Merge pull request #223 from lidofinance/cms/lido-landing/scorecard

Update Lido landing “scorecard”
lidofinance · Dec 3, 2024 · 0dfa07b · 0dfa07b
2 parents bafc4d1 + a249fbc
commit 0dfa07b
Showing 1 changed file with 8 additions and 8 deletions.
diff --git a/lido-landing/scorecard.md b/lido-landing/scorecard.md
@@ -36,7 +36,7 @@ rows:
   - scorecard-attribute: "No operator has more than 1% of the total stake"
     categories: "Validator set"
     self-assessment: "Good"
-    comments: "As of Q2/2024, all operators have less than 1% of the total stake. Quarterly updates on the details and ratio of amount of stake that is over the soft-ceiling can be found in the [Lido Validator and Node Operator Metrics (VaNOM) web-app](https://app.hex.tech/8dedcd99-17f4-49d8-944e-4857a355b90a/app/3f7d6967-3ef6-4e69-8f7b-d02d903f045b/latest). Additionally, through the Simple DVT Module and the Community Staking Module, hundreds of net new operators have already started using the Lido protocol in 2024, further reducing concentration of stake share amongst large entities."
+    comments: "As of Q3/2024, all operators have less than 1% of the total stake. Quarterly updates on the details and ratio of amount of stake that is over the soft-ceiling can be found in the\_[Lido Validator and Node Operator Metrics (VaNOM) web-app](https://app.hex.tech/8dedcd99-17f4-49d8-944e-4857a355b90a/app/3f7d6967-3ef6-4e69-8f7b-d02d903f045b/latest). Additionally, through the Simple DVT Module and the Community Staking Module, hundreds of net new operators have already started using the Lido protocol in 2024, further reducing concentration of stake share amongst large entities."
   - scorecard-attribute: "Lido Protocol governance lives on Ethereum"
     categories: "Security"
     self-assessment: "Good"
@@ -56,7 +56,7 @@ rows:
   - scorecard-attribute: "Client Diversity"
     categories: "Validator set"
     self-assessment: "Good"
-    comments: "As at Q4/2023, Node Operators using the Lido protocol continue to utilize a [well-balanced suite of Consensus Layer clients](https://app.hex.tech/8dedcd99-17f4-49d8-944e-4857a355b90a/app/3f7d6967-3ef6-4e69-8f7b-d02d903f045b/latest?tab=client-diversity) in aggregate. Execution Layer diversity significantly improved as a result of [Node Operator commitments to reduce their reliance on Geth as a supermajority client](https://{{research}}/t/ethereum-node-operator-el-diversity-improvement-commitments/6459). Geth is no longer the majority Execution Layer client, seeing a usage of 37%, just below Nethermind at 41%."
+    comments: "As of Q3/2024, Node Operators using the Lido protocol continue to utilize a\_[well-balanced suite of Consensus Layer clients](https://app.hex.tech/8dedcd99-17f4-49d8-944e-4857a355b90a/app/3f7d6967-3ef6-4e69-8f7b-d02d903f045b/latest?tab=client-diversity)\_in aggregate. Execution Layer diversity significantly improved as a result of [Node Operator commitments to reduce their reliance on Geth as a supermajority client](https://{{research}}/t/ethereum-node-operator-el-diversity-improvement-commitments/6459).\_Geth is no longer the supermajority Execution Layer client, seeing a usage of 38%, just above Nethermind at 37%."
   - scorecard-attribute: "Delegation is enabled in on-chain governance"
     categories: "Governance"
     self-assessment: "Good"
@@ -70,11 +70,11 @@ rows:
   - scorecard-attribute: "Distributed geographically"
     categories: "Validator set"
     self-assessment: "Okay"
-    comments: "As at Q2/2024, around 22% of validators are operated by North-America (US+Canada) based Node Operators, but there remains an over-reliance on European based entities. Improvements have been noted in not only the addition of Asian and South American-based operators, but also the distribution  of validators across under-represented geographies. However, the community can continue to promote geographical diversity [latest stats can be found here](https://app.hex.tech/8dedcd99-17f4-49d8-944e-4857a355b90a/app/3f7d6967-3ef6-4e69-8f7b-d02d903f045b/latest?selectedStaticCellId=be392244-4d90-4212-9492-d07ded405735)."
+    comments: "As of Q3/2024, around 22% of validators are operated by North-America (US+Canada) based Node Operators, but there remains an over-reliance on European based entities. Improvements have been noted in not only the addition of Asian and South American-based operators, but also the distribution of validators across under-represented geographies. However, the community can continue to promote geographical diversity.\_[Latest stats can be found here](https://app.hex.tech/8dedcd99-17f4-49d8-944e-4857a355b90a/app/3f7d6967-3ef6-4e69-8f7b-d02d903f045b/latest?selectedStaticCellId=be392244-4d90-4212-9492-d07ded405735)."
   - scorecard-attribute: "Best practices in security and key management"
     categories: "Validator set"
     self-assessment: "Okay"
-    comments: "In the Curated Operator module, keys are managed by professional node operators. [As of the Q2/24, 23.2% of validators in the module](https://app.hex.tech/8dedcd99-17f4-49d8-944e-4857a355b90a/app/3f7d6967-3ef6-4e69-8f7b-d02d903f045b/latest) utilize Attestant’s Vouch CL client. While Vouch utilization does not directly correlate to usage of Attestants Dirk key manager that includes threshold signing, it is roughly indicative. In the Simple DVT Module, participants utilize Obol and SSV Network based DVT. All validator keys are created through a Distributed Key Generation process, with no single Node Operator (or other party) controlling a full private key at any point of their existence."
+    comments: "In the Curated Operator module, keys are managed by professional node operators.\_[As of the Q3/24, 23.2% of validators in the module](https://app.hex.tech/8dedcd99-17f4-49d8-944e-4857a355b90a/app/3f7d6967-3ef6-4e69-8f7b-d02d903f045b/latest)\_utilize Attestant’s Vouch CL client. While Vouch utilization does not directly correlate to usage of Attestants Dirk key manager that includes threshold signing, it is roughly indicative. In the Simple DVT Module, participants utilize Obol and SSV Network based DVT. All validator keys are created through a Distributed Key Generation process, with no single Node Operator (or other party) controlling a full private key at any point of their existence."
   - scorecard-attribute: "Node operators are disincentivized from acting maliciously"
     categories: "Validator set"
     self-assessment: "Okay"
@@ -90,15 +90,15 @@ rows:
   - scorecard-attribute: "DAO goals are easily accessible"
     categories: "Governance"
     self-assessment: "Okay"
-    comments: "[The GOOSE framework](https://snapshot.org/#/lido-snapshot.eth/proposal/0x58bbc5d540e46081043ef29d4d1ee56b7df4dc1b0369aa78e0c15a2403549353) is utilized to set goals for one-year and three-year periods. The [current goals](https://snapshot.org/#/lido-snapshot.eth/proposal/0x0fa423280ce2bcc2596901d81322716ad440c7581658030a7d21784c2661d81c) were adopted in November 2023 and updated in May 2024 ([reGOOSE](https://snapshot.org/#/lido-snapshot.eth/proposal/0x300523518b08f20c585751c0a720ef3ec53698d4e5062154d285b15cb062f96c)). The ongoing GOOSE cycle will propose new goals, with a vote to adopt them expected by the end of 2024."
-  - scorecard-attribute: "Distributed variation of on-premise infra and cloud providers"
+    comments: "[The GOOSE framework](https://snapshot.org/#/lido-snapshot.eth/proposal/0x58bbc5d540e46081043ef29d4d1ee56b7df4dc1b0369aa78e0c15a2403549353) is utilized to set one-year and three-year goals. The [goals for 2025](https://snapshot.org/#/lido-snapshot.eth/proposal/0xeedef9fea3d782f192410768cabaf6974da40ef36e1d22c7f8fff5fd4cfc7a59) were adopted in November 2024, marking a new focus for the upcoming year.\\\nMeanwhile, [](https://snapshot.org/#/lido-snapshot.eth/proposal/0x0fa423280ce2bcc2596901d81322716ad440c7581658030a7d21784c2661d81c)[the current goals](https://snapshot.org/#/lido-snapshot.eth/proposal/0x0fa423280ce2bcc2596901d81322716ad440c7581658030a7d21784c2661d81c), adopted in November 2023, were adjusted in May 2024 ([reGOOSE](https://snapshot.org/#/lido-snapshot.eth/proposal/0x300523518b08f20c585751c0a720ef3ec53698d4e5062154d285b15cb062f96c)), remain active and relevant."
+  - scorecard-attribute: "Distributed variation of on-premises infra and cloud providers"
     categories: "Validator set"
     self-assessment: "Okay"
-    comments: "Reliance on public cloud has increased from 40% to 50% in Q2/2024. The usage is balanced against forms of Bare Metal (Colocated, On-Premises or Dedicated Hardware)Reliance on public cloud services has decreased significantly from 45%-50% in Q4/2023 to 38%-40% in Q1/2024. The majority of Node Operators now utilize some form of Bare Metal (Colocated, On-Premises or Dedicated hardware). Details can be found in the [Lido VaNOM web-app](https://app.hex.tech/8dedcd99-17f4-49d8-944e-4857a355b90a/app/3f7d6967-3ef6-4e69-8f7b-d02d903f045b/latest?selectedStaticCellId=fd91537b-e4b5-42b6-813d-6ec0ff957cd3)."
+    comments: "Reliance on public cloud has stabilized from around 50% in Q3/2024. The usage is balanced against forms of Bare Metal (Colocated, On-Premises or Dedicated Hardware). Details can be found in the\_[Lido VaNOM web-app](https://app.hex.tech/8dedcd99-17f4-49d8-944e-4857a355b90a/app/3f7d6967-3ef6-4e69-8f7b-d02d903f045b/latest?selectedStaticCellId=fd91537b-e4b5-42b6-813d-6ec0ff957cd3)."
   - scorecard-attribute: "There’s a way for operators to permissionlessly enter the set and prove themselves"
     categories: "Validator set"
     self-assessment: "Okay"
-    comments: "The first permissionless module called [CSM](https://{{research}}/t/community-staking-module/5917) is now live on Ethereum mainnet in the Early Adoption (perrmissioned) mode to onboard a sub-set of identified likely solo stakers to CSM on mainnet prior to the module opening up to everyone. This mechanism safeguards against the potential crowding out of CSM’s capacity by large operators during the initial phase. Once Early Adoption mode is deactivated (expected to happen early 2025), the module will become fully permissionless. is now deployed on the testnet and planned to be proposed to on-chain vote by the end of 2024."
+    comments: "The first permissionless module called\_[CSM](https://{{operatorportal}}/modules/community-staking-module)\_is now live on Ethereum mainnet in the Early Adoption (perrmissioned) mode to onboard a sub-set of identified likely solo stakers to CSM on mainnet prior to the module opening up to everyone. This mechanism safeguards against the potential crowding out of CSM’s capacity by large operators during the initial phase. Once Early Adoption mode is deactivated (expected to happen early 2025), the module will become fully permissionless."
 :::
 
 ## Needs Improvement