-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 8.3k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
API Deprecations replace deprecated: true
with the deprecated object
#196095
Comments
While it's true these are deprecated, bc we decided to slow down removal we might need to hold off surfacing this in the UA until viable alternatives are ready for main use cases. |
I'd prefer to surface these now and continue to do so throughout v9 because they're widely used.
While it's true we don't have alternatives for all SO types (and probably never will), there are some and the docs point users to those: https://www.elastic.co/guide/en/kibana/current/api.html. The other reason we should make a noise now is that we've been trying to get rid of the SO APIs for 4+ years and the deprecation of these specific APIs is generally ignored. |
Pinging @elastic/response-ops (Team:ResponseOps) |
Pinging @elastic/kibana-core (Team:Core) |
For the record, Core decided not to surface the deprecated global saved objects HTTP APIs in the upgrade assistant as critical warnings, since they are not being removed in 9.0. |
# Summary Adds a new API deprecations feature inside core. This feature enabled plugin developers to mark their versioned and unversioned public routes as deprecated. These deprecations will be surfaced to the users through UA to help them understand the deprecation and address it before upgrading. This PR also surfaces these deprecations to UA. Closes #117241 1. Core service to flag deprecated routes 2. UA code to surface and resolve deprecated routes ## Flagging a deprecated Route ### The route deprecation option We have three types of route deprecations: - `type: bump`: A version bump deprecation means the API has a new version and the current version will be removed in the future in favor of the newer version. - `type: remove`: This API will be completely removed. You will no longer be able to use it in the future. - `type: migrate`: This API will be migrated to a different API and will be removed in the future in favor of the other API. All route deprecations expect a documentation link to help users navigate. We might add a generic documentation link and drop this requirement in the future but for now this is required. ### Deprecated Route Example Full examples can be found in the `routing_example` example plugin located in this directory: `examples/routing_example/server/routes/deprecated_routes` ```ts router[versioned?].get( { path: '/', options: { deprecated: { documentationUrl: 'https://google.com', severity: 'warning', reason: { type: 'bump', newApiVersion: '2024-10-13', }, }, }, }, async (context, req, res) => { ... ``` ## Surfaced API deprecations in UA The list of deprecated APIs will be listed inside Kibana deprecations along with the already supported config deprecations. <img width="1728" alt="image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/5bece704-b80b-4397-8ba2-6235f8995e4a"> Users can click on the list item to learn more about each deprecation and mark it as resolved <img width="1476" alt="image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/91c9207b-b246-482d-a5e4-21d0c61582a8"> ### Marking as resolved Users can click on mark as resolved button in the UA to hide the deprecation from the Kiban deprecations list. We keep track on when this button was clicked and how many times the API has been called. If the API is called again the deprecation will re-appear inside the list. We might add a feature in the future to permenantly supress the API deprecation from showing in the list through a configuration (#196089) If the API has been marked as resolved before we show this in the flyout message: > The API GET /api/deprecations/ has been called 25 times. The last time the API was called was on Monday, October 14, 2024 1:08 PM +03:00. > The api has been called 2 times since the last time it was marked as resolved on Monday, October 14, 2024 1:08 PM +03:00 Once marked as resolved the flyout exists and we show this to the user until they refresh the page <img width="1453" alt="image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/8bb5bc8b-d1a3-478f-9489-23cfa7db6350"> ## Telemetry: We keep track of 2 new things for telemetry purposes: 1. The number of times the deprecated API has been called 2. The number of times the deprecated API has been resolved (how many times the mark as resolved button in UA was clicked) ## Code review - [x] Core team is expected to review the whole PR - [ ] Docs team to review the copy and update the UA displayed texts (title, description, and manual steps) - [x] kibana-management team is expected to review the UA code changes and UI - [ ] A few teams are only required to approve this PR and update their `deprecated: true` route param to the new deprecationInfo object we now expect. There is an issue tracker to address those in separate PRs later on: #196095 ## Testing Run kibana locally with the test example plugin that has deprecated routes ``` yarn start --plugin-path=examples/routing_example --plugin-path=examples/developer_examples ``` The following comprehensive deprecated routes examples are registered inside the folder: `examples/routing_example/server/routes/deprecated_routes` Run them in the console to trigger the deprecation condition so they show up in the UA: ``` # Versioned routes: Version 1 is deprecated GET kbn:/api/routing_example/d/versioned?apiVersion=1 GET kbn:/api/routing_example/d/versioned?apiVersion=2 # Non-versioned routes GET kbn:/api/routing_example/d/removed_route POST kbn:/api/routing_example/d/migrated_route {} ``` 1. You can also mark as deprecated in the UA to remove the deprecation from the list. 2. Check the telemetry response to see the reported data about the deprecated route. 3. Calling version 2 of the API does not do anything since it is not deprecated unlike version `1` (`GET kbn:/api/routing_example/d/versioned?apiVersion=2`) 4. Internally you can see the deprecations counters from the dev console by running the following: ``` GET .kibana_usage_counters/_search { "query": { "bool": { "should": [ {"match": { "usage-counter.counterType": "deprecated_api_call:total"}}, {"match": { "usage-counter.counterType": "deprecated_api_call:resolved"}}, {"match": { "usage-counter.counterType": "deprecated_api_call:marked_as_resolved"}} ] } } } ``` --------- Co-authored-by: kibanamachine <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: florent-leborgne <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Elastic Machine <[email protected]>
The following routes have
deprecated: true
. We need to replace them with the deprecated object that provides enough metadata for users in UA to be able to address it before their next upgrade.We will start throwing an error in the near future to prevent developers from passing
true
to the deprecated param so we need to address those ASAP.Here is an example of what
true
needs to be replaced with (note theoptions.deprecated
param):See these instructions on adding a guide and this example PR, guides are required for each deprecation!
Check the PR notes or docs to learn more #196081
Saved objects APIs
Actions APIs
Alerts APIs
Cases APIs
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: