour of the tests), so I was thinking it would at least not hang. |
|
|
This in fact is the biggest reason we're not running the test suite on at least one of the automated builders. The zfs-test suite does do this but even under illumos it's not 100% deadlock free. It's just far less likely because they use a dynamic system_taskq to handle the IO which can have up to 64 threads. That makes a deadlock due to taskq ordering far far far less likely (but possible). That said I'd love to see this issue solved either by:
Coincidentally enough I'll be proposing patches either latter today or this week to add dynamic taskq support to ZoL. This should allow us to adapt the illumos way of handling this which may be good enough for most purposes. |
behlendorf
added
the
Component: Test Suite
behlendorf
changed the title
behlendorf
changed the title
behlendorf
added a commit
to behlendorf/zfs
that referenced
this issue
May 9, 2017
Enable additional test cases, in most cases this required a few minor modifications to the test scripts. In a few cases a real bug was uncovered and fixed. And in a handful of cases where pools are layered on pools the test case will be skipped until this is supported. Details below for each test case. * zpool_add_004_pos - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. * zpool_add_005_pos.ksh - Skip dumpadm portion of the test which isn't relevant for Linux. The find_vfstab_dev, find_mnttab_dev, and save_dump_dev functions were updated accordingly for Linux. * zpool_add_006_pos - Update test case such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Switch to truncate from mkfile to reduce space requirements and speed up the test case. * zpool_clear_001_pos - Speed up test case by filling filesystem to 25% capacity. * zpool_create_002_pos, zpool_create_004_pos - Use sparse files for file vdevs in order to avoid increasing the partition size. * zpool_create_006_pos - 6ba1ce9 allows raidz+mirror configs with similar redundancy. Updating the valid_args and forced_args cases. * zpool_create_008_pos - Disable overlapping partition portion. * zpool_create_011_neg - Fix to correctly create the extra partition. Modified zpool_vdev.c to use fstat64_blk() wrapper which includes the st_size even for block devices. * zpool_create_012_neg - Updated to properly find swap devices. * zpool_create_014_neg, zpool_create_015_neg - Updated to use swap_setup() and swap_cleanup() wrappers which do the right thing on Linux and Illumos. Removed '-n' option which successed under Linux due to differences in the inuse checks. * zpool_create_016_pos.ksh - Skipped test case isn't useful. * zpool_create_020_pos - Added missing / to cleanup() function. Remove cache file prior to test to ensure a clean environment and avoid false positives. * zpool_destroy_001_pos - Removed test case which creates a pool on a zvol. This is more likely to deadlock under Linux and has never been completely supported on any platform. * zpool_destroy_002_pos - 'zpool destroy -f' is unsupported on Linux. Mount point must not be busy in order to unmount them. * zfs_destroy_001_pos - Handle EBUSY error which can occur with volumes when racing with udev. * zpool_expand_001_pos, zpool_expand_003_neg - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. The test could be modified to use loopback devices but it would be preerable to use the test case as is for improved coverage. * zpool_export_004_pos - Updated test case to such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Normal file vdev under /var/tmp are fine. * zpool_import_all_001_pos - Updated to skip partition 1, which is known as slice 2, on Illumos. This prevents overwritting the default TESTPOOL which was causing the failure. * zpool_import_002_pos, zpool_import_012_pos - No changes needed. * zpool_remove_003_pos - No changes needed * zpool_upgrade_002_pos, zpool_upgrade_004_pos - Root cause addressed by upstream OpenZFS commit 3b7f360. * zpool_upgrade_007_pos - Disabled in test case due to known failure. Opened issue openzfs#6112 * zvol_misc_002_pos - Updated to to use ext2. * zvol_misc_001_neg, zvol_misc_003_neg, zvol_misc_004_pos, zvol_misc_005_neg, zvol_misc_006_pos - Moved to skip list, thesei test case could be updated to use Linux's crash dump facility. * zvol_swap_* - Updated to use swap_setup/swap_cleanup helpers. File creation switched from /tmp to /var/tmp. Enabled minimal useful tests for Linux, skip test cases which aren't applicable. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <[email protected]> Issue openzfs#3484 Issue openzfs#5634 Issue openzfs#2437 Issue openzfs#5202 Issue openzfs#4034 Issue openzfs#6095
behlendorf
added a commit
to behlendorf/zfs
that referenced
this issue
May 9, 2017
Enable additional test cases, in most cases this required a few minor modifications to the test scripts. In a few cases a real bug was uncovered and fixed. And in a handful of cases where pools are layered on pools the test case will be skipped until this is supported. Details below for each test case. * zpool_add_004_pos - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. * zpool_add_005_pos.ksh - Skip dumpadm portion of the test which isn't relevant for Linux. The find_vfstab_dev, find_mnttab_dev, and save_dump_dev functions were updated accordingly for Linux. * zpool_add_006_pos - Update test case such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Switch to truncate from mkfile to reduce space requirements and speed up the test case. * zpool_clear_001_pos - Speed up test case by filling filesystem to 25% capacity. * zpool_create_002_pos, zpool_create_004_pos - Use sparse files for file vdevs in order to avoid increasing the partition size. * zpool_create_006_pos - 6ba1ce9 allows raidz+mirror configs with similar redundancy. Updating the valid_args and forced_args cases. * zpool_create_008_pos - Disable overlapping partition portion. * zpool_create_011_neg - Fix to correctly create the extra partition. Modified zpool_vdev.c to use fstat64_blk() wrapper which includes the st_size even for block devices. * zpool_create_012_neg - Updated to properly find swap devices. * zpool_create_014_neg, zpool_create_015_neg - Updated to use swap_setup() and swap_cleanup() wrappers which do the right thing on Linux and Illumos. Removed '-n' option which successed under Linux due to differences in the inuse checks. * zpool_create_016_pos.ksh - Skipped test case isn't useful. * zpool_create_020_pos - Added missing / to cleanup() function. Remove cache file prior to test to ensure a clean environment and avoid false positives. * zpool_destroy_001_pos - Removed test case which creates a pool on a zvol. This is more likely to deadlock under Linux and has never been completely supported on any platform. * zpool_destroy_002_pos - 'zpool destroy -f' is unsupported on Linux. Mount point must not be busy in order to unmount them. * zfs_destroy_001_pos - Handle EBUSY error which can occur with volumes when racing with udev. * zpool_expand_001_pos, zpool_expand_003_neg - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. The test could be modified to use loopback devices but it would be preerable to use the test case as is for improved coverage. * zpool_export_004_pos - Updated test case to such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Normal file vdev under /var/tmp are fine. * zpool_import_all_001_pos - Updated to skip partition 1, which is known as slice 2, on Illumos. This prevents overwritting the default TESTPOOL which was causing the failure. * zpool_import_002_pos, zpool_import_012_pos - No changes needed. * zpool_remove_003_pos - No changes needed * zpool_upgrade_002_pos, zpool_upgrade_004_pos - Root cause addressed by upstream OpenZFS commit 3b7f360. * zpool_upgrade_007_pos - Disabled in test case due to known failure. Opened issue openzfs#6112 * zvol_misc_002_pos - Updated to to use ext2. * zvol_misc_001_neg, zvol_misc_003_neg, zvol_misc_004_pos, zvol_misc_005_neg, zvol_misc_006_pos - Moved to skip list, thesei test case could be updated to use Linux's crash dump facility. * zvol_swap_* - Updated to use swap_setup/swap_cleanup helpers. File creation switched from /tmp to /var/tmp. Enabled minimal useful tests for Linux, skip test cases which aren't applicable. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <[email protected]> Issue openzfs#3484 Issue openzfs#5634 Issue openzfs#2437 Issue openzfs#5202 Issue openzfs#4034 Issue openzfs#6095
behlendorf
added a commit
to behlendorf/zfs
that referenced
this issue
May 10, 2017
Enable additional test cases, in most cases this required a few minor modifications to the test scripts. In a few cases a real bug was uncovered and fixed. And in a handful of cases where pools are layered on pools the test case will be skipped until this is supported. Details below for each test case. * zpool_add_004_pos - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. * zpool_add_005_pos.ksh - Skip dumpadm portion of the test which isn't relevant for Linux. The find_vfstab_dev, find_mnttab_dev, and save_dump_dev functions were updated accordingly for Linux. * zpool_add_006_pos - Update test case such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Switch to truncate from mkfile to reduce space requirements and speed up the test case. * zpool_clear_001_pos - Speed up test case by filling filesystem to 25% capacity. * zpool_create_002_pos, zpool_create_004_pos - Use sparse files for file vdevs in order to avoid increasing the partition size. * zpool_create_006_pos - 6ba1ce9 allows raidz+mirror configs with similar redundancy. Updating the valid_args and forced_args cases. * zpool_create_008_pos - Disable overlapping partition portion. * zpool_create_011_neg - Fix to correctly create the extra partition. Modified zpool_vdev.c to use fstat64_blk() wrapper which includes the st_size even for block devices. * zpool_create_012_neg - Updated to properly find swap devices. * zpool_create_014_neg, zpool_create_015_neg - Updated to use swap_setup() and swap_cleanup() wrappers which do the right thing on Linux and Illumos. Removed '-n' option which successed under Linux due to differences in the inuse checks. * zpool_create_016_pos.ksh - Skipped test case isn't useful. * zpool_create_020_pos - Added missing / to cleanup() function. Remove cache file prior to test to ensure a clean environment and avoid false positives. * zpool_destroy_001_pos - Removed test case which creates a pool on a zvol. This is more likely to deadlock under Linux and has never been completely supported on any platform. * zpool_destroy_002_pos - 'zpool destroy -f' is unsupported on Linux. Mount point must not be busy in order to unmount them. * zfs_destroy_001_pos - Handle EBUSY error which can occur with volumes when racing with udev. * zpool_expand_001_pos, zpool_expand_003_neg - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. The test could be modified to use loopback devices but it would be preerable to use the test case as is for improved coverage. * zpool_export_004_pos - Updated test case to such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Normal file vdev under /var/tmp are fine. * zpool_import_all_001_pos - Updated to skip partition 1, which is known as slice 2, on Illumos. This prevents overwritting the default TESTPOOL which was causing the failure. * zpool_import_002_pos, zpool_import_012_pos - No changes needed. * zpool_remove_003_pos - No changes needed * zpool_upgrade_002_pos, zpool_upgrade_004_pos - Root cause addressed by upstream OpenZFS commit 3b7f360. * zpool_upgrade_007_pos - Disabled in test case due to known failure. Opened issue openzfs#6112 * zvol_misc_002_pos - Updated to to use ext2. * zvol_misc_001_neg, zvol_misc_003_neg, zvol_misc_004_pos, zvol_misc_005_neg, zvol_misc_006_pos - Moved to skip list, thesei test case could be updated to use Linux's crash dump facility. * zvol_swap_* - Updated to use swap_setup/swap_cleanup helpers. File creation switched from /tmp to /var/tmp. Enabled minimal useful tests for Linux, skip test cases which aren't applicable. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <[email protected]> Issue openzfs#3484 Issue openzfs#5634 Issue openzfs#2437 Issue openzfs#5202 Issue openzfs#4034 Issue openzfs#6095
behlendorf
added a commit
to behlendorf/zfs
that referenced
this issue
May 11, 2017
Enable additional test cases, in most cases this required a few minor modifications to the test scripts. In a few cases a real bug was uncovered and fixed. And in a handful of cases where pools are layered on pools the test case will be skipped until this is supported. Details below for each test case. * zpool_add_004_pos - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. * zpool_add_005_pos.ksh - Skip dumpadm portion of the test which isn't relevant for Linux. The find_vfstab_dev, find_mnttab_dev, and save_dump_dev functions were updated accordingly for Linux. Add O_EXCL to the in-use check to prevent the -f (force) option from working for mounted filesystems and improve the resulting error. * zpool_add_006_pos - Update test case such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Switch to truncate from mkfile to reduce space requirements and speed up the test case. * zpool_clear_001_pos - Speed up test case by filling filesystem to 25% capacity. * zpool_create_002_pos, zpool_create_004_pos - Use sparse files for file vdevs in order to avoid increasing the partition size. * zpool_create_006_pos - 6ba1ce9 allows raidz+mirror configs with similar redundancy. Updating the valid_args and forced_args cases. * zpool_create_008_pos - Disable overlapping partition portion. * zpool_create_011_neg - Fix to correctly create the extra partition. Modified zpool_vdev.c to use fstat64_blk() wrapper which includes the st_size even for block devices. * zpool_create_012_neg - Updated to properly find swap devices. * zpool_create_014_neg, zpool_create_015_neg - Updated to use swap_setup() and swap_cleanup() wrappers which do the right thing on Linux and Illumos. Removed '-n' option which successed under Linux due to differences in the inuse checks. * zpool_create_016_pos.ksh - Skipped test case isn't useful. * zpool_create_020_pos - Added missing / to cleanup() function. Remove cache file prior to test to ensure a clean environment and avoid false positives. * zpool_destroy_001_pos - Removed test case which creates a pool on a zvol. This is more likely to deadlock under Linux and has never been completely supported on any platform. * zpool_destroy_002_pos - 'zpool destroy -f' is unsupported on Linux. Mount point must not be busy in order to unmount them. * zfs_destroy_001_pos - Handle EBUSY error which can occur with volumes when racing with udev. * zpool_expand_001_pos, zpool_expand_003_neg - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. The test could be modified to use loopback devices but it would be preerable to use the test case as is for improved coverage. * zpool_export_004_pos - Updated test case to such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Normal file vdev under /var/tmp are fine. * zpool_import_all_001_pos - Updated to skip partition 1, which is known as slice 2, on Illumos. This prevents overwritting the default TESTPOOL which was causing the failure. * zpool_import_002_pos, zpool_import_012_pos - No changes needed. * zpool_remove_003_pos - No changes needed * zpool_upgrade_002_pos, zpool_upgrade_004_pos - Root cause addressed by upstream OpenZFS commit 3b7f360. * zpool_upgrade_007_pos - Disabled in test case due to known failure. Opened issue openzfs#6112 * zvol_misc_002_pos - Updated to to use ext2. * zvol_misc_001_neg, zvol_misc_003_neg, zvol_misc_004_pos, zvol_misc_005_neg, zvol_misc_006_pos - Moved to skip list, thesei test case could be updated to use Linux's crash dump facility. * zvol_swap_* - Updated to use swap_setup/swap_cleanup helpers. File creation switched from /tmp to /var/tmp. Enabled minimal useful tests for Linux, skip test cases which aren't applicable. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <[email protected]> Issue openzfs#3484 Issue openzfs#5634 Issue openzfs#2437 Issue openzfs#5202 Issue openzfs#4034 Issue openzfs#6095
behlendorf
added a commit
to behlendorf/zfs
that referenced
this issue
May 11, 2017
Enable additional test cases, in most cases this required a few minor modifications to the test scripts. In a few cases a real bug was uncovered and fixed. And in a handful of cases where pools are layered on pools the test case will be skipped until this is supported. Details below for each test case. * zpool_add_004_pos - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. * zpool_add_005_pos.ksh - Skip dumpadm portion of the test which isn't relevant for Linux. The find_vfstab_dev, find_mnttab_dev, and save_dump_dev functions were updated accordingly for Linux. Add O_EXCL to the in-use check to prevent the -f (force) option from working for mounted filesystems and improve the resulting error. * zpool_add_006_pos - Update test case such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Switch to truncate from mkfile to reduce space requirements and speed up the test case. * zpool_clear_001_pos - Speed up test case by filling filesystem to 25% capacity. * zpool_create_002_pos, zpool_create_004_pos - Use sparse files for file vdevs in order to avoid increasing the partition size. * zpool_create_006_pos - 6ba1ce9 allows raidz+mirror configs with similar redundancy. Updating the valid_args and forced_args cases. * zpool_create_008_pos - Disable overlapping partition portion. * zpool_create_011_neg - Fix to correctly create the extra partition. Modified zpool_vdev.c to use fstat64_blk() wrapper which includes the st_size even for block devices. * zpool_create_012_neg - Updated to properly find swap devices. * zpool_create_014_neg, zpool_create_015_neg - Updated to use swap_setup() and swap_cleanup() wrappers which do the right thing on Linux and Illumos. Removed '-n' option which successed under Linux due to differences in the inuse checks. * zpool_create_016_pos.ksh - Skipped test case isn't useful. * zpool_create_020_pos - Added missing / to cleanup() function. Remove cache file prior to test to ensure a clean environment and avoid false positives. * zpool_destroy_001_pos - Removed test case which creates a pool on a zvol. This is more likely to deadlock under Linux and has never been completely supported on any platform. * zpool_destroy_002_pos - 'zpool destroy -f' is unsupported on Linux. Mount point must not be busy in order to unmount them. * zfs_destroy_001_pos - Handle EBUSY error which can occur with volumes when racing with udev. * zpool_expand_001_pos, zpool_expand_003_neg - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. The test could be modified to use loopback devices but it would be preerable to use the test case as is for improved coverage. * zpool_export_004_pos - Updated test case to such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Normal file vdev under /var/tmp are fine. * zpool_import_all_001_pos - Updated to skip partition 1, which is known as slice 2, on Illumos. This prevents overwritting the default TESTPOOL which was causing the failure. * zpool_import_002_pos, zpool_import_012_pos - No changes needed. * zpool_remove_003_pos - No changes needed * zpool_upgrade_002_pos, zpool_upgrade_004_pos - Root cause addressed by upstream OpenZFS commit 3b7f360. * zpool_upgrade_007_pos - Disabled in test case due to known failure. Opened issue openzfs#6112 * zvol_misc_002_pos - Updated to to use ext2. * zvol_misc_001_neg, zvol_misc_003_neg, zvol_misc_004_pos, zvol_misc_005_neg, zvol_misc_006_pos - Moved to skip list, thesei test case could be updated to use Linux's crash dump facility. * zvol_swap_* - Updated to use swap_setup/swap_cleanup helpers. File creation switched from /tmp to /var/tmp. Enabled minimal useful tests for Linux, skip test cases which aren't applicable. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <[email protected]> Issue openzfs#3484 Issue openzfs#5634 Issue openzfs#2437 Issue openzfs#5202 Issue openzfs#4034 Issue openzfs#6095
behlendorf
added a commit
that referenced
this issue
May 11, 2017
Enable additional test cases, in most cases this required a few minor modifications to the test scripts. In a few cases a real bug was uncovered and fixed. And in a handful of cases where pools are layered on pools the test case will be skipped until this is supported. Details below for each test case. * zpool_add_004_pos - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. * zpool_add_005_pos.ksh - Skip dumpadm portion of the test which isn't relevant for Linux. The find_vfstab_dev, find_mnttab_dev, and save_dump_dev functions were updated accordingly for Linux. Add O_EXCL to the in-use check to prevent the -f (force) option from working for mounted filesystems and improve the resulting error. * zpool_add_006_pos - Update test case such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Switch to truncate from mkfile to reduce space requirements and speed up the test case. * zpool_clear_001_pos - Speed up test case by filling filesystem to 25% capacity. * zpool_create_002_pos, zpool_create_004_pos - Use sparse files for file vdevs in order to avoid increasing the partition size. * zpool_create_006_pos - 6ba1ce9 allows raidz+mirror configs with similar redundancy. Updating the valid_args and forced_args cases. * zpool_create_008_pos - Disable overlapping partition portion. * zpool_create_011_neg - Fix to correctly create the extra partition. Modified zpool_vdev.c to use fstat64_blk() wrapper which includes the st_size even for block devices. * zpool_create_012_neg - Updated to properly find swap devices. * zpool_create_014_neg, zpool_create_015_neg - Updated to use swap_setup() and swap_cleanup() wrappers which do the right thing on Linux and Illumos. Removed '-n' option which succeeds under Linux due to differences in the in-use checks. * zpool_create_016_pos.ksh - Skipped test case isn't useful. * zpool_create_020_pos - Added missing / to cleanup() function. Remove cache file prior to test to ensure a clean environment and avoid false positives. * zpool_destroy_001_pos - Removed test case which creates a pool on a zvol. This is more likely to deadlock under Linux and has never been completely supported on any platform. * zpool_destroy_002_pos - 'zpool destroy -f' is unsupported on Linux. Mount point must not be busy in order to unmount them. * zfs_destroy_001_pos - Handle EBUSY error which can occur with volumes when racing with udev. * zpool_expand_001_pos, zpool_expand_003_neg - Skip test on Linux until adding zvols to pools is fully supported and deadlock free. The test could be modified to use loop-back devices but it would be preferable to use the test case as is for improved coverage. * zpool_export_004_pos - Updated test case to such that it doesn't depend on nested pools. Normal file vdev under /var/tmp are fine. * zpool_import_all_001_pos - Updated to skip partition 1, which is known as slice 2, on Illumos. This prevents overwriting the default TESTPOOL which was causing the failure. * zpool_import_002_pos, zpool_import_012_pos - No changes needed. * zpool_remove_003_pos - No changes needed * zpool_upgrade_002_pos, zpool_upgrade_004_pos - Root cause addressed by upstream OpenZFS commit 3b7f360. * zpool_upgrade_007_pos - Disabled in test case due to known failure. Opened issue #6112 * zvol_misc_002_pos - Updated to to use ext2. * zvol_misc_001_neg, zvol_misc_003_neg, zvol_misc_004_pos, zvol_misc_005_neg, zvol_misc_006_pos - Moved to skip list, these test case could be updated to use Linux's crash dump facility. * zvol_swap_* - Updated to use swap_setup/swap_cleanup helpers. File creation switched from /tmp to /var/tmp. Enabled minimal useful tests for Linux, skip test cases which aren't applicable. Reviewed-by: Giuseppe Di Natale <[email protected]> Reviewed-by: loli10K <[email protected]> Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <[email protected]> Issue #3484 Issue #5634 Issue #2437 Issue #5202 Issue #4034 Closes #6095
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Distro: Ubuntu 15.04
Kernel: 3.19.0-18-generic
ZFS: 0.6.4.1
Creating a zpool with mirror, raidz1 and raidz2 vdevs hangs when the vdevs are inside a larger zfs filesystem. The zpool create just hangs indefinitely and after 2 minutes I see a hung task message.
Example output:
Below is the script that can reproduce the problem:
Below is the kernel log:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: