Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Use custom struct instead of std::pair in QueryHeap #6921

Merged
merged 4 commits into from
May 31, 2024

Conversation

SiarheiFedartsou
Copy link
Member

@SiarheiFedartsou SiarheiFedartsou commented May 30, 2024

  • improves readability
  • seems to be a microoptimisation

Benchmark Results

Benchmark Base PR
alias aliased u32: 1087.89
plain u32: 1085.74
aliased double: 957.784
plain double: 954.912
aliased u32: 1094.16
plain u32: 1143.48
aliased double: 1181.03
plain double: 1173.1
json-render String: 6.5949ms
Stringstream: 9.33359ms
Vector: 6.8915ms
String: 6.56282ms
Stringstream: 9.17836ms
Vector: 6.80801ms
match_ch Default radius:
4.46775ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.0544847ms/coordinate
Radius 5m:
4.4405ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.0541524ms/coordinate
Radius 10m:
15.1805ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.185128ms/coordinate
Radius 15m:
37.1138ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.452607ms/coordinate
Radius 30m:
317.423ms/req at 82 coordinate
3.87101ms/coordinate
Default radius:
4.42469ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.0539597ms/coordinate
Radius 5m:
4.38681ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.0534976ms/coordinate
Radius 10m:
15.0091ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.183038ms/coordinate
Radius 15m:
36.6437ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.446875ms/coordinate
Radius 30m:
312.646ms/req at 82 coordinate
3.81276ms/coordinate
match_mld Default radius:
3.34427ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.0407838ms/coordinate
Radius 5m:
2.79952ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.0341405ms/coordinate
Radius 10m:
10.3098ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.125729ms/coordinate
Radius 15m:
26.4945ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.323104ms/coordinate
Radius 30m:
310.665ms/req at 82 coordinate
3.7886ms/coordinate
Default radius:
2.78484ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.0339614ms/coordinate
Radius 5m:
2.7996ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.0341415ms/coordinate
Radius 10m:
10.1723ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.124052ms/coordinate
Radius 15m:
26.0148ms/req at 82 coordinate
0.317254ms/coordinate
Radius 30m:
304.017ms/req at 82 coordinate
3.70753ms/coordinate
packedvector random write:
std::vector 9858.82 ms
util::packed_vector 82186.3 ms
slowdown: 8.33632
random read:
std::vector 8513.61 ms
util::packed_vector 33472.8 ms
slowdown: 3.93168
random write:
std::vector 11236.2 ms
util::packed_vector 73886.6 ms
slowdown: 6.57575
random read:
std::vector 11103.5 ms
util::packed_vector 30234 ms
slowdown: 2.72293
route_ch 1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
509.659ms
0.509659ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
351.646ms
0.351646ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
628.2ms
0.6282ms/req
1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
152.53ms
0.15253ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
97.4741ms
0.0974741ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
132.57ms
0.13257ms/req
1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
151.428ms
0.151428ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
97.0949ms
0.0970949ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
132.039ms
0.132039ms/req
1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
511.645ms
0.511645ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
353.033ms
0.353033ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
630.633ms
0.630633ms/req
1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
149.976ms
0.149976ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
96.5049ms
0.0965049ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
132.923ms
0.132923ms/req
1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
149.583ms
0.149583ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
96.4442ms
0.0964442ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
131.794ms
0.131794ms/req
route_mld 1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
643.621ms
0.643621ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
441.984ms
0.441984ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
818.912ms
0.818912ms/req
1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
280.732ms
0.280732ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
164.269ms
0.164269ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
300.394ms
0.300394ms/req
1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
272.22ms
0.27222ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
161.836ms
0.161836ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
293.598ms
0.293598ms/req
1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
640.204ms
0.640204ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
436.477ms
0.436477ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=full, steps=true
815.515ms
0.815515ms/req
1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
268.377ms
0.268377ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
159.875ms
0.159875ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=false, steps=false
287.392ms
0.287392ms/req
1000 routes, 3 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
261.197ms
0.261197ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, no alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
161.217ms
0.161217ms/req
1000 routes, 2 coordinates, 3 alternatives, overview=false, steps=false, radius=750
287.302ms
0.287302ms/req
rtree 1 result:
207.75ms -> 0.020775 ms/query
10 results:
243.355ms -> 0.0243355 ms/query
1 result:
207.172ms -> 0.0207172 ms/query
10 results:
243.418ms -> 0.0243418 ms/query

@DennisOSRM
Copy link
Collaborator

Nice readability improvement

@SiarheiFedartsou
Copy link
Member Author

Nice readability improvement

I hope it is not only readability :) locally I have slight performance improvement on some of benchmarks. It can be confusing, but there are indeed some reasons why std::pair can be slower than raw struct:
https://danlark.org/2020/04/13/why-is-stdpair-broken/
https://www.reddit.com/r/cpp/comments/ar4ghs/stdpair_disappointing_performance/

But tbh I am not 100% sure yet it is the case here.

@SiarheiFedartsou
Copy link
Member Author

SiarheiFedartsou commented May 30, 2024

e indeed some reasons why std::pair can be slower than raw struct: https://danlark.org/2020/04/13/why-is-stdpair-broken/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cpp/comments/ar4ghs/stdpair_disappointing_performance/

But tbh I am not 100% sure yet it is the case here.

Well, according to our CI benchmark it seems to be indeed a microoptimisation, but hard to say for sure as improvement is really small. Also weird that I see it only for MLD(UPDATE: after re-run there is slight improvement on CH as well, but it is hard to say if it is statistically significant). But as this is nice as readability only thing I propose to merge it anyway.


bool operator>(const HeapData &other) const
{
if (weight == other.weight)
Copy link
Member Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

It seems it guarantees that we will get keys with the same weight in insertion order and I added it only to preserve guarantees we had before with std::pair, but is it really needed? 🤔

@SiarheiFedartsou SiarheiFedartsou marked this pull request as ready for review May 30, 2024 15:59
@SiarheiFedartsou SiarheiFedartsou merged commit 42fafdc into master May 31, 2024
21 checks passed
@SiarheiFedartsou SiarheiFedartsou deleted the sf-pair-vs-struct branch May 31, 2024 05:06
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants