karate : Complex JSON Schema matching

[avyasbms]

Feature: Complex Schema
  Background:
    * def JSONtobeValidiated =
    """

  {
  "MyArray": {
    "MYinternalDetails": [
      {
        "SomeField": "dc",
        "textfield": [],
        "OptionalArray1": [
          {
            "Users": "Y",
            "IsAllowed": "Y"
          },
          {
            "Users": "Y",
            "IsAllowed": "Y"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "SomeField": "cd",
        "textfield": [],
        "OptionalArray3": [
          {
            "Astring": "Lazy",
            "AnotherString": "N",
            "textfield": []
          },
          {
            "Astring": "FREE",
            "AnotherString": "N",
            "textfield": [
              {
                "title": "Name",
                "alertMessage": "Please enter valid name."
              },
              {
                "title": "Mobile No",
                "alertMessage": "Please enter mobile no."
              }
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "SomeField": "gv",
        "textfield": [
          {
            "title": "First",
            "alertMessage": "SOme Alert"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "SomeField": "rp",
        "textfield": []
      }
    ]
  }
}"""

    * def textfield = { title: '#string', alertMessage: '#string' }
    * def OptionalArray1 = { Users: '#string',IsAllowed: '#string' }
    * def OptionalArray3 = { Astring: '#string' ,AnotherString: '#string', textfield: '##[]'  }

    * def MYinternalDetails =
    """
      {
        SomeField: '#string',
        textfield: '##[]',
        OptionalArray1: '##[] OptionalArray1'
        OptionalArray3: '##[] OptionalArray3'
      }

    """

    * def ValidJsonSchema = { MyArray: { MYinternalDetails: '#[] MYinternalDetails' } }

  Scenario: These matches works

    * match JSONtobeValidiated.MyArray.MYinternalDetails == '#[]'
    * match JSONtobeValidiated.MyArray.MYinternalDetails == '#[4]'
    * match JSONtobeValidiated contains  { MyArray: '#ignore' }
    * match JSONtobeValidiated contains { MyArray: { MYinternalDetails: '#ignore' } }



  Scenario: These match doesn't work
    * match JSONtobeValidiated contains { MyArray: { MYinternalDetails: '#[] MYinternalDetails' } }

  Scenario: These match doesn't work either

    * match JSONtobeValidiated.MyArray.MYinternalDetails == '#[] MYinternalDetails'

  Scenario: These match Also doesn't work

    * match JSONtobeValidiated == ValidJsonSchema

In Above Example , Schema matching doesn't seems to be working as expected. Need to match full JSON schema.

Reference: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/49231115/karate-complex-json-schema-matching

[ptrthomas]

able to replicate with this example:

Background:
* def json =
"""
{
  "foo": {
    "bars": [
      { "barOne": "dc", "barTwos": [] },
      { "barOne": "dc", "barTwos": [{ title: 'blah' }] },
      { "barOne": "dc", "barTwos": [{ title: 'blah' }], barThrees: [] },
      { "barOne": "dc", "barTwos": [{ title: 'blah' }], barThrees: [{ num: 1 }] }
    ]
  }
}
"""

* def barTwo = { title: '#string' }
* def barThree = { num: '#number' }
* def bar = { barOne: '#string', barTwos: '#[] barTwo', barThrees: '##[] barThree' }

Scenario:
* match json.foo.bars == '#[] bar'

[ptrthomas]

@avyasbms thanks a lot for finding this, it is fixed in dev. if you can build and run from source, do verify - else we can release a 0.7.0.2 shortly.

[avyasbms]

Waiting for 0.7.0.2 to verify.

[avyasbms]

@ptrthomas Can you let me know how to verify?
A lot of our APIs are pending on this one.

[ptrthomas]

@avyasbms sorry, I should have done this earlier, but somehow thought you had a workaround.

I just released 0.7.0.2 - can you confirm that it works ?

[avyasbms]

Hey @ptrthomas It seems to be working. I'll check more cases and will confirm. Thanks a lot.

[avyasbms]

Confirming that it worked for many other cases as well. Thanks again!

[ptrthomas]

thanks @avyasbms I'll just keep this open pending the official 0.8.0 release

[ptrthomas]

released 0.8.0

[roma-shukla-wcq]

Hi @ptrthomas, the bug is again reproducible in 1.4.1.RC3. Please see this stackoverflow question for details: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/77125005/karate-complex-json-schema-validation-does-not-work-as-expected

I'm unaware of the process around reopening issues, so please suggest.

[ptrthomas]

@roma-shukla-wcq there is some discussion in #2364 which I think is related to your issue, this may need more changes