OptionsToString Incremental Source Generator

Problem: I have a configuration class for use with IOptions and I want to safely log out its values at runtime.

Solution: Use an incremental source generator to generate an extension method to get a string with masked values for the properties.

The methods to mask the values can be used outside of the generated code, too. See below for details.

This package generates an OptionsToString extension method for a class. Using attributes you can control how the values are masked. You can use this to log out the values of your configuration at startup, or via a REST endpoint.

Quick Example

Edit the source of your configuration class and decorate it with attributes.

namespace Test;

[OptionsToString]
internal class PropertySimple
{
    [OutputMask]
    public string Secret { get; set; } = "Secret";

    public int RetryLimit { get; set; } = 5;

    [OutputRegex(Regex = "User Id=([^;]+).*Password=([^;]+)")]
    public string ConnectionString { get; set; } = "Server=myServerAddress;Database=myDataBase;User Id=myUsername;Password=myPassword;";
}

// usage
_logger.LogInformation(new PropertySimple().OptionsToString());

Output:

Test.PropertySimple:
  Secret           : "******"
  RetryLimit       : 5
  ConnectionString : "Server=myServerAddress;Database=myDataBase;User Id=***;Password=***;"

Alternatively, if you don't have the code for PropertySimple this will produce the same output.

internal class PropertyConfig
{
    [OutputPropertyMask(nameof(IOptionsSimple.Secret))]
    [OutputPropertyRegex(nameof(IOptionsSimple.ConnectionString), Regex = "User Id=([^;]+).*Password=([^;]+)")]
    public PropertySimple? PropertySimple { get; set; }
}

// usage
_logger.LogInformation(new PropertyConfig().PropertySimple.OptionsToString());

Usage

Add the OptionToStringGenerator NuGet package to your project.
If you can update the class
1. Decorate a class with the OptionsToString attribute.
2. Optionally decorate properties with an Output* attribute to specify how you want them to be masked. If you don't decorate a property, its full text is dumped out.
If you don't want to or can't update the class
1. Add a property to your class of the Type you want to dump out.
2. Decorate the property with multiple OutputProperty* attributes to control how the properties are masked.

Example of Editing a Class

Here's a larger sample class that uses all the different types of masking. Anything without an attribute has its value written out in the clear. The output follows.

namespace Test;
using Seekatar.OptionToStringGenerator;

[OptionsToString]
public class PublicOptions
{
    public class AClass
    {
        public string Name { get; set; } = "maybe this is secret";
        public override string ToString() => $"{nameof(AClass)}: {Name}";
    }

    public string PlainText { get; set; } = "hi mom";

    public char Why { get; set; } = 'Y';

    public int PlainInt { get; set; } = 42;

    public double PlainDouble { get; set; } = 3.141;

    public double PlainDecimal { get; set; } = 6.02;

    public DateTime PlainDateTime { get; set; } = new DateTime(2020, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5);

    public DateOnly PlainDatOnly { get; set; } = new DateOnly(2020, 1, 2);

    public TimeOnly PlainTimeOnly { get; set; } = new TimeOnly(12, 23, 2);

    public TimeSpan TimeSpan { get; set; } = new TimeSpan(1, 2, 3, 4, 5);

    public Guid UUID { get; set; } = Guid.Parse("6536b25c-3a45-48d8-8ea3-756e19f5bad1");

    public string? NullItem { get; set; }

    public AClass AnObject { get; set; } = new();

    [OutputRegex(Regex = @"AClass\:\s+(.*)")]
    public AClass AMaskedObject { get; set; } = new();

    [OutputMask]
    public string FullyMasked { get; set; } = "thisisasecret";

    [OutputMask(PrefixLen=3)]
    public string FirstThreeNotMasked { get; set; } = "abc1233435667";

    [OutputMask(SuffixLen=3)]
    public string LastThreeNotMasked { get; set; } = "abc1233435667";

    [OutputMask(PrefixLen = 3, SuffixLen=3)]
    public string FirstAndLastThreeNotMasked { get; set; } = "abc1233435667";

    [OutputMask(PrefixLen = 100)]
    public string NotMaskedSinceLongLength { get; set; } = "abc1233435667";

    [OutputLengthOnly]
    public string LengthOnly { get; set; } = "thisisasecretthatonlyshowsthelength";

    [OutputRegex(Regex="User Id=([^;]+).*Password=([^;]+)")]
    public string MaskUserAndPassword { get; set; } = "Server=server;Database=db;User Id=myUsername;Password=myPassword;";

    [OutputRegex(Regex="User Id=([^;]+).*Password=([^;]+)",IgnoreCase=true)]
    public string MaskUserAndPasswordIgnoreCase { get; set; } = "Server=server;Database=db;user Id=myUsername;Password=myPassword;";

    [OutputRegex(Regex = "User Id=([^;]+).*Password=([^;]+)")]
    public string RegexNotMatched { get; set; } = "Server=server;Database=db;user Id=myUsername;Password=myPassword;";

    public ConsoleColor Color { get; set; } = ConsoleColor.Red;

    [OutputIgnore]
    public string IgnoreMe { get; set; } = "abc1233435667";
}

// usage
var options = new PublicOptions();
_logger.LogInformation(options.OptionsToString());

The output has the class name (by default) followed by an indented list of all the properties' values masked as specified.

Test.PublicOptions:
  PlainText                     : "hi mom"
  Why                           : "Y"
  PlainInt                      : 42
  PlainDouble                   : 3.141
  PlainDecimal                  : 6.02
  PlainDateTime                 : 01/02/2020 03:04:05
  PlainDatOnly                  : 01/02/2020
  PlainTimeOnly                 : 12:23
  TimeSpan                      : 1.02:03:04.0050000
  UUID                          : 6536b25c-3a45-48d8-8ea3-756e19f5bad1
  NullItem                      : null
  AnObject                      : "AClass: maybe this is secret"
  AMaskedObject                 : "AClass: ***"
  FullyMasked                   : "*************"
  FirstThreeNotMasked           : "abc**********"
  LastThreeNotMasked            : "**********667"
  FirstAndLastThreeNotMasked    : "abc*******667"
  NotMaskedSinceLongLength      : "abc1233435667"
  LengthOnly                    : Len = 35
  MaskUserAndPassword           : "Server=server;Database=db;User Id=***;Password=***;"
  MaskUserAndPasswordIgnoreCase : "Server=server;Database=db;user Id=***;Password=***;"
  RegexNotMatched               : "***Regex no match***!"
  Color                         : Red

Example of Using a Property

Here's a similar example where you don't have the source for the class, or don't want to change it. In this case, you use multiple OutputProperty* attributes, one for each property you want to mask.

This is from the tests where PropertyPublicClass is identical to PublicOptions, so the output will be the same aside from the class name.

namespace Test;
using Seekatar.OptionToStringGenerator;

public class PropertyTestOptions
{
    public MyClass(IOption<PropertyPublicClass> options, ILogger<PropertyTestOptions> logger)
    {
        _options =options.Value;
        logger.LogInformation(options.OptionsToString());
    }

    [OutputPropertyRegex(nameof(PropertyPublicClass.AMaskedObject), Regex = @"AClass\:\s+(.*)")]
    [OutputPropertyMask(nameof(PropertyPublicClass.FullyMasked))]
    [OutputPropertyMask(nameof(PropertyPublicClass.FirstThreeNotMasked), PrefixLen = 3)]
    [OutputPropertyMask(nameof(PropertyPublicClass.LastThreeNotMasked), SuffixLen = 3)]
    [OutputPropertyMask(nameof(PropertyPublicClass.FirstAndLastThreeNotMasked), PrefixLen = 3, SuffixLen = 3)]
    [OutputPropertyMask(nameof(PropertyPublicClass.NotMaskedSinceLongLength), PrefixLen = 100)]
    [OutputPropertyLengthOnly(nameof(PropertyPublicClass.LengthOnly))]
    [OutputPropertyRegex(nameof(PropertyPublicClass.MaskUserAndPassword), Regex = "User Id=([^;]+).*Password=([^;]+)")]
    [OutputPropertyRegex(nameof(PropertyPublicClass.MaskUserAndPasswordIgnoreCase), Regex = "User Id=([^;]+).*Password=([^;]+)", IgnoreCase = true)]
    [OutputPropertyRegex(nameof(PropertyPublicClass.RegexNotMatched), Regex = "User Id=([^;]+).*Password=([^;]+)")]
    [OutputPropertyIgnore(nameof(PropertyPublicClass.IgnoreMe) )]
    public PropertyPublicClass? PublicClass { get; set; }
}

Notes

All public properties are included by default and output as plain text.
Properties will be in the order they are defined in the class, unless Sort=true is set on the OptionsToString attribute.
Parent class properties are included by default. Use ExcludeParents = true on the OptionsToString attribute to exclude them.
Use the OutputIgnore attribute to exclude a property.
ToString() is called on the property's value, then the mask is applied. You can have a custom ToString() method on a class to format its output then it will be masked as the AClass example above.
When editing the class, only one Output* attribute is allowed per property. If more than one is set, you'll get a compile warning, and the last attribute set will be used.
Regex strings with back slashes need to use a verbatim string or escape the back slashes (e.g. @"\s+" or "\\s+").
OutputRegex must have a Regex parameter, or you'll get a compile error.
If the regex doesn't match the value, the output will be ***Regex no match***! to indicate it didn't match.
To customize the formatting of masked output see below

Formatting Options

There are properties on the OptionsToStringAttribute for classes and OutputPropertyFormat for properties to control how the output is generated.

Name	Description	Default
`Indent`	The indenting string	" " (Two spaces)
`Separator`	The name-value separator	":"
`Title`	The title to use for the output. See below	Class name
`Json`	Format the output as JSON	false
`Sort`	Sort the properties	false

In addition to literal text, the Title parameter can include property names in braces. For example

// for a class
[OptionsToString(Title = nameof(TitleOptions) + "_{StringProp}_{IntProp}")]
public class TitleOptions
{
    public int IntProp { get; set; } = 42;
    public string StringProp { get; set; } = "hi mom";
}

// for a property
internal class PropertyTestSimple
{
    [OutputPropertyFormat(Title = nameof(TitleOptions) + "_{StringProp}_{IntProp}")]
    public TitleOptions TitleOptions { get; set; } = new ();
}

Both will output

TitleOptions_hi mom_42:
  IntProp    : 42
  StringProp : "hi mom"

Per-Property Formatting Options

For types that take a format string to ToString() such as DateTime, numbers, etc., you can use the OutputFormatToString attribute. You can also supply a custom method to format a property. For example flattening an array and masking its values. The sample below shows a few examples:

    # comma separate thousands
    [OutputFormatToString("N0")]
    public int PlainInt { get; set; } = 423433;

    # two decimal places
    [OutputFormatToString("0.00")]
    public double PlainDouble { get; set; } = 3.141;

    # use the U format for DateTime
    [OutputFormatToString("R")]
    public DateTime PlainDateTime { get; set; } = new DateTime(2020, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5);

    [OutputFormatProvider(typeof(FormatOptions), nameof(MyFormatter))]
    public List<string> Secrets { get; set; } = new List<string> { "secret", "hushhush", "psssst" };

    # mask each string in the array showing only the first 3 characters
    public static string? MyFormatter(List<string> o)
    {
        if (o is null) return null;
        return string.Join(",", o.Select(s => Mask.MaskSuffix(s, 3)));
    }

Output:

  PlainInt      : 423,433
  PlainDouble   : 3.14
  PlainDateTime : Thu, 02 Jan 2020 03:04:05 GMT
  Secrets       : "sec***,hus*****,pss***"

Collections

Instead of using OutputFormatProvider, you can create your own method to handle collections. The MessagingOptions test class does so by overriding ToString to get its options and all the children.

public override string ToString()
{
    var sb = new StringBuilder(this.OptionsToString());
    sb.AppendLine();
    foreach (var c in Consumers ?? new Dictionary<string, ClientOptions>())
    {
        sb.AppendLine(c.Value.OptionsToString());
    }
    foreach (var p in Producers ?? new Dictionary<string, ClientOptions>())
    {
        sb.AppendLine(p.Value.OptionsToString());
    }

    return sb.ToString();
}

Nested Classes

If you have an option class that contains another option class, do not set any attributes the property, and the OptionsToString will be called on the nested class, with extra indent of the parent class.

[OptionsToString] // use default indent of two spaces
class NestedOptions
{
    [OutputMask(PrefixLen = 3)]
    public string NestedSecret { get; set; } = "ChildSecret";
}

[OptionsToString]
class ParentOfNested
{
    [OutputMask(PrefixLen = 3)]
    public string Secret { get; set; } = "ParentSecret";

    public NestedOptions Nested { get; set; } = new();
}

Will produce this:

Test.ParentOfNested:
  Secret : "Par*********"
  Nested : Test.NestedOptions:
    NestedSecret : "Chi********" 👈 This line has 2x parent indent

Attributes

For a class use these attributes.

Name	On	Description
OptionsToString	Class	Marker for the class, and has formatting options
OutputMask	Member	Mask the value with asterisks, with optional prefix and suffix clear
OutputRegex	Member	Mask the value with a regex
OutputLengthOnly	Member	Only output the length of the value
OutputIgnore	Member	Ignore the property
OutputFormatToString	Member	Format the value using ToString() with a format string
OutputFormatProvider	Member	Format the value using a custom method

For a property, use these attributes on the property

Name	Description
OutputPropertyFormat	Optional Formatting options
OutputPropertyMask	Mask the value with asterisks, with optional prefix and suffix
OutputPropertyRegex	Mask the value with a regex
OutputPropertyLengthOnly	Only output the length of the value
OutputPropertyIgnore	Ignore the property

Warnings and Errors

If attributes have invalid parameters you will get warnings or errors from the compiler. They are documented here.

Trouble Shooting

Error CS9057

You may get an error when compiling your code that uses this package.

##[error]#15 7.135 CSC : error CS9057: The analyzer assembly '/root/.nuget/packages/seekatar.optiontostringgenerator/0.1.4/analyzers/dotnet/cs/Seekatar.OptionToStringGenerator.dll' references version '4.6.0.0' of the compiler, which is newer than the currently running version '4.4.0.0'.

You must use the .NET SDK 6.0.416 or higher. You can check your version with dotnet --list-sdks.

Using Seekatar.Mask

The methods used by the generated code to mask a value are available when you include the source generator NuGet package. They are in the Seekatar.Mask namespace.

using static Seekatar.Mask;

...
MaskSuffix("abc123", 3) // returns "abc***"

Methods are as follows. Each of these corresponds to an attribute as described above. All take object? and return string?. Check each for parameters that control usage.

Method	Description
MaskAll	Return a string of the same length as the input, with all characters masked
MaskLengthOnly	Return `Len <length>`
MaskPrefix	Mask the prefix of the string, showing only a few suffix characters
MaskPrefixSuffix	Show only a few prefix and suffix characters
MaskRegex	Mask capture groups of a regex
MaskSuffix	Mask the suffix of the string, showing only a few prefix characters

Implementation

Big shout out to Andrew Lock and his blog series on incremental source generators. I used that as a starting point for this project.

His blog tells his story of building a source generator and you learn better ways to do things as you progress through the blog.

In particular, in the last entry he breaks out the Attributes into their own assembly. In the initial generator, he injects the Attributes as code with these lines in the Initialize method of the generator, which is the typical method like this:

context.RegisterPostInitializationOutput(ctx => ctx.AddSource(
    "ClassExtensionsAttribute.g.cs",
    SourceText.From(SourceGenerationHelper.Attribute, Encoding.UTF8)));

He says this works fine unless someone uses InternalsVisibleTo to expose the internals of one assembly to another. He tried several things to solve this before coming up with a robust solution in part 8 of his series. There's quite a bit of advanced csproj editing that he covers to get it to work. I applied similar changes and everything but the unit tests worked. After viewing his repo, I found his original unit test helper methods to build the code on-the-fly for the unit tests was different. After picking up those changes, the unit tests worked.

Basic Logic of OptionsToStringGenerator.Initialize()

This has the implementation of IIncrementalGenerator.Initialize method. For this generator here's what I did:

Look for classes with at least one attribute (predicate, which must be very fast)
Look for ones with my OptionToStringAttribute (transform, which can be slower)
Execute() generates the code
1. Take the syntax and get the semantic model of the class, extracting the name, accessibility, and list of properties with a get
2. Generate the code for the extension method

Branching Strategy

Branch from main for new features
Pushes will trigger a build and test run using GitHub Actions
When ready, create a PR to main
To push to the NuGet Gallery create a releases/vX.X.X branch and push to it.

Debugging and Testing

To debug the generator, the unit test project calls RunGeneratorsAndUpdateCompilation to run the generator and get the output. The unit test output will be the C# code for the extension method of the objects.

The integration test project runs the generator then calls the extension methods and gets the output from it.

In both cases, the output is written to files and the Verify package is used to compare the output to a snapshot file.

For integration tests, if you make changes to the generator, you often have to restart Visual Studio to get it to load the new one.

Links to Documentation

These are links to the MS documentation for the items I used in the generator.

ISymbol -- Base class for all semantic symbols

IPropertySymbol -- Semantic for the property

GetMethod -- is it a {get}
DeclaredAccessibility -- is it public?

INamedTypeSymbol -- More specific semantic for the class

GetAttributes
ContainingNamespace
DeclaredAccessibility
GetMembers -- get all the members of the class

Links

Andrew Lock's blog series on incremental generators (Part 1)
Verify snapshot test tool
MS Build (csproj) Pack Doc covers some of the less frequently used options
MS LoggerMessage source generator source code referenced by Andrew.
MS .NET Generators' source code

Name		Name	Last commit message	Last commit date
Latest commit History 35 Commits
.github/workflows		.github/workflows
.vscode		.vscode
src		src
test-container		test-container
.gitignore		.gitignore
.markdownlint.json		.markdownlint.json
CHANGELOG.md		CHANGELOG.md
FormatTest.dib		FormatTest.dib
LICENSE		LICENSE
README.md		README.md
pull_request_template.md		pull_request_template.md
run.ps1		run.ps1

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Repository files navigation

OptionsToString Incremental Source Generator

Quick Example

Usage

Example of Editing a Class

Example of Using a Property

Notes

Formatting Options

Per-Property Formatting Options

Collections

Nested Classes

Attributes

Warnings and Errors

Trouble Shooting

Error CS9057

Using Seekatar.Mask

Implementation

Basic Logic of OptionsToStringGenerator.Initialize()

Branching Strategy

Debugging and Testing

Links to Documentation

Links

About

Releases 7

Packages

Contributors 3

Languages

License

Seekatar/OptionToStringGenerator

Folders and files

Latest commit

History

Repository files navigation

OptionsToString Incremental Source Generator

Quick Example

Usage

Example of Editing a Class

Example of Using a Property

Notes

Formatting Options

Per-Property Formatting Options

Collections

Nested Classes

Attributes

Warnings and Errors

Trouble Shooting

Error CS9057

Using Seekatar.Mask

Implementation

Basic Logic of OptionsToStringGenerator.Initialize()

Branching Strategy

Debugging and Testing

Links to Documentation

Links

About

Resources

License

Stars

Watchers

Forks

Releases 7

Packages 0

Contributors 3

Languages

Packages