Authorize rest requests (#2753)

* WIP on rest layer authz Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * WIP on rest-layer authz Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Extension handshake Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Extension TLS Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Remove SecurityRestFilterChanges to isolate extension TLS change Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Remove SecurityRestFilterChanges to isolate extension TLS change Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Remove SecurityRestFilterChanges to isolate extension TLS change Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Remove SecurityRestFilterChanges to isolate extension TLS change Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Remove SecurityRestFilterChanges to isolate extension TLS change Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * WIP for HelloWorld sample extension role Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Initial implementation of authz check in REST layer Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Remove header Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Create authorizeRequest method Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * small fix Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Change to ProtectedRoute Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Remove extension permissions Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Initial implementation of authz check in REST layer Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Extension TLS Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> * Adds dummy roles for testing rest authorization against legacy permissions Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Adds support for legacy permissions to perform rest authorization Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes white-space changes Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Rebases ConfigConstants with main Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Implements a new logic for rest permissions check to be more flexible Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes spotless errors Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Adds regex to match against current role permissions when comparing new permission with legacy ones Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Moves legacy permission check logic to ConfigModelV7 Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes extra new-lines Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes unused imports Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes out-of-scope white space changes Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes code-ql errors Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes spotless and code-ql errors Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes variable name and remove references to whitelist in javadoc Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Adds tests for rest layer privilege evaluator Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Adds license header to the test file Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Updates zstd dependency to fetch from core version.properties Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Updates action name in the regex to be dynamic Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Adds support for allowing evaluation against multiple actions names for a registered named route Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Updates tests Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Adds null check Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Makes authorize logic clearer to follow Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Adds extra check to ensure new actions are also evaluated against transport actions Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes spotless errors Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes security rest filter setup Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Removes extension reference Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * turn on audit logging Signed-off-by: Maciej Mierzwa <[email protected]> * Adds unit tests for restPathMatches method Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Cleans up TODOs Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Organizes demo users and roles for extension Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Address PR feedback Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Adds more comments Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * add privileges info Signed-off-by: Maciej Mierzwa <[email protected]> * Makes whoami action a named route and fixes license header check Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Adds integ tests for whoami route Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Change permissions order in roles.yml Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Adds developer documentation for authorization in REST layer Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes broken tests Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes checkstyle errors Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Addresses feedback and cleans up logic for super admin check Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Addresses Plugin Install CI failure Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Fixes failing citest task Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Modifies WhoAmI integ tests Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Adds a new endpoint called whoamiprotected and removes changes made to whoami route Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Updates documentation to reflect the new API Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Addresses PR feedback Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> * Renames action0 to actions Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> --------- Signed-off-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> Signed-off-by: Darshit Chanpura <[email protected]> Signed-off-by: Maciej Mierzwa <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Craig Perkins <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: MaciejMierzwa <[email protected]>
opensearch-project · Jul 7, 2023 · a53a8a6 · a53a8a6
1 parent 49cbf52
commit a53a8a6
Show file tree

Hide file tree

Showing 14 changed files with 795 additions and 24 deletions.
diff --git a/DEVELOPER_GUIDE.md b/DEVELOPER_GUIDE.md
@@ -10,6 +10,7 @@ So you want to contribute code to OpenSearch Security? Excellent! We're glad you
   - [Running integration tests](#running-integration-tests)
     - [Bulk test runs](#bulk-test-runs)
     - [Checkstyle Violations](#checkstyle-violations)
+  - [Authorization in REST Layer](#authorization-in-rest-layer)
   - [Submitting Changes](#submitting-changes)
   - [Backports](#backports)
 
@@ -78,6 +79,51 @@ mv config/* $OPENSEARCH_HOME/config/opensearch-security/
 rm -rf config/
 ```
 
+### Installing demo extension users and roles
+
+If you are working with an extension and want to set up demo users for the Hello-World extension, append following items to files inside `$OPENSEARCH_HOME/config/opensearch-security/`:
+1. In **internal_users.yml**
+```yaml
+hw-user:
+  hash: "$2a$12$VcCDgh2NDk07JGN0rjGbM.Ad41qVR/YFJcgHp0UGns5JDymv..TOG"
+  reserved: true
+  description: "Demo user for ext-test"
+```
+
+2. In **roles.yml**
+```yaml
+extension_hw_greet:
+  reserved: true
+  cluster_permissions:
+    - 'hw:greet'
+
+extension_hw_full:
+  reserved: true
+  cluster_permissions:
+    - 'hw:goodbye'
+    - 'hw:greet'
+    - 'hw:greet_with_adjective'
+    - 'hw:greet_with_name'
+
+legacy_hw_greet_with_name:
+  reserved: true
+  cluster_permissions:
+    - 'cluster:admin/opensearch/hw/greet_with_name'
+```
+
+3. In **roles_mapping.yml**
+```yaml
+legacy_hw_greet_with_name:
+  reserved: true
+  users:
+    - "hw-user"
+
+extension_hw_greet:
+  reserved: true
+  users:
+    - "hw-user"
+```
+
 To install the demo certificates and default configuration, answer `y` to the first two questions and `n` to the last one. The log should look like below:
 
 ```bash
@@ -188,6 +234,11 @@ Checkstyle enforces several rules within this codebase. Sometimes it will be nec
   // CS-ENFORCE-ALL
 ```
 
+## Authorization in REST Layer
+
+See [REST_AUTHZ_FOR_PLUGINS](REST_AUTHZ_FOR_PLUGINS.md).
+
+
 ## Submitting Changes
 
 See [CONTRIBUTING](CONTRIBUTING.md).

diff --git a/REST_AUTHZ_FOR_PLUGINS.md b/REST_AUTHZ_FOR_PLUGINS.md
@@ -0,0 +1,136 @@
+# Authorization at REST Layer for plugins
+
+This feature is introduced as an added layer of security on top of existing TransportLayer authorization framework. In order to leverage these feature some core changes need to be made at Route registration level. This document talks about how you can achieve this.
+
+**NOTE:** This doesn't replace Transport Layer Authorization. Plugin developers may choose to skip creating transport actions for APIs that do not need interaction with the Transport Layer.
+
+## Pre-requisites
+
+The security plugin must be installed and operational in your OpenSearch cluster for this feature to work.
+
+### How does NamedRoute authorization work?
+
+Once the routes are defined as NamedRoute, they, along-with their handlers, will be registered the same way as Route objects. When a request comes in, `SecurityRestFilter.java` applies an authorization check which extracts information about the NamedRoute.
+Next we get the unique name and actionNames associated with that route and evaluate these against existing `cluster_permissions` across all roles of the requesting user. If the authorization check succeeds, the request chain proceeds as normal. If it fails, a 401 response is returned to the user.
+
+NOTE:
+1. The action names defined in roles must exactly match the names of registered routes, or else, the request would be deemed unauthorized.
+2. This check will not be implemented for plugins who do not use NamedRoutes.
+
+
+
+### How to translate an existing Route to be a NamedRoute?
+
+Here is a sample of an existing route converted to a named route:
+Before:
+```
+public List<Route> routes() {
+    return ImmutableList.of(
+            new Route(GET, "/uri")
+        );
+}
+```
+With new scheme:
+```
+public List<NamedRoute> routes() {
+    return ImmutableList.of(
+            new NamedRoute.Builder().method(GET).path("/uri").uniqueName("plugin:uri").actionNames(Set.of("cluster:admin/opensearch/plugin/uri")).build()
+        );
+}
+```
+
+`actionNames()` are optional. They correspond to any current actions defined as permissions in roles.
+Ensure that these name-to-route mappings are easily accessible to the cluster admins to allow granting access to these APIs.
+
+### How does authorization in the REST Layer work?
+
+We will continue on the above example of translating `/uri` from Route to NamedRoute.
+
+Consider these roles are defined in the cluster:
+```yaml
+plugin_role:
+  reserved: true
+  cluster_permissions:
+    - 'plugin:uri'
+
+plugin_role_legacy:
+  reserved: true
+  cluster_permissions:
+    - 'cluster:admin/opensearch/plugin/uri'
+```
+
+Successful authz scenarios for a user:
+1. The user is mapped either to `plugin_role` OR `plugin_role_legacy`.
+2. The user is mapped to both of these roles.
+3. The user is mapped to `plugin_role` even if no `actionNames()` were registered for this route.
+
+Unsuccessful authz scenarios for a user:
+1. The user is not mapped any roles.
+2. The user is mapped to a different role which doesn't grant the cluster permissions: `plugin:uri` OR `cluster:admin/opensearch/plugin/uri`/
+3. The user is mapped to a role `plugin_role_other` which has a typo in action name, i.e.`plugin:uuri`.
+
+
+### Sample API in Security Plugin
+
+As part of this effort a new uri `GET /whoamiprotected` was introduced as a NamedRoute version of `GET /whoami`. Here is how you can test it:
+
+#### roles.yml
+```yaml
+who_am_i_role:
+  reserved: true
+  cluster_permissions:
+    - 'security:whoamiprotected'
+
+who_am_i_role_legacy:
+  reserved: true
+  cluster_permissions:
+    - 'cluster:admin/opendistro_security/whoamiprotected'
+
+who_am_i_role_no_perm:
+  reserved: true
+  cluster_permissions:
+    - 'some_invalid_perm'
+
+```
+
+#### internal_users.yml
+```yaml
+who_am_i-user:
+  hash: "$2a$12$VcCDgh2NDk07JGN0rjGbM.Ad41qVR/YFJcgHp0UGns5JDymv..TOG" #admin
+  reserved: true
+  description: "Demo user for ext-test"
+
+who_am_i_legacy-user:
+  hash: "$2a$12$VcCDgh2NDk07JGN0rjGbM.Ad41qVR/YFJcgHp0UGns5JDymv..TOG"
+  reserved: true
+  description: "Demo user for ext-test"
+
+who_am_i_no_perm-user:
+  hash: "$2a$12$VcCDgh2NDk07JGN0rjGbM.Ad41qVR/YFJcgHp0UGns5JDymv..TOG"
+  reserved: true
+  description: "Demo user for ext-test"
+```
+
+#### roles_mapping.yml
+```yaml
+who_am_i_role:
+  reserved: true
+  users:
+    - "who_am_i-user"
+
+who_am_i_role_legacy:
+  reserved: true
+  users:
+    - "who_am_i_legacy-user"
+
+who_am_i_role_no_perm:
+  reserved: true
+  users:
+    - "who_am_i_no_perm-user"
+```
+
+Follow [DEVELOPER_GUIDE](DEVELOPER_GUIDE.md) to setup OpenSearch cluster and initialize security plugin. Once you have verified that security plugin is installed correctly and OpenSearch is running, execute following curl requests:
+1. `curl -XGET https://who_am_i-user:admin@localhost:9200/_plugins/_security/whoami --insecure` should succeed.
+2. `curl -XGET https://who_am_i_legacy-user:admin@localhost:9200/_plugins/_security/whoami --insecure` should succeed.
+3. `curl -XGET https://who_am_i_no-perm-user:admin@localhost:9200/_plugins/_security/whoami --insecure` should fail.
+4. `curl -XPOST ` to `/whoami` with all 3 users should succeed. This is because POST route is not a NamedRoute and hence no authorization check was made.
diff --git a/src/integrationTest/java/org/opensearch/security/rest/WhoAmITests.java b/src/integrationTest/java/org/opensearch/security/rest/WhoAmITests.java
@@ -0,0 +1,107 @@
+/*
+* SPDX-License-Identifier: Apache-2.0
+*
+* The OpenSearch Contributors require contributions made to
+* this file be licensed under the Apache-2.0 license or a
+* compatible open source license.
+*
+* Modifications Copyright OpenSearch Contributors. See
+* GitHub history for details.
+*/
+
+package org.opensearch.security.rest;
+
+import com.carrotsearch.randomizedtesting.annotations.ThreadLeakScope;
+import org.apache.hc.core5.http.HttpStatus;
+import org.junit.ClassRule;
+import org.junit.Test;
+import org.junit.runner.RunWith;
+import org.opensearch.test.framework.TestSecurityConfig;
+import org.opensearch.test.framework.TestSecurityConfig.Role;
+import org.opensearch.test.framework.cluster.ClusterManager;
+import org.opensearch.test.framework.cluster.LocalCluster;
+import org.opensearch.test.framework.cluster.TestRestClient;
+
+import static org.hamcrest.MatcherAssert.assertThat;
+import static org.hamcrest.Matchers.equalTo;
+import static org.opensearch.test.framework.TestSecurityConfig.AuthcDomain.AUTHC_HTTPBASIC_INTERNAL;
+
+@RunWith(com.carrotsearch.randomizedtesting.RandomizedRunner.class)
+@ThreadLeakScope(ThreadLeakScope.Scope.NONE)
+public class WhoAmITests {
+    protected final static TestSecurityConfig.User WHO_AM_I = new TestSecurityConfig.User("who_am_i_user").roles(
+        new Role("who_am_i_role").clusterPermissions("security:whoamiprotected")
+    );
+
+    protected final static TestSecurityConfig.User WHO_AM_I_LEGACY = new TestSecurityConfig.User("who_am_i_user_legacy").roles(
+        new Role("who_am_i_role_legacy").clusterPermissions("cluster:admin/opendistro_security/whoamiprotected")
+    );
+
+    protected final static TestSecurityConfig.User WHO_AM_I_NO_PERM = new TestSecurityConfig.User("who_am_i_user_no_perm").roles(
+        new Role("who_am_i_role_no_perm")
+    );
+
+    protected final static TestSecurityConfig.User WHO_AM_I_UNREGISTERED = new TestSecurityConfig.User("who_am_i_user_no_perm");
+
+    public static final String WHOAMI_ENDPOINT = "_plugins/_security/whoami";
+    public static final String WHOAMI_PROTECTED_ENDPOINT = "_plugins/_security/whoamiprotected";
+
+    @ClassRule
+    public static LocalCluster cluster = new LocalCluster.Builder().clusterManager(ClusterManager.THREE_CLUSTER_MANAGERS)
+        .authc(AUTHC_HTTPBASIC_INTERNAL)
+        .users(WHO_AM_I, WHO_AM_I_LEGACY, WHO_AM_I_NO_PERM)
+        .build();
+
+    @Test
+    public void testWhoAmIWithGetPermissions() throws Exception {
+        try (TestRestClient client = cluster.getRestClient(WHO_AM_I)) {
+            assertThat(client.get(WHOAMI_PROTECTED_ENDPOINT).getStatusCode(), equalTo(HttpStatus.SC_OK));
+        }
+
+        try (TestRestClient client = cluster.getRestClient(WHO_AM_I)) {
+            assertThat(client.get(WHOAMI_ENDPOINT).getStatusCode(), equalTo(HttpStatus.SC_OK));
+        }
+    }
+
+    @Test
+    public void testWhoAmIWithGetPermissionsLegacy() throws Exception {
+        try (TestRestClient client = cluster.getRestClient(WHO_AM_I_LEGACY)) {
+            assertThat(client.get(WHOAMI_ENDPOINT).getStatusCode(), equalTo(HttpStatus.SC_OK));
+        }
+
+        try (TestRestClient client = cluster.getRestClient(WHO_AM_I_LEGACY)) {
+            assertThat(client.get(WHOAMI_PROTECTED_ENDPOINT).getStatusCode(), equalTo(HttpStatus.SC_OK));
+        }
+    }
+
+    @Test
+    public void testWhoAmIWithoutGetPermissions() throws Exception {
+        try (TestRestClient client = cluster.getRestClient(WHO_AM_I_NO_PERM)) {
+            assertThat(client.get(WHOAMI_ENDPOINT).getStatusCode(), equalTo(HttpStatus.SC_OK));
+        }
+
+        try (TestRestClient client = cluster.getRestClient(WHO_AM_I_NO_PERM)) {
+            assertThat(client.get(WHOAMI_PROTECTED_ENDPOINT).getStatusCode(), equalTo(HttpStatus.SC_UNAUTHORIZED));
+        }
+    }
+
+    @Test
+    public void testWhoAmIPost() throws Exception {
+        try (TestRestClient client = cluster.getRestClient(WHO_AM_I)) {
+            assertThat(client.post(WHOAMI_ENDPOINT).getStatusCode(), equalTo(HttpStatus.SC_OK));
+        }
+
+        try (TestRestClient client = cluster.getRestClient(WHO_AM_I_LEGACY)) {
+            assertThat(client.post(WHOAMI_ENDPOINT).getStatusCode(), equalTo(HttpStatus.SC_OK));
+        }
+
+        try (TestRestClient client = cluster.getRestClient(WHO_AM_I_NO_PERM)) {
+            assertThat(client.post(WHOAMI_ENDPOINT).getStatusCode(), equalTo(HttpStatus.SC_OK));
+        }
+
+        try (TestRestClient client = cluster.getRestClient(WHO_AM_I_UNREGISTERED)) {
+            assertThat(client.post(WHOAMI_ENDPOINT).getStatusCode(), equalTo(HttpStatus.SC_OK));
+        }
+
+    }
+}
diff --git a/src/main/java/org/opensearch/security/OpenSearchSecurityPlugin.java b/src/main/java/org/opensearch/security/OpenSearchSecurityPlugin.java
@@ -146,6 +146,7 @@
 import org.opensearch.security.http.XFFResolver;
 import org.opensearch.security.privileges.PrivilegesEvaluator;
 import org.opensearch.security.privileges.PrivilegesInterceptor;
+import org.opensearch.security.privileges.RestLayerPrivilegesEvaluator;
 import org.opensearch.security.resolver.IndexResolverReplacer;
 import org.opensearch.security.rest.DashboardsInfoAction;
 import org.opensearch.security.rest.SecurityConfigUpdateAction;
@@ -205,6 +206,7 @@ public final class OpenSearchSecurityPlugin extends OpenSearchSecuritySSLPlugin
     private volatile SecurityInterceptor si;
     private volatile PrivilegesEvaluator evaluator;
     private volatile UserService userService;
+    private volatile RestLayerPrivilegesEvaluator restLayerEvaluator;
     private volatile ThreadPool threadPool;
     private volatile ConfigurationRepository cr;
     private volatile AdminDNs adminDns;
@@ -1019,8 +1021,11 @@ public Collection<Object> createComponents(
             principalExtractor = ReflectionHelper.instantiatePrincipalExtractor(principalExtractorClass);
         }
 
+        restLayerEvaluator = new RestLayerPrivilegesEvaluator(clusterService, threadPool, auditLog, cih, namedXContentRegistry);
+
         securityRestHandler = new SecurityRestFilter(
             backendRegistry,
+            restLayerEvaluator,
             auditLog,
             threadPool,
             principalExtractor,
@@ -1035,6 +1040,7 @@ public Collection<Object> createComponents(
         dcf.registerDCFListener(irr);
         dcf.registerDCFListener(xffResolver);
         dcf.registerDCFListener(evaluator);
+        dcf.registerDCFListener(restLayerEvaluator);
         dcf.registerDCFListener(securityRestHandler);
         if (!(auditLog instanceof NullAuditLog)) {
             // Don't register if advanced modules is disabled in which case auditlog is instance of NullAuditLog
@@ -1072,6 +1078,7 @@ public Collection<Object> createComponents(
         components.add(xffResolver);
         components.add(backendRegistry);
         components.add(evaluator);
+        components.add(restLayerEvaluator);
         components.add(si);
         components.add(dcf);
         components.add(userService);

diff --git a/src/main/java/org/opensearch/security/auditlog/impl/AbstractAuditLog.java b/src/main/java/org/opensearch/security/auditlog/impl/AbstractAuditLog.java
@@ -184,6 +184,7 @@ public void logMissingPrivileges(String privilege, String effectiveUser, RestReq
         msg.addRemoteAddress(remoteAddress);
         msg.addRestRequestInfo(request, auditConfigFilter);
         msg.addEffectiveUser(effectiveUser);
+        msg.addPrivilege(privilege);
         save(msg);
     }
 

diff --git a/src/main/java/org/opensearch/security/dlic/rest/support/Utils.java b/src/main/java/org/opensearch/security/dlic/rest/support/Utils.java
@@ -44,6 +44,7 @@
 import org.opensearch.core.xcontent.NamedXContentRegistry;
 import org.opensearch.core.xcontent.ToXContent;
 import org.opensearch.core.xcontent.XContentParser;
+import org.opensearch.rest.NamedRoute;
 import org.opensearch.rest.RestHandler.DeprecatedRoute;
 import org.opensearch.rest.RestHandler.Route;
 import org.opensearch.security.DefaultObjectMapper;
@@ -240,9 +241,17 @@ public static List<Route> addRoutesPrefix(List<Route> routes) {
      * Total number of routes will be expanded len(prefixes) as much comparing to the list passed in
      */
     public static List<Route> addRoutesPrefix(List<Route> routes, final String... prefixes) {
-        return routes.stream()
-            .flatMap(r -> Arrays.stream(prefixes).map(p -> new Route(r.getMethod(), p + r.getPath())))
-            .collect(ImmutableList.toImmutableList());
+        return routes.stream().flatMap(r -> Arrays.stream(prefixes).map(p -> {
+            if (r instanceof NamedRoute) {
+                NamedRoute nr = (NamedRoute) r;
+                return new NamedRoute.Builder().method(nr.getMethod())
+                    .path(p + nr.getPath())
+                    .uniqueName(nr.name())
+                    .legacyActionNames(nr.actionNames())
+                    .build();
+            }
+            return new Route(r.getMethod(), p + r.getPath());
+        })).collect(ImmutableList.toImmutableList());
     }
 
     /**