Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

How will i do a pagination or lazy loading? #32

Open
arunkrishna39 opened this issue Jul 18, 2017 · 36 comments
Open

How will i do a pagination or lazy loading? #32

arunkrishna39 opened this issue Jul 18, 2017 · 36 comments

Comments

@arunkrishna39
Copy link

No description provided.

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Jul 18, 2017

Your issue doesn't follow our guidelines. Please fix the following:

  • Issue description cannot be empty (?)

Click here for details.

Thank you! 🙏

This comment was made by GitMagic – Magically enforcing your contribution guidelines.

@brh55
Copy link
Owner

brh55 commented Jul 18, 2017

Hey @arunkrishna39, Sorry I don't have either functionality implemented, but I do plan on implementing Lazy Loading when my current application development process is at this stage.

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

srameshr commented Jul 22, 2017

@brh55 Eagerly waiting! Any time estimates?

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

srameshr commented Sep 7, 2017

@brh55 Now that masonry implements flatlist, we should have this feature with onEndReached and ListFooterComponent right?

@kmcgill88
Copy link
Collaborator

@srameshr I believe the answer is no, not yet. @brh55's implementation of FlatList has not been merged yet. See #39

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

@kmcgill88 Flatlist has been merged, but the FlatList has been wrapped by a ListView which has been deprecated.

@vvavepacket
Copy link

@srameshr do you think that if we add our own implementation in FlatList's onEndReached() and onRefresh(), we could do ininite scroll/pagination out of the box?

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

What I am doing right now is, passing refresh component to ListView.
Can you do a FlatList rewrite of the ListView implementation under Masonry.js

@brh55
Copy link
Owner

brh55 commented Sep 27, 2017

I've done a FlatList rewrite within the experiment branch -- it works, but not efficiently. Looks to be some sort of delay with the re-render time.

@vvavepacket
Copy link

guys, I dig deep into the code, and saw that FlatList is present inside Column.js (master branch). Now, I tried to add methods like onEndReached(). I noticed it is called during rendering when images are loading.. But if I try to manually scroll down, it doesn't get called. Any idea what to do so we can have FlatList's onEndReached() method works to enable pagination?

@vvavepacket
Copy link

@brh55 can you confirm that FlatList rewrite is only for 0.3.x version?
@srameshr do you mean to create a FlatList rewrite for the master/0.4.x/latest one?

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

srameshr commented Oct 2, 2017

@brh55 @vvavepacket I am on the master branch and there is a big delay during inital rendering.

There are two things here:

  1. These is a ListView inside Masonry.js
  2. There WAS list view inside Column.js but now it has been converted to flat list.

I am guessing that the ListView inside Masonry.js is responsible for the terrible rendering time.

@brh55
Copy link
Owner

brh55 commented Oct 2, 2017

If ListView is responsible then it's most likely the dataSource diff function. A quick way to check this is with removing line 19 + 42 in masonry, and replacing rowHasChanged with returning true and seeing if perhaps this is where the issue may lie.

@brh55
Copy link
Owner

brh55 commented Oct 2, 2017

@srameshr Could you give that a try on your app, and see if you notice any improvements?

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

srameshr commented Oct 3, 2017

@brh55 Nope! Its still the same. It takes 15 seconds to render just one image.

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

srameshr commented Oct 3, 2017

@brh55 I got it. I think its because of the remote images. If I serve it with static images, it renders in a flash but when the images are remote, it takes 15 seconds at minimum.
I'm assuming its because you are calculating the dimensions of the image before rendering.
Is it possible to just render the grid with minimumHeight and then insert images after it has been downloaded and the dimensions are calculated?

My bad! My images take 14 seconds to download on a web browser! Crazy! Im on AWS M4 xLarge instance.

@brh55
Copy link
Owner

brh55 commented Oct 3, 2017

What are your image sizes? It's deceiving on the apps and this component because they are resizing, but good role of thumb is 300kb or less. Unless it's high def is important of course.

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

srameshr commented Oct 3, 2017

2.7 MB 😝
Im using a resizer now!

@brh55
Copy link
Owner

brh55 commented Oct 3, 2017

@srameshr best way to kill my bandwidth 🗡

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

srameshr commented Oct 3, 2017

@brh55 Sorry for that. Il make sure I cross verify before posting an issue.

@brh55
Copy link
Owner

brh55 commented Oct 3, 2017

@srameshr haha no worries

@vvavepacket
Copy link

Were you guys able to implement pagination by using flatlist's onRefresh/onEndReached() methods?

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

srameshr commented Oct 3, 2017

@vvavepacket Since the Masonry.js file still has ListView, I do something like #51.
See the last but one comment in that.

@vvavepacket
Copy link

@srameshr i see that #51 is for pull to refresh. Did you tried about doing continous loading, like when user reaches bottom of list, the flatlist will continosuly fetch new data and add it?

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

srameshr commented Oct 3, 2017

No, I have not yet tried that. But hopefully by the time I need it, ListView gets replaced by FlatList under masonry which supports InfinteLoading and Pull to refresh.

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

srameshr commented Oct 3, 2017

ezgif-4-2810d897af
@brh55 I think the elements in the grid that are not downloaded should have an empty placeholder at least with a loading icon. See the demo attached. After I refresh the view, the GIF that is in the second position is not rendered until its completely loaded.

I would suggest just returning the header and footer with the actual image being a <ActivityIndicator /> or any placeholder with a certain height.

@kesha-antonov
Copy link

Hello guys!
How's it going?

Is it possible now to do loadMoreResults on onEndReached?

@srameshr
Copy link
Contributor

@brh55 so infinite loading is a feature that lot of people are waiting for. FlatList provides it out of the box since it inherits ScrollView props.

So, until the ListView remains in Masonry.js, I dont think there is any way to provide this feature.

@brh55
Copy link
Owner

brh55 commented Nov 13, 2017

@srameshr I feel you, give me some time to think about a good way to implement this. I have two possible ways, but unsure of potential side-effects and can foresee a lot of potential bugs arising

@vvavepacket
Copy link

@brh55 let us know if u need to test out your idea :) we are ready testers any time :) , this feature looks promising and is in great need and will make plugin more awesome

@davidsamacoits
Copy link

Hey guys! Any news about the infinite loading/scroll feature? Is it working now?

@vvavepacket
Copy link

vvavepacket commented Mar 26, 2018 via email

@brh55
Copy link
Owner

brh55 commented Mar 31, 2018

@davidsamacoits @vvavepacket Sorry ya'll been extremely busy at work and have had to put off a lot of OSS activities. So I'm definitely looking for co-maintainers, open for PR's and we can put together an implementation on this.

@kikoseijo
Copy link

Hi people!

Regarding this awesome library, Has anyone got an example with Relay? just wondering!

Best regards!

@abhinav011085
Copy link

@brh55 is this done? Eagerly waiting for this feature.

@brh55
Copy link
Owner

brh55 commented Jul 10, 2018

@abhinav011085 There is infinite scroll, it's not actually documented officially, but it's shown in the example.

Here is how it's passed in as props:

onEndReached={this._addData}

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

9 participants