Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
Make "// @Dart=" version comments affect the applied style. (#1600)
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
The formatter uses an incoming language version to control how the
formatted code is parsed. The langauge version is also used to
determine whether you get the short or tall style.

Prior to this PR, a "// @Dart=" version comment in the formatted code
would affect the language version the code is parsed at. But it wouldn't
use that comment to determine whether you get the short or tall style.
This fixes that.

Fix #1599.
  • Loading branch information
munificent authored Nov 14, 2024
1 parent 02957e6 commit 6753ab4
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Showing 3 changed files with 120 additions and 1 deletion.
8 changes: 7 additions & 1 deletion lib/src/dart_formatter.dart
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -193,9 +193,15 @@ final class DartFormatter {
// Format it.
var lineInfo = parseResult.lineInfo;

// If the code has an `@dart=` comment, use that to determine the style.
var sourceLanguageVersion = languageVersion;
if (parseResult.unit.languageVersionToken case var token?) {
sourceLanguageVersion = Version(token.major, token.minor, 0);
}

// Use language version to determine what formatting style to apply.
SourceCode output;
if (languageVersion > latestShortStyleLanguageVersion) {
if (sourceLanguageVersion > latestShortStyleLanguageVersion) {
// Look for a page width comment before the code.
int? pageWidthFromComment;
for (Token? comment = node.beginToken.precedingComments;
Expand Down
57 changes: 57 additions & 0 deletions test/cli/language_version_test.dart
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -266,5 +266,62 @@ main() {

await d.dir('code', [d.file('a.dart', after)]).validate();
});

test('language version comment override opts into short style', () async {
const before = '''
// @dart=3.6
main() { f(argument, // comment
another);}
''';
const after = '''
// @dart=3.6
main() {
f(
argument, // comment
another);
}
''';

await d.dir('code', [d.file('a.dart', before)]).create();

var process = await runFormatterOnDir(['--language-version=3.7']);
await process.shouldExit(0);

await d.dir('code', [d.file('a.dart', after)]).validate();
});

test('language version comment override opts into tall style', () async {
// Note that in real-world code it doesn't make sense for a language
// version comment to be *higher* than the specified default language
// version before you can't use a comment that's higher than the minimum
// version in the package's SDK constraint. (Otherwise, you could end up
// trying to run a library whose language version isn't supported by the
// SDK you are running it in.)
//
// But we support it in the formatter since it's possible to specify a
// default language version using mechanisms other than the pubspec SDK
// constraint.
const before = '''
// @dart=3.7
main() { f(argument, // comment
another);}
''';
const after = '''
// @dart=3.7
main() {
f(
argument, // comment
another,
);
}
''';

await d.dir('code', [d.file('a.dart', before)]).create();

var process = await runFormatterOnDir(['--language-version=3.6']);
await process.shouldExit(0);

await d.dir('code', [d.file('a.dart', after)]).validate();
});
});
}
56 changes: 56 additions & 0 deletions test/dart_formatter_test.dart
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -81,6 +81,62 @@ main() {
});
});

test('language version comment override opts into short style', () async {
// Use a language version with tall style.
var formatter = makeFormatter(languageVersion: Version(3, 7, 0));

// But the code has a comment to opt into the short style.
const before = '''
// @dart=3.6
main() { f(argument, // comment
another);}
''';
const after = '''
// @dart=3.6
main() {
f(
argument, // comment
another);
}
''';

expect(formatter.format(before), after);
});

test('language version comment override opts into tall style', () async {
// Use a language version with short style.
var formatter = makeFormatter(languageVersion: Version(3, 6, 0));

// But the code has a comment to opt into the tall style.
//
// Note that in real-world code it doesn't make sense for a language
// version comment to be *higher* than the specified default language
// version before you can't use a comment that's higher than the minimum
// version in the package's SDK constraint. (Otherwise, you could end up
// trying to run a library whose language version isn't supported by the
// SDK you are running it in.)
//
// But we support it in the formatter since it's possible to specify a
// default language version using mechanisms other than the pubspec SDK
// constraint.
const before = '''
// @dart=3.7
main() { f(argument, // comment
another);}
''';
const after = '''
// @dart=3.7
main() {
f(
argument, // comment
another,
);
}
''';

expect(formatter.format(before), after);
});

test('throws a FormatterException on failed parse', () {
var formatter = makeFormatter();
expect(() => formatter.format('wat?!'), throwsA(isA<FormatterException>()));
Expand Down

0 comments on commit 6753ab4

Please sign in to comment.