on plots tab add sorting for barcharts #4893

SURAJ-SHARMA27 · 2024-04-16T11:11:43Z

Describe changes proposed in this pull request:

I have created a dropdown field named 'Sort' which currently contains two options: 'Sort by Alphabet' and 'Sort by Count'. By default, 'Sort by Alphabet' is selected. I implemented the logic for 'Sort by Count' as follows:

i) I passed the 'sortOption' prop throughout the plot components.
ii) In 'MultipleCategoryBarPlotUtils.ts', I added a case where if the 'sortOption' is 'sortByCount', it creates an array named 'totalSumArray'. This array stores fields defined by the interface:

interface TotalSumItem {
    majorCategory: string;
    sum: number;
    minorCategory: { name: string; count: number; percentage: number.. }[];
}

Then, I sorted the above array with respect to 'sum', and finally returned the individually sorted array. I implemented the same for sorted labels.

Checks

Has tests or has a separate issue that describes the types of test that should be created. If no test is included it should explicitly be mentioned in the PR why there is no test.
The commit log is comprehensible. It follows 7 rules of great commit messages. For most PRs a single commit should suffice, in some cases multiple topical commits can be useful. During review it is ok to see tiny commits (e.g. Fix reviewer comments), but right before the code gets merged to master or rc branch, any such commits should be squashed since they are useless to the other developers. Definitely avoid merge commits, use rebase instead.
Is this PR adding logic based on one or more clinical attributes? If yes, please make sure validation for this attribute is also present in the data validation / data loading layers (in backend repo) and documented in File-Formats Clinical data section!

Any screenshots or GIFs?

Screencast.from.2024-04-16.15-48-09.webm

netlify · 2024-04-16T11:11:58Z

✅ Deploy Preview for cbioportalfrontend ready!

Name	Link
🔨 Latest commit	`ece5a45`
🔍 Latest deploy log	https://app.netlify.com/sites/cbioportalfrontend/deploys/66307d5e564ec400082ec82f
😎 Deploy Preview	https://deploy-preview-4893--cbioportalfrontend.netlify.app
📱 Preview on mobile	Toggle QR Code... Use your smartphone camera to open QR code link.

To edit notification comments on pull requests, go to your Netlify site configuration.

I missed one simple condition ,now I have added it. This searching functionality will only work for stacked bar graphs.

src/pages/groupComparison/MultipleCategoryBarPlot.tsx

src/shared/components/plots/MultipleCategoryBarPlotUtils.ts

gblaih · 2024-04-25T20:13:58Z

src/shared/components/plots/MultipleCategoryBarPlotUtils.ts

    // reverse the order of stacked or horizontal bars
    if ((!horizontalBars && stacked) || (horizontalBars && !stacked)) {
        data = _.reverse(data);
    }
+    console.log(data, 'iscalled2');
+    data.forEach(item => {


this whole logic looks similar to the one above

cbioportal-frontend/src/pages/groupComparison/MultipleCategoryBarPlot.tsx

Line 440 in a05006d

this.data.forEach(item => {

would be great if we could make a helper function with all this logic to minimize duplicate code.

agreed! can this be DRY'd?

gblaih · 2024-04-25T20:16:39Z

src/shared/components/plots/PlotsTab.tsx

+            console.log(selectedOption, 'thisisselectedoptions');
+            console.log(this.sortOption, 'thisSOrtts');
+            this.sortOption = selectedOption.value;
+            // this.setState({ sortOption: selectedOption.value });


we can remove these comments now

SURAJ-SHARMA27 · 2024-04-27T05:56:54Z

@gblaih I have made nearly all the changes you suggested. Could you please review them and merge the branch if everything looks good?

gblaih · 2024-04-29T20:35:11Z

src/pages/groupComparison/MultipleCategoryBarPlot.tsx

+
+        const sortedLabels = totalSumArray.map(item => item.majorCategory);
+
+        if (this.props.sortOption == 'sortByCount') {


i think we can move all the logic above this to inside this if block as we only need to calculate sortedLabels when sortOption is sortByCount. same for the similar function in MultipleCategoryBarPlotUtils.ts

gblaih · 2024-04-29T20:38:05Z

src/shared/components/plots/MultipleCategoryBarPlotUtils.ts

+interface TotalSumItem {
+    majorCategory: string;
+    sum: number;
+    minorCategory: { name: string; count: number; percentage: number }[];
+}

+export { TotalSumItem };


we can delete this and just import and use the one you made here

cbioportal-frontend/src/pages/groupComparison/MultipleCategoryBarPlot.tsx

Line 63 in 1c2a8f4

export interface TotalSumItem {

gblaih · 2024-04-29T20:40:46Z

src/shared/components/plots/MultipleCategoryBarPlotUtils.ts

+
+        const finals = minorCategoryArrays[minorCategory];
+
+        let categoriezedCounts;


categorizedCounts

gblaih · 2024-04-29T20:44:55Z

src/pages/groupComparison/ClinicalData.tsx

@@ -937,6 +937,7 @@ export default class ClinicalData extends React.Component<
                                    ? this.highlightedRow.qValue
                                    : null
                            }
+                            sortOption={'sortByAlphabet'}


we can probably delete this and the other instances of passing sortByAlphabet throughout the code now that we made sortOption optional and we've taken care of the case when sortOption is not sortByCount

gblaih · 2024-04-29T20:56:53Z

@SURAJ-SHARMA27 added a couple minor comments to be addressed but looks good overall. thanks!

SURAJ-SHARMA27 · 2024-04-30T05:08:51Z

@gblaih , I have made all the changes suggested. Could you review it once more?

alisman · 2024-05-01T19:59:26Z

src/pages/groupComparison/MultipleCategoryBarPlot.tsx

@@ -424,12 +435,56 @@ export default class MultipleCategoryBarPlot extends React.Component<
    }

    @computed get labels() {
+        if (this.props.sortOption == 'sortByCount') {


@SURAJ-SHARMA27 this is going to actually mutate the sorting of counts in this.data. i.e. sort it in place. instead, we should use functional/immutable approach to return a sorted list of labels without mutating underlying data.

I have removed the mutable approach and created a separate totalSumArray, which does not make any changes to this.data

alisman · 2024-05-01T20:06:33Z

src/pages/groupComparison/MultipleCategoryBarPlot.tsx

+                    a.majorCategory.localeCompare(b.majorCategory)
+                );
+            });
+            const totalSumArray: TotalSumItem[] = [];


this code is quite confusing. it would be clearer if you used _.sortBy(collection, ()=>); where the return of the callback is a _.sum of the item counts within.

The logic is that I will traverse this.data and will make one totalSumArray array which has a schema like:

{ majorCategory: countItem.majorCategory, sum: countItem.count, minorCategory: [ { name: item.minorCategory, count: countItem.count, percentage: countItem.percentage, }, ], }

Now, I will traverse this.data and go to each majorCategory to update the totalSum in which i will store the count of each object. Then, I will sort the totalSumArray with respect to totalSum and extract the information as per the requirements like label and majorCategory.

Let's take an example. For one configuration, this.data contains:

{ 0: { minorCategory: 'Male', counts: Array(42) }, 1: { minorCategory: 'Female', counts: Array(42) } }

I will traverse each object, go to the counts array, and create one object for like Melanoma in totalSumArray in which I will store the information and sum of counts for each object. Then, I will sort the totalSumArray according to sum and retrieve the labels from there.

alisman · 2024-05-01T20:07:30Z

src/pages/groupComparison/MultipleCategoryBarPlot.tsx

@@ -424,12 +435,56 @@ export default class MultipleCategoryBarPlot extends React.Component<
    }

    @computed get labels() {
+        if (this.props.sortOption == 'sortByCount') {
+            _.forEach(this.data, item => {


i'm curious why you need to sort alphabetical first. you should put comments explaining each step.

I was sorting the elements alphabetically first so that all the elements in each object would come in the same order, allowing me to calculate the count corresponding to each element accurately. For example:

data = { 0: { minorCategory: 'Male', counts: Array(42) }, 1: { minorCategory: 'Female', counts: Array(42) } }

Let's say, in the array containing 42 elements in the Male minorCategory, the first index is X, and in the Female minorCategory, the first index is Y in counts. If I calculate sum_of_total_counts = data[0].counts[0].count + data[1].counts[1].count, the sum_of_total_counts calculated is incorrect because it adds the counts for X and Y. However, if I sort it alphabetically, the counts array for each minorCategory will be in the same order, and I can find the total count easily.

alisman · 2024-05-01T20:08:54Z

src/pages/groupComparison/MultipleCategoryBarPlot.tsx

@@ -739,7 +794,8 @@ export default class MultipleCategoryBarPlot extends React.Component<
            this.categoryCoord,
            !!this.props.horizontalBars,
            !!this.props.stacked,
-            !!this.props.percentage
+            !!this.props.percentage,
+            this.props.sortOption || 'sortByAlphabet'


you should probably apply this default inside the makeBarSpec

alisman · 2024-05-01T20:10:15Z

src/shared/components/plots/PlotsTab.tsx

@@ -4448,6 +4464,32 @@ export default class PlotsTab extends React.Component<IPlotsTabProps, {}> {
                            </label>
                        </div>
                    )}
+                    {this.isStacked && (this.plotType.result==3) && (


can we make the 3 into an Enum so it's human understandable?

alisman · 2024-05-01T20:12:39Z

src/shared/components/plots/PlotsTab.tsx

@@ -5193,7 +5235,16 @@ export default class PlotsTab extends React.Component<IPlotsTabProps, {}> {
            DownloadControlOption.SHOW_ALL
        );
    }
-
+    get isStacked() {
+        const isPercentage =


confusing structure. clearer if get rid of isPercentage local var and you just spell it out:

A === B || A === C

alisman

@SURAJ-SHARMA27 i think the code here can be improved. the biggest issue is the sorting of what should be immutable data. see comments. one good rule of thumb is to avoid forEach. The reason is that forEach forces you do do a sideeffect because it isn't "functional". It doesn't simply return a new thing (e.g. a sorted array that is a computation of underlying array). Always use more specific operators like map/reduce/sort etc. Learing the full set of Lodash functions will help you.

alisman · 2024-05-13T14:36:09Z

@SURAJ-SHARMA27 have you had a chance to look at these comments?

SURAJ-SHARMA27 · 2024-05-22T16:57:32Z

@SURAJ-SHARMA27 have you had a chance to look at these comments?

Actually, my laptop's RAM was causing issues, which is why the repository was not running locally.

inodb · 2024-10-24T14:37:41Z

This is superseded by: #4960

sorting-functionality-enabled

6cfd7c7

Update PlotsTab.tsx

a05006d

I missed one simple condition ,now I have added it. This searching functionality will only work for stacked bar graphs.

inodb added the gsoc label Apr 25, 2024

inodb requested a review from gblaih April 25, 2024 14:50

inodb added the cl-external-api External API section of changelog. Changes to handle an external API (i.e. not cBioPortal API) label Apr 25, 2024

inodb changed the title ~~sorting-functionality-enabled~~ on plots tab add sorting for barcharts Apr 25, 2024

inodb added enhancement and removed cl-external-api External API section of changelog. Changes to handle an external API (i.e. not cBioPortal API) labels Apr 25, 2024