Introduce graph-based pod container removal

Originally, during pod removal, we locked every container in the
pod at once, did a number of validity checks to ensure everything
was safe, and then removed all the containers in the pod.

A deadlock was recently discovered with this approach. In brief,
we cannot lock the entire pod (or much more than a single
container at a time) without causing a deadlock. As such, we
converted to an approach where we just looped over each container
in the pod, removing them individually. Unfortunately, this
removed a lot of the validity checking of the earlier approach,
allowing for a lot of unintended bad things. Infra containers
could be removed while containers in the pod still depended on
them, for example.

There's no easy way to do validity checks while in a simple loop,
so I implemented a version of our graph-traversal logic that
currently handles pod start. This version acts in the reverse
order of startup: startup starts from containers which depend on
nothing and moves outwards, while removal acts on containers which
have nothing depend on them and moves inwards. By doing graph
traversal, we can guarantee that nothing is removed while
something that depends on it still exists - so the infra
container should be the last thing in a pod that is removed, for
example.

In the (unlikely) case that a graph of the pod's containers
cannot be built (most likely impossible without database editing)
the old method of pod removal has been retained to ensure that
even misbehaving pods can be forcibly evicted from the state.

I'm fairly confident that this resolves the problem, but there
are a lot of assumptions around dependency structure built into
the original pod removal code and I am not 100% sure I have
captured all of them.

Fixes #15526

Signed-off-by: Matthew Heon <[email protected]>

libpod/container_graph.go

@@ -281,3 +281,94 @@ func startNode(ctx context.Context, node *containerNode, setError bool, ctrError
 		startNode(ctx, successor, ctrErrored, ctrErrors, ctrsVisited, restart)
 	}
 }
+
+// Visit a node on the container graph and remove it, or set an error if it
+// failed to remove. Only intended for use in pod removal; do *not* use when
+// removing individual containers.
+// All containers are assumed to be *UNLOCKED* on running this function.
+// Container locks will be acquired as necessary.
+// Pod and infraID are optional. If a pod is given it must be *LOCKED*.
+func removeNode(ctx context.Context, node *containerNode, pod *Pod, force bool, timeout *uint, setError bool, ctrErrors map[string]error, ctrsVisited map[string]bool, ctrNamedVolumes map[string]*ContainerNamedVolume) {
+	// If we already visited this node, we're done.
+	if ctrsVisited[node.id] {
+		return
+	}
+
+	// Someone who depends on us failed.
+	// Mark us as failed and recurse.
+	if setError {
+		ctrsVisited[node.id] = true
+		ctrErrors[node.id] = fmt.Errorf("a container that depends on container %s could not be removed: %w", node.id, define.ErrCtrStateInvalid)
+
+		// Hit anyone who depends on us, set errors there as well.
+		for _, successor := range node.dependsOn {
+			removeNode(ctx, successor, pod, force, timeout, true, ctrErrors, ctrsVisited, ctrNamedVolumes)
+		}
+	}
+
+	// Does anyone still depend on us?
+	// Cannot remove if true. Once all our dependencies have been removed,
+	// we will be removed.
+	for _, dep := range node.dependedOn {
+		// The container that depends on us hasn't been removed yet.
+		// OK to continue on
+		if ok := ctrsVisited[dep.id]; !ok {
+			return
+		}
+	}
+
+	// Going to try to remove the node, mark us as visited
+	ctrsVisited[node.id] = true
+
+	ctrErrored := false
+
+	// Verify that all that depend on us are gone.
+	// Graph traversal should guarantee this is true, but this isn't that
+	// expensive, and it's better to be safe.
+	for _, dep := range node.dependedOn {
+		if _, err := node.container.runtime.GetContainer(dep.id); err == nil {
+			ctrErrored = true
+			ctrErrors[node.id] = fmt.Errorf("a container that depends on container %s still exists: %w", node.id, define.ErrDepExists)
+		}
+	}
+
+	// Lock the container
+	node.container.lock.Lock()
+
+	// Gate all subsequent bits behind a ctrErrored check - we don't want to
+	// proceed if a previous step failed.
+	if !ctrErrored {
+		if err := node.container.syncContainer(); err != nil {
+			ctrErrored = true
+			ctrErrors[node.id] = err
+		}
+	}
+
+	if !ctrErrored {
+		for _, vol := range node.container.config.NamedVolumes {
+			ctrNamedVolumes[vol.Name] = vol
+		}
+
+		if pod != nil && pod.state.InfraContainerID == node.id {
+			pod.state.InfraContainerID = ""
+			if err := pod.save(); err != nil {
+				ctrErrored = true
+				ctrErrors[node.id] = fmt.Errorf("error removing infra container %s from pod %s: %w", node.id, pod.ID(), err)
+			}
+		}
+	}
+
+	if !ctrErrored {
+		if err := node.container.runtime.removeContainer(ctx, node.container, force, false, true, false, timeout); err != nil {
+			ctrErrored = true
+			ctrErrors[node.id] = err
+		}
+	}
+
+	node.container.lock.Unlock()
+
+	// Recurse to anyone who we depend on and remove them
+	for _, successor := range node.dependsOn {
+		removeNode(ctx, successor, pod, force, timeout, ctrErrored, ctrErrors, ctrsVisited, ctrNamedVolumes)
+	}
+}

libpod/pod_api.go

@@ -40,7 +40,7 @@ func (p *Pod) startInitContainers(ctx context.Context) error {
 			icLock := initCon.lock
 			icLock.Lock()
 			var time *uint
-			if err := p.runtime.removeContainer(ctx, initCon, false, false, true, time); err != nil {
+			if err := p.runtime.removeContainer(ctx, initCon, false, false, true, false, time); err != nil {
 				icLock.Unlock()
 				return fmt.Errorf("failed to remove once init container %s: %w", initCon.ID(), err)
 			}

libpod/runtime_ctr.go

@@ -581,15 +581,17 @@ func (r *Runtime) setupContainer(ctx context.Context, ctr *Container) (_ *Contai
 // be removed also if and only if the container is the sole user
 // Otherwise, RemoveContainer will return an error if the container is running
 func (r *Runtime) RemoveContainer(ctx context.Context, c *Container, force bool, removeVolume bool, timeout *uint) error {
-	return r.removeContainer(ctx, c, force, removeVolume, false, timeout)
+	return r.removeContainer(ctx, c, force, removeVolume, false, false, timeout)
 }
 
 // Internal function to remove a container.
 // Locks the container, but does not lock the runtime.
 // removePod is used only when removing pods. It instructs Podman to ignore
 // infra container protections, and *not* remove from the database (as pod
 // remove will handle that).
-func (r *Runtime) removeContainer(ctx context.Context, c *Container, force, removeVolume, removePod bool, timeout *uint) error {
+// ignoreDeps is *DANGEROUS* and should not be used outside of a very specific
+// context (alternate pod removal code, where graph traversal is not possible).
+func (r *Runtime) removeContainer(ctx context.Context, c *Container, force, removeVolume, removePod, ignoreDeps bool, timeout *uint) error {
 	if !c.valid {
 		if ok, _ := r.state.HasContainer(c.ID()); !ok {
 			// Container probably already removed
@@ -618,25 +620,27 @@ func (r *Runtime) removeContainer(ctx context.Context, c *Container, force, remo
 	// pod.
 	var pod *Pod
 	runtime := c.runtime
-	if c.config.Pod != "" && !removePod {
+	if c.config.Pod != "" {
 		pod, err = r.state.Pod(c.config.Pod)
 		if err != nil {
 			return fmt.Errorf("container %s is in pod %s, but pod cannot be retrieved: %w", c.ID(), pod.ID(), err)
 		}
 
-		// Lock the pod while we're removing container
-		if pod.config.LockID == c.config.LockID {
-			return fmt.Errorf("container %s and pod %s share lock ID %d: %w", c.ID(), pod.ID(), c.config.LockID, define.ErrWillDeadlock)
-		}
-		pod.lock.Lock()
-		defer pod.lock.Unlock()
-		if err := pod.updatePod(); err != nil {
-			return err
-		}
+		if !removePod {
+			// Lock the pod while we're removing container
+			if pod.config.LockID == c.config.LockID {
+				return fmt.Errorf("container %s and pod %s share lock ID %d: %w", c.ID(), pod.ID(), c.config.LockID, define.ErrWillDeadlock)
+			}
+			pod.lock.Lock()
+			defer pod.lock.Unlock()
+			if err := pod.updatePod(); err != nil {
+				return err
+			}
 
-		infraID := pod.state.InfraContainerID
-		if c.ID() == infraID {
-			return fmt.Errorf("container %s is the infra container of pod %s and cannot be removed without removing the pod", c.ID(), pod.ID())
+			infraID := pod.state.InfraContainerID
+			if c.ID() == infraID {
+				return fmt.Errorf("container %s is the infra container of pod %s and cannot be removed without removing the pod", c.ID(), pod.ID())
+			}
 		}
 	}
 
@@ -696,7 +700,7 @@ func (r *Runtime) removeContainer(ctx context.Context, c *Container, force, remo
 	// Check that no other containers depend on the container.
 	// Only used if not removing a pod - pods guarantee that all
 	// deps will be evicted at the same time.
-	if !removePod {
+	if !ignoreDeps {
 		deps, err := r.state.ContainerInUse(c)
 		if err != nil {
 			return err
@@ -777,13 +781,11 @@ func (r *Runtime) removeContainer(ctx context.Context, c *Container, force, remo
 	if c.config.Pod != "" {
 		// If we're removing the pod, the container will be evicted
 		// from the state elsewhere
-		if !removePod {
-			if err := r.state.RemoveContainerFromPod(pod, c); err != nil {
-				if cleanupErr == nil {
-					cleanupErr = err
-				} else {
-					logrus.Errorf("Removing container %s from database: %v", c.ID(), err)
-				}
+		if err := r.state.RemoveContainerFromPod(pod, c); err != nil {
+			if cleanupErr == nil {
+				cleanupErr = err
+			} else {
+				logrus.Errorf("Removing container %s from database: %v", c.ID(), err)
 			}
 		}
 	} else {
@@ -872,7 +874,7 @@ func (r *Runtime) evictContainer(ctx context.Context, idOrName string, removeVol
 	if err == nil {
 		logrus.Infof("Container %s successfully retrieved from state, attempting normal removal", id)
 		// Assume force = true for the evict case
-		err = r.removeContainer(ctx, tmpCtr, true, removeVolume, false, timeout)
+		err = r.removeContainer(ctx, tmpCtr, true, removeVolume, false, false, timeout)
 		if !tmpCtr.valid {
 			// If the container is marked invalid, remove succeeded
 			// in kicking it out of the state - no need to continue.
@@ -1034,7 +1036,7 @@ func (r *Runtime) RemoveDepend(ctx context.Context, rmCtr *Container, force bool
 	}
 
 	report := reports.RmReport{Id: rmCtr.ID(), RawInput: rmCtr.ID()}
-	report.Err = r.removeContainer(ctx, rmCtr, force, removeVolume, false, timeout)
+	report.Err = r.removeContainer(ctx, rmCtr, force, removeVolume, false, false, timeout)
 	return append(rmReports, &report), nil
 }
 

libpod/runtime_img.go

@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ func (r *Runtime) RemoveContainersForImageCallback(ctx context.Context) libimage
 					return fmt.Errorf("removing image %s: container %s using image could not be removed: %w", imageID, ctr.ID(), err)
 				}
 			} else {
-				if err := r.removeContainer(ctx, ctr, true, false, false, timeout); err != nil {
+				if err := r.removeContainer(ctx, ctr, true, false, false, false, timeout); err != nil {
 					return fmt.Errorf("removing image %s: container %s using image could not be removed: %w", imageID, ctr.ID(), err)
 				}
 			}

libpod/runtime_pod_linux.go

@@ -17,6 +17,7 @@ import (
 	"github.com/containers/podman/v4/libpod/events"
 	"github.com/containers/podman/v4/pkg/rootless"
 	"github.com/containers/podman/v4/pkg/specgen"
+	"github.com/hashicorp/go-multierror"
 	"github.com/sirupsen/logrus"
 )
 
@@ -191,29 +192,9 @@ func (r *Runtime) SavePod(pod *Pod) error {
 	return nil
 }
 
-func (r *Runtime) removePod(ctx context.Context, p *Pod, removeCtrs, force bool, timeout *uint) error {
-	if err := p.updatePod(); err != nil {
-		return err
-	}
-
-	ctrs, err := r.state.PodContainers(p)
-	if err != nil {
-		return err
-	}
-	numCtrs := len(ctrs)
-
-	// If the only running container in the pod is the pause container, remove the pod and container unconditionally.
-	pauseCtrID := p.state.InfraContainerID
-	if numCtrs == 1 && ctrs[0].ID() == pauseCtrID {
-		removeCtrs = true
-		force = true
-	}
-	if !removeCtrs && numCtrs > 0 {
-		return fmt.Errorf("pod %s contains containers and cannot be removed: %w", p.ID(), define.ErrCtrExists)
-	}
-
-	ctrNamedVolumes := make(map[string]*ContainerNamedVolume)
-
+// DO NOT USE THIS FUNCTION DIRECTLY. Use removePod(), below. It will call
+// removeMalformedPod() if necessary.
+func (r *Runtime) removeMalformedPod(ctx context.Context, p *Pod, ctrs []*Container, force bool, timeout *uint, ctrNamedVolumes map[string]*ContainerNamedVolume) error {
 	var removalErr error
 	for _, ctr := range ctrs {
 		err := func() error {
@@ -231,7 +212,7 @@ func (r *Runtime) removePod(ctx context.Context, p *Pod, removeCtrs, force bool,
 				ctrNamedVolumes[vol.Name] = vol
 			}
 
-			return r.removeContainer(ctx, ctr, force, false, true, timeout)
+			return r.removeContainer(ctx, ctr, force, false, true, true, timeout)
 		}()
 
 		if removalErr == nil {
@@ -261,6 +242,69 @@ func (r *Runtime) removePod(ctx context.Context, p *Pod, removeCtrs, force bool,
 		return err
 	}
 
+	return nil
+}
+
+func (r *Runtime) removePod(ctx context.Context, p *Pod, removeCtrs, force bool, timeout *uint) error {
+	if err := p.updatePod(); err != nil {
+		return err
+	}
+
+	ctrs, err := r.state.PodContainers(p)
+	if err != nil {
+		return err
+	}
+	numCtrs := len(ctrs)
+
+	// If the only running container in the pod is the pause container, remove the pod and container unconditionally.
+	pauseCtrID := p.state.InfraContainerID
+	if numCtrs == 1 && ctrs[0].ID() == pauseCtrID {
+		removeCtrs = true
+		force = true
+	}
+	if !removeCtrs && numCtrs > 0 {
+		return fmt.Errorf("pod %s contains containers and cannot be removed: %w", p.ID(), define.ErrCtrExists)
+	}
+
+	var removalErr error
+	ctrNamedVolumes := make(map[string]*ContainerNamedVolume)
+
+	// Build a graph of all containers in the pod.
+	graph, err := BuildContainerGraph(ctrs)
+	if err != nil {
+		// We have to allow the pod to be removed.
+		// But let's only do it if force is set.
+		if !force {
+			return fmt.Errorf("cannot create container graph for pod %s: %w", p.ID(), err)
+		}
+
+		removalErr = fmt.Errorf("creating container graph for pod %s failed, fell back to loop removal: %w", p.ID(), err)
+
+		if err := r.removeMalformedPod(ctx, p, ctrs, force, timeout, ctrNamedVolumes); err != nil {
+			logrus.Errorf("Error creating container graph for pod %s: %v. Falling back to loop removal.", p.ID(), err)
+			return err
+		}
+	} else {
+		ctrErrors := make(map[string]error)
+		ctrsVisited := make(map[string]bool)
+
+		for _, node := range graph.notDependedOnNodes {
+			removeNode(ctx, node, p, force, timeout, false, ctrErrors, ctrsVisited, ctrNamedVolumes)
+		}
+
+		// This is gross, but I don't want to change the signature on
+		// removePod - especially since any change here eventually has
+		// to map down to one error unless we want to make a breaking
+		// API change.
+		if len(ctrErrors) > 0 {
+			var allErrs error
+			for id, err := range ctrErrors {
+				allErrs = multierror.Append(allErrs, fmt.Errorf("removing container %s from pod %s: %w", id, p.ID(), err))
+			}
+			return allErrs
+		}
+	}
+
 	for volName := range ctrNamedVolumes {
 		volume, err := r.state.Volume(volName)
 		if err != nil && !errors.Is(err, define.ErrNoSuchVolume) {

libpod/runtime_volume_linux.go

@@ -324,7 +324,7 @@ func (r *Runtime) removeVolume(ctx context.Context, v *Volume, force bool, timeo
 
 			logrus.Debugf("Removing container %s (depends on volume %q)", ctr.ID(), v.Name())
 
-			if err := r.removeContainer(ctx, ctr, force, false, false, timeout); err != nil {
+			if err := r.removeContainer(ctx, ctr, force, false, false, false, timeout); err != nil {
 				return fmt.Errorf("removing container %s that depends on volume %s: %w", ctr.ID(), v.Name(), err)
 			}
 		}

test/e2e/pod_rm_test.go

@@ -318,4 +318,31 @@ var _ = Describe("Podman pod rm", func() {
 		result.WaitWithDefaultTimeout()
 		Expect(result).Should(Exit(0))
 	})
+
+	It("podman pod rm pod with infra container and running container", func() {
+		podName := "testPod"
+		ctrName := "testCtr"
+
+		ctrAndPod := podmanTest.Podman([]string{"run", "-d", "--pod", fmt.Sprintf("new:%s", podName), "--name", ctrName, ALPINE, "top"})
+		ctrAndPod.WaitWithDefaultTimeout()
+		Expect(ctrAndPod).Should(Exit(0))
+
+		removePod := podmanTest.Podman([]string{"pod", "rm", "-a"})
+		removePod.WaitWithDefaultTimeout()
+		Expect(removePod).Should(Not(Exit(0)))
+
+		ps := podmanTest.Podman([]string{"pod", "ps"})
+		ps.WaitWithDefaultTimeout()
+		Expect(ps).Should(Exit(0))
+		Expect(ps.OutputToString()).To(ContainSubstring(podName))
+
+		removePodForce := podmanTest.Podman([]string{"pod", "rm", "-af"})
+		removePodForce.WaitWithDefaultTimeout()
+		Expect(removePodForce).Should(Exit(0))
+
+		ps2 := podmanTest.Podman([]string{"pod", "ps"})
+		ps2.WaitWithDefaultTimeout()
+		Expect(ps2).Should(Exit(0))
+		Expect(ps2.OutputToString()).To(Not(ContainSubstring(podName)))
+	})
 })