saveDir didn't work #525

Jayshanx · 2021-09-09T07:56:29Z

when i set savedDir=/storage/emulated/0/Android/data/vn.hunghd.example/files
but files save to /storage/emulated/0/Download/Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf

compileSdkVersion: 30
android version: 11
flutter_downloader: 1.7.0
flutter version: 2.5.0

my code

  Future<String?> _findLocalPath() async {
    var externalStorageDirPath;
    if (Platform.isAndroid) {
      try {
        // externalStorageDirPath = await AndroidPathProvider.downloadsPath;
        externalStorageDirPath = (await getExternalStorageDirectory())?.path;  //<-----------here
      } catch (e) {
        final directory = await getExternalStorageDirectory();
        externalStorageDirPath = directory?.path;
      }
    } else if (Platform.isIOS) {
      externalStorageDirPath = (await getApplicationDocumentsDirectory()).absolute.path;
    }
    return externalStorageDirPath;
  }

logs

[+5686 ms] W/WM-WorkSpec(22928): Backoff delay duration less than minimum value
[  +35 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): DownloadWorker{url=http://enos.itcollege.ee/~jpoial/allalaadimised/reading/Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf,filename=null,savedDir=/storage/emulated/0/Android/data/vn.hunghd.example/files,header={"auth": "test_for_sql_encoding"},isResume=false
[   +1 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Update notification: {notificationId: 5, title: http://enos.itcollege.ee/~jpoial/allalaadimised/reading/Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf, status: 2, progress: 0}
[  +10 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Open connection to http://enos.itcollege.ee/~jpoial/allalaadimised/reading/Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf
[        ] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Headers = {"auth": "test_for_sql_encoding"}
[   +2 ms] I/flutter (22928): Background Isolate Callback: task (384f753e-2958-4526-9fbc-9d2b12641b9d) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (0)
[   +5 ms] I/flutter (22928): UI Isolate Callback: [384f753e-2958-4526-9fbc-9d2b12641b9d, DownloadTaskStatus(2), 0]
[ +690 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Response with redirection code
[        ] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Location = https://enos.itcollege.ee/~jpoial/allalaadimised/reading/Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf
[        ] D/DownloadWorker(22928): New url: https://enos.itcollege.ee/~jpoial/allalaadimised/reading/Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf
[        ] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Open connection to https://enos.itcollege.ee/~jpoial/allalaadimised/reading/Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf
[   +1 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Headers = {"auth": "test_for_sql_encoding"}
[+1332 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Content-Type = application/pdf
[        ] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Content-Length = 8620159
[        ] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Charset = null
[        ] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Content-Disposition = null
[        ] D/DownloadWorker(22928): fileName = Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf
[ +645 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Update notification: {notificationId: 5, title: Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf, status: 2, progress: 1}
[   +3 ms] I/flutter (22928): Background Isolate Callback: task (384f753e-2958-4526-9fbc-9d2b12641b9d) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (1)
[        ] I/flutter (22928): UI Isolate Callback: [384f753e-2958-4526-9fbc-9d2b12641b9d, DownloadTaskStatus(2), 1]
[+1891 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Update notification: {notificationId: 5, title: Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf, status: ...
...
...
...
[        ] I/flutter (22928): UI Isolate Callback: [384f753e-2958-4526-9fbc-9d2b12641b9d, DownloadTaskStatus(2), 100]
[  +18 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): File downloaded (/storage/emulated/0/Download/Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf)
[   +3 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Setting an intent to open the file /storage/emulated/0/Download/Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf               //<<<<<<<<<<------------------------here


[        ] I/flutter (22928): Background Isolate Callback: task (384f753e-2958-4526-9fbc-9d2b12641b9d) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(3)) and process (100)
[   +1 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Update too frequently!!!!, but it is the final update, we should sleep a second to ensure the update call can be processed
[   +5 ms] I/flutter (22928): UI Isolate Callback: [384f753e-2958-4526-9fbc-9d2b12641b9d, DownloadTaskStatus(3), 100]
[  +10 ms] D/MediaScannerConnection(22928): Scanned /storage/emulated/0/Download/Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf to content://media/external_primary/file/319376
[        ] D/DownloadWorker(22928): MediaStore updated (content://media/external_primary/file/319376)
[ +985 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): Update notification: {notificationId: 5, title: Android-Programming-Cookbook.pdf, status: 3, progress: 100}
[   +8 ms] D/DownloadWorker(22928): File downloaded
[   +5 ms] I/WM-WorkerWrapper(22928): Worker result SUCCESS for Work [ id=384f753e-2958-4526-9fbc-9d2b12641b9d, tags={ flutter_download_task, vn.hunghd.flutterdownloader.DownloadWorker } ]

The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:

cyanlink · 2021-09-09T18:17:15Z

+1, can reproduce here.

Jayshanx · 2021-09-10T01:03:03Z

here the code seems to be the problem

flutter_downloader/android/src/main/java/vn/hunghd/flutterdownloader/DownloadWorker.java

Line 351 in 26e2ef4

Uri uriApi29 = null;

tijanirf · 2021-09-10T15:14:45Z

Also happened to me on:

android version: 9
flutter_downloader: 1.6.0
flutter version: 2.5.0

But, it was previously successful:

android version: 9
flutter_downloader: 1.6.0
flutter version: 2.2.1

Maybe the culprit is flutter 2.5.0

ronny-sugianto · 2021-09-10T15:18:56Z

Also happened to me on:

android version: 9

flutter_downloader: 1.6.0

flutter version: 2.5.0

But, it was previously successful:

android version: 9

flutter_downloader: 1.6.0

flutter version: 2.2.1

Maybe the culprit is flutter 2.5.0

I also experienced the same thing,
but i'm using android version : 11 (api 30)

Jayshanx · 2021-09-10T17:28:10Z

Also happened to me on:

android version: 9

flutter_downloader: 1.6.0

flutter version: 2.5.0

But, it was previously successful:

android version: 9

flutter_downloader: 1.6.0

flutter version: 2.2.1

Maybe the culprit is flutter 2.5.0

flutter 2.5.0 is not culprit , you can see pr #526 (comment)

Jayshanx · 2021-09-10T17:30:00Z

Also happened to me on:

android version: 9

flutter_downloader: 1.6.0

flutter version: 2.5.0

But, it was previously successful:

android version: 9

flutter_downloader: 1.6.0

flutter version: 2.2.1

Maybe the culprit is flutter 2.5.0

I also experienced the same thing,
but i'm android version : 11 (api 30)

The problem has been solved， you can use #526 (comment)

tijanirf · 2021-09-10T22:35:32Z

#526 (comment)

I just realized it was already mentioned before my comment.

Checked the PR, hope it merged soon.

hnvn · 2021-09-11T13:37:20Z

There's change on android storage management from Android 11. please upgrade to v1.7.0

tijanirf · 2021-09-11T13:59:54Z

Actually, we tried first on flutter 2.5 & flutter_downloader v1.7.0 and the error happened. Then we tried downgrading as I mentioned above in my comment. We end up rollback our app to flutter 2.2.1 and flutter_downloader v1.6.0 to make it works.

I'll try to debug deeper and let you know about my findings on monday 🤞

tijanirf · 2021-09-13T04:00:11Z

Actually, we tried first on flutter 2.5 & flutter_downloader v1.7.0 and the error happened. Then we tried downgrading as I mentioned above in my comment. We end up rollback our app to flutter 2.2.1 and flutter_downloader v1.6.0 to make it works.

I'll try to debug deeper and let you know about my findings on monday 🤞

There's change on android storage management from Android 11. please upgrade to v1.7.0

I just tested on these specs and still got the same issue as mentioned above:

android version: 9
flutter_downloader: 1.7.0
flutter version: 2.5.0

Logs

D/DownloadWorker( 5067): DownloadWorker{url=https://storage.googleapis.com/vx_dev_tasks/tasks/710/INV2021015974 (1).pdf,filename=null,savedDir=/storage/emulated/0/Android/data/com.sunterra.vx.dev/files/Downloads,header=,isResume=false
D/DownloadWorker( 5067): Open connection to https://storage.googleapis.com/vx_dev_tasks/tasks/710/INV2021015974 (1).pdf
D/DownloadWorker( 5067): Content-Type = application/pdf
D/DownloadWorker( 5067): Content-Length = 85763
D/DownloadWorker( 5067): Charset = null
D/DownloadWorker( 5067): Content-Disposition = null
D/DownloadWorker( 5067): fileName = INV2021015974 (1).pdf
D/DownloadWorker( 5067): File downloaded (/storage/emulated/0/Download/INV2021015974 (1).pdf)
D/DownloadWorker( 5067): File downloaded
I/WM-WorkerWrapper( 5067): Worker result SUCCESS for Work [ id=e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57, tags={ flutter_download_task, vn.hunghd.flutterdownloader.DownloadWorker } ]
D/DownloadWorker( 5067): MediaStore updated (content://media/external/file/696232)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (0)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (2)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (8)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (14)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (21)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (27)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (34)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (41)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (47)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (54)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (60)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (66)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (73)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (79)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (86)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (92)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (98)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(2)) and process (100)
I/flutter ( 5067): Background Isolate Callback: task (e40f444b-ab20-49b9-b58d-12b77fe94c57) is in status (DownloadTaskStatus(3)) and process (100)

Even though it's written DownloadWorker{url=https://storage.googleapis.com/vx_dev_tasks/tasks/710/INV2021015974 (1).pdf,filename=null,savedDir=/storage/emulated/0/Android/data/com.sunterra.vx.dev/files/Downloads,header=,isResume=false, the file is not exist on the savedDir. The file is downloaded to /storage/emulated/0/Download/INV2021015974 (1).pdf

I'm not using android 11, so upgrading to v1.7.0 won't fix the problem.

hnvn · 2021-10-09T03:26:18Z

Please upgrade to v1.7.1. For more detail, please have a look at this comment

huynguyennovem mentioned this issue Sep 9, 2021

Hotfix: file is not saved on savedDir #526

Merged

Jayshanx changed the title ~~saveDir didn't work in flutter 2.5.0~~ saveDir didn't work Sep 10, 2021

hnvn closed this as completed Sep 11, 2021

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

saveDir didn't work #525

saveDir didn't work #525

Jayshanx commented Sep 9, 2021

cyanlink commented Sep 9, 2021

Jayshanx commented Sep 10, 2021

tijanirf commented Sep 10, 2021

ronny-sugianto commented Sep 10, 2021 •

edited

Loading

Jayshanx commented Sep 10, 2021

Jayshanx commented Sep 10, 2021

tijanirf commented Sep 10, 2021

hnvn commented Sep 11, 2021

tijanirf commented Sep 11, 2021

tijanirf commented Sep 13, 2021

hnvn commented Oct 9, 2021

saveDir didn't work #525

saveDir didn't work #525

Comments

Jayshanx commented Sep 9, 2021

cyanlink commented Sep 9, 2021

Jayshanx commented Sep 10, 2021

tijanirf commented Sep 10, 2021

ronny-sugianto commented Sep 10, 2021 • edited Loading

Jayshanx commented Sep 10, 2021

Jayshanx commented Sep 10, 2021

tijanirf commented Sep 10, 2021

hnvn commented Sep 11, 2021

tijanirf commented Sep 11, 2021

tijanirf commented Sep 13, 2021

hnvn commented Oct 9, 2021

ronny-sugianto commented Sep 10, 2021 •

edited

Loading