For Cycle 22

[wiz]

Since DAO cycle 20 failed and DAO cycle 21 was over the issuance limit, this is my compensation request for cycles 20, 21, and 22 combined. Since my stuff is the same for each cycle I'm using the average rate of 70 cents, 80 cents, and 121 cents = 90 cents for simple calculation.

Summary

• BSQ requested: 4666
• USD requested: 4200
• BSQ rate: 0.90 USD per BSQ
• Previous compensation request (if applicable): For Cycle 20 #753 (failed)

Contributions delivered in Cycle 20

Title	Team	USD	Link	Notes
Mempool Explorer Operator (2x)	ops*	400	bisq-network/roles#107	mempool.space, mempool.ninja
Bitcoin Node Operator (4x)	ops*	200	bisq-network/roles#67	node100,node140,node210,node220
Bisq Analytics Operator (1x)	ops*	100	bisq-network/roles#88	matomo.bisq.network
Bisq Markets Operator (2x)	ops*	200	bisq-network/roles#9	bisq.markets
Bisq Pricenode Operator (1x)	ops*	100	bisq-network/roles#14	price.bisq.wiz.biz
Bisq Seednode Operator (3x)	ops*	300	bisq-network/roles#15	wizseed3, wizseed7, wizseeds
Bisq Wiki Operator (1x)	ops*	100	bisq-network/roles#92	bisq.wiki

Contributions delivered in Cycle 21

Title	Team	USD	Link	Notes
Mempool Explorer Operator (2x)	ops*	400	bisq-network/roles#107	mempool.space, mempool.ninja
Bitcoin Node Operator (4x)	ops*	200	bisq-network/roles#67	node100,node140,node210,node220
Bisq Analytics Operator (1x)	ops*	100	bisq-network/roles#88	matomo.bisq.network
Bisq Markets Operator (2x)	ops*	200	bisq-network/roles#9	bisq.markets
Bisq Pricenode Operator (1x)	ops*	100	bisq-network/roles#14	price.bisq.wiz.biz
Bisq Seednode Operator (3x)	ops*	300	bisq-network/roles#15	wizseed3, wizseed7, wizseeds
Bisq Wiki Operator (1x)	ops*	100	bisq-network/roles#92	bisq.wiki

Contributions delivered in Cycle 22

Title	Team	USD	Link	Notes
Mempool Explorer Operator (2x)	ops*	400	bisq-network/roles#107	mempool.space, mempool.ninja
Bitcoin Node Operator (4x)	ops*	200	bisq-network/roles#67	node100,node140,node210,node220
Bisq Analytics Operator (1x)	ops*	100	bisq-network/roles#88	matomo.bisq.network
Bisq Markets Operator (2x)	ops*	200	bisq-network/roles#9	bisq.markets
Bisq Pricenode Operator (1x)	ops*	100	bisq-network/roles#14	price.bisq.wiz.biz
Bisq Seednode Operator (3x)	ops*	300	bisq-network/roles#15	wizseed3, wizseed7, wizseeds
Bisq Wiki Operator (1x)	ops*	100	bisq-network/roles#92	bisq.wiki

[ghost]

Info

Read BSQ amount from summary: 4516
Read USD amount from summary: 4200
Read BSQ rate from summary: 0.93
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":400}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":300}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":400}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":300}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":400}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":300}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}

Errors

Incorrect BSQ rate specified: 0.93, expected: 0.75
ERROR: Total BSQ does not match the sum of line items:

• Summary total: 4516.00 BSQ
• Calculated total: 5600.00 BSQ

[ghost]

Info

Read BSQ amount from summary: 4666
Read USD amount from summary: 4200
Read BSQ rate from summary: 0.9
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":400}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":300}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":400}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":300}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":400}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":200}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":300}
Parsed lineitem: {"team":"ops","amount":100}

Errors

Incorrect BSQ rate specified: 0.90, expected: 1.21
ERROR: Total BSQ does not match the sum of line items:

• Summary total: 4666.00 BSQ
• Calculated total: 3471.07 BSQ

[wiz]

b63cba89e376a9c12afc3504eae6c76a77aeadeebf3ba5c619e31d53d212ad48

[RefundAgent]

This compensation request uses a rate of 0.9 USD for one BSQ, whereas the spotprice is 2.7 USD for one BSQ.

[MwithM]

This proposal is using the same method to calculate the BSQ rate as for Cycle 21 and it was considered that this could happen on this cycle as some of them retrieved from asking for compensation on Cycle 21. #782 (comment)
After some discussion during this cycle, I made a proposal to use 30D average in order to reduce this difference between spot and compensation prices. bisq-network/proposals#313

[wiz]

@RefundAgent hey remember that time you paid out an extra 2 BTC to someone and the DAO bailed you out?

[RefundAgent]

@wiz I also remember your position concerning this mistake. But I guess this time is different since there is no mistake involved.

@MwithM The method is still completely wrong and to use a 30 day average as some "compromise" has no advantage at all. All investors in Bisq that I know about have sold the majority of their BSQ due to the lack of business sense in Bisq.

[MwithM]

This needs to be reviewed @bisq-network/team-leads

[ripcurlx]

As it would have been this amount of BSQ created if the CR would have been approved in the respective cycles I approve this request as dev team lead.

[ghost]

Issuance cannot be displayed as there were errors in the comp request

[MwithM]

Closed as accepted.