Nomad 1.8.4 failed to exec into task: No path to region

[mcphailtom]

Nomad version

Nomad v1.8.4
BuildDate 2024-09-17T20:18:34Z
Revision 22ab32e

Operating system and Environment details

Linux 20.04.1-Ubuntu

Issue

As part of regular releases we are upgrading our shipped versions of Nomad. In our latest release candidates we have attempted a two step move from 1.15.17 -> 1.7.7 -> 1.8.4.

During testing we have performed this upgrade on a sample set of clusters and in all cases the upgrade is completely successfully. We have also attempted the 1.5.17 -> 1.8.4 upgrade without issue. Jobs are running as expected.

Several tests in our test suite use the nomad alloc exec command for test execution and we are seeing intermittent failures of the tests with the error message: failed to exec into task: No path to region

After some initial investigation it appears the command fails on all nodes of the cluster except the node where the allocation is actually running.

This behaviors is not consistent with previous versions of nomad.

Reproduction steps

Using a sample job:

admin@app1:~$ nomad job status mysql
ID            = mysql
Name          = mysql
Submit Date   = 2024-12-05T01:13:35Z
Type          = system
Priority      = 50
Datacenters   = primary
Namespace     = default
Node Pool     = default
Status        = running
Periodic      = false
Parameterized = false

Summary
Task Group  Queued  Starting  Running  Failed  Complete  Lost  Unknown
mysql       0       0         3        0       0         0     0

Allocations
ID        Node ID   Task Group  Version  Desired  Status   Created    Modified
37e41f01  520855e6  mysql       0        run      running  10h7m ago  10h7m ago
69195c2c  8c55b7e6  mysql       0        run      running  10h7m ago  23m38s ago
8cf697a1  9da121d6  mysql       0        run      running  10h7m ago  10h7m ago
admin@app1:~$ nomad node status
ID        Node Pool  DC       Name   Class   Drain  Eligibility  Status
8c55b7e6  default    primary  data1  <none>  false  eligible     ready
0abc5c85  default    primary  app1   <none>  false  eligible     ready
520855e6  default    primary  data2  <none>  false  eligible     ready
9da121d6  default    primary  data3  <none>  false  eligible     ready
8f82e4c6  default    primary  app2   <none>  false  eligible     ready
admin@app1:~$

Running an alloc exec on the app1 node where no allocation is running produces the following result:

admin@app1:~$ nomad alloc exec -job mysql /bin/bash
failed to exec into task: No path to region
admin@app1:~$

Running it again on the data3 node where an allocation is running will function as expected:

admin@data3:~$ nomad alloc exec -job mysql /bin/bash
root@data3:/#

Running from another node with an explicit -region set to the default region functions as expected.

admin@app1:~$ nomad alloc exec -region primary -job mysql /bin/bash
root@data3:/#

Expected Result

The command should exec on any node/agent in the cluster in the default region (since agents default to the region they are connected to in the case of no flag)

Actual Result

An error is produced unless running on the node on which the allocation exists.

Job file (if appropriate)

Nomad Server logs (if appropriate)

Nomad Client logs (if appropriate)

[mcphailtom]

cc @half-ogre @jamesooo @andrba @another-mattr

[tgross]

Hi @mcphailtom! The error you're seeing (ErrNoRegionPath) comes from only a few places in the code. Each Nomad client agent is connected to exactly one Nomad server at a time (rotating between servers as needed to rebalance and handle failures). When you call nomad alloc exec, the HTTP API call gets transformed into a RPC call. The RPC call is forward from that agent to the server the agent is connected to. That server forwards the RPC to the leader (if it's not the leader). The leader looks up which server the destination allocation is on, and forwards the RPC to that server. And finally, the RPC is forwarded from that node to the client where the allocation is running. This is why you can make a request to any node anywhere and it makes its way to the correct place.

The ErrNoRegionPath error appears in only 3 places:

• rpc.go#L702
• rpc.go#L730
• client_rpc.go#L170

In all 3 locations, we're looking up a server from the list of Raft peers.

That you're getting an error here suggests that there's a problem in your cluster topology. One or more servers are not showing up in the list of Raft peers. I suspect you've either got a split brain in the cluster during your upgrade or you've got one peer that's not joining (maybe it's got a configuration or networking issue).

To help diagnose:

• The error should be showing up in the logs of the host that's hitting it. Is that error happening on a client or a server?
• Use nomad server members to verify the health of servers.
• The Autopilot Read Health API will tell you which servers the cluster thinks it knows about.
• The Read Raft Configuration API should match that.
• The List Members API will give you the list of servers in the gossip pool (this is a lot of the same information in nomad server members but more detail).

Also, small detail:

Running from another node with an explicit -region set to the default region functions as expected.

Your example shows you're passing the same name as the DC. Datacenter and region aren't the same thing. Maybe you have the same name for them both, but just wanted to make sure 😁

[tgross]

I suspect #24635 is related and I have a reproduction for that and a culprit commit. Working on figuring out the underlying problem now.

[tgross]

Fix up here for review: #24644

[half-ogre]

Thanks @tgross! Is there a way for me to monitor when this makes it into a release for us to test?

[tgross]

We were planning on releasing yesterday but were delayed because of GitHub / release infrastructure issues. Should land today if there are no other snafus.

Just in general, we try to release a patch version monthly. There's a public announcements-only mailing list https://groups.google.com/g/nomad-tool, the nomad-release tag on Discuss here https://discuss.hashicorp.com/tags/c/nomad/28/nomad-release, and the RSS (well, Atom) feed for the GitHub releases here: https://github.com/hashicorp/nomad/releases.atom

[half-ogre]

Perfect, and thanks for sharing @tgross!