You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
we do have fangames in there though
there's some Sonic Before/After the Sequel songs in there
and they have the Sonic franchise artist, like any other official Sonic song on the wiki
Lan:
Huh. That's a mistake, I believe, or not something I would call consistent right now. Would be good to trace.
Lan noted tracks like this (specifically unreleased Pokémon Unbound tracks) should go under "Miscellany by Homestuck Musicians" or "Other music originating outside Homestuck", in the current layout. There shouldn't be a "Sonic the Hedgehog" or "Pokémon" artist. Reasoning below:
Does include stuff by non-official discography artists, mind. I don't think we have anything from fangames in "Music from video games" yet, because everything there belongs to a franchise, and franchise artists currently only cover official material from that franchise
We need to do a more thorough look-over of all tracks in "Music from video games" to check for other tracks that are from fan-games, and update them accordingly.
Alternatively (/in addition), we can consider improved structuring for video game music in general, with fan-games in mind. Although it's reasonable that fan-tracks don't belong under a franchise artist per se, they're surely related as far as "more references to undertale stuff" go. See also #470, #412.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
As Morris noted (#hsmusic-chat):
Lan:
Morris linked these tracks:
https://hsmusic.wiki/preview-en/track/before-the-sequel-title-screen/
https://hsmusic.wiki/preview-en/track/breakfast-time-for-horizon-heights-boss-act-phase-2/
https://hsmusic.wiki/preview-en/track/the-adventure-continues-for-horizon-heights-act-1/
Lan noted tracks like this (specifically unreleased Pokémon Unbound tracks) should go under "Miscellany by Homestuck Musicians" or "Other music originating outside Homestuck", in the current layout. There shouldn't be a "Sonic the Hedgehog" or "Pokémon" artist. Reasoning below:
We need to do a more thorough look-over of all tracks in "Music from video games" to check for other tracks that are from fan-games, and update them accordingly.
Alternatively (/in addition), we can consider improved structuring for video game music in general, with fan-games in mind. Although it's reasonable that fan-tracks don't belong under a franchise artist per se, they're surely related as far as "more references to undertale stuff" go. See also #470, #412.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: