sounds not working

[367757475]

System Information

MultiMC version:

Operating System:

Summary of the issue or suggestion:

What should happen: when minecraft boots up it is supposed to have sound, note i am using 1.7.3 beta.

Steps to reproduce the issue (Add more if needed):

1. unknown

Suspected cause: unknown... HELP!!!

Logs/Screenshots:

---

Additional Info:

[Janrupf]

I think thats the same issue as always, the old links are broken. I don't know if this affects all old versions but some if them are just gone.

[peterix]

Yeah... This will need some workaround... Is Mojang hosting these files still?

[367757475]

whats strange is this just worked for me about 3 days ago. sounds also don't work with actual minecraft launcher.

[ghost]

so I had this issue as well, but I fixed it. So I'm pretty sure that the game tries to look for the correct resources(sounds) and if it cant find the right resources it tries to download them from a dead link. The way I fixed this is just replacing the resources folder in the instance I was using with the one I had from beta 1.7.3(Don't remember where I downloaded from them but I have them)

[367757475]

thank you Jilms for your help, I would like to have those resource files if you wouldn't mind.

[367757475]

i found another resources folder online, the only problem is you have to hit F3 and S at the same time. Is there any way ti fix this because i am lazy and don't feel like doing that,

[peterix]

You can get the sounds here: https://mega.nz/#F!U3owiTzK!QtYRYthO4i7Cyshf2MWmNg

[Revemohl]

Given how this issue is known but has been going unsolved for about two months (https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/WEB-1004), would it be possible for MultiMC's servers to locally host the sound files for older versions and for the program itself to download them from there until some activity happens from Mojang's side?

[peterix]

I believe that this should be solved in an official way, without me rehosting files.

[QuImUfu]

i made a very simple bash script that takes files from /assets/objects and copies them into the resources folder format expected by minecraft beta.

https://gist.github.com/QuImUfu/c0284fe6e3cf8e5ddb93fa0b8b96dfd3

Some files that belong into the resources folder are not included in the files in the /assets/objects folder.
i made a zip containing those files.

https://dl.dropbox.com/s/e8n9tvio25ac7yb/resources.zip

together these are exactly the files listed on http://s3.amazonaws.com/MinecraftResources and match on md5sum.

so to create a beta resources folder on Linux:

• use MultiMC to start any legacy instance once (to download the assets)
• download and copy the script to {MMC_DIR}/assets/objects
• execute it
• download the zip and extract it into the resource folder created in /assets/objects by the script
• copy/move the resource folder into your beta instance

[peterix]

I wonder if the files are there, but simply don't have an index that would point to them. And seeing how the files on the server are simply checksums, maybe it would be worth it to just reconstruct the indexes and backfill them into the legacy versions...

[peterix]

So, I checked those with sha1sum:

 ~  playground  resources-beta  $  find . -type f | xargs sha1sum 
7c5b628070ce191762b972fc3a58d57bc10a628a  ./streaming/mellohi.mus
d5ce66b3787648036b29c504786bcc237cd316d3  ./streaming/11.mus
21c9b7c6b486247322051f90aa964f161edc78d8  ./streaming/far.mus
eaf1d4879f3bf6f5f60ba01f475dc581c641b4ae  ./streaming/blocks.mus
a01e4caf7aaac61502a4a5e4f277b0de4795b802  ./streaming/stal.mus
d639bf7f0516e5e363fe5db2aa150cedd38de19a  ./streaming/chirp.mus
bea1c181fce1150f3aaea8f14a773394ccc253d2  ./streaming/cat.mus
c343dc04df647fb25bec35ee23dc973e7374dcf9  ./streaming/13.mus
a96c409e8d54d95520cf6d2caa583b5667e2dc63  ./streaming/wait.mus
bcadae10578ff321236f5670934f0b287eb80fbc  ./streaming/strad.mus
872d3d24452ff2155bb6be4a14c103e4451e6416  ./streaming/mall.mus
b245effde68d07ffe32a033b61e96f1ed7e28783  ./streaming/ward.mus
9d52e43288d7f9e4d14199368a0f30ae3570d05a  ./sound3/random/levelup.ogg
19c729c3ceb753a824246b494bce5fa5c802f0f0  ./newsound/fire/ignite.ogg
17e66efe64256142c55ef6f35060f277f127bb44  ./newsound/liquid/lava.ogg
9e22b5aeec31de99410b682cc161a6096a1cd00a  ./newsound/random/old_explode.ogg
40a5a4307c1a2a5a1b9f71254275689845374104  ./newsound/random/drr.ogg
9d52e43288d7f9e4d14199368a0f30ae3570d05a  ./newsound/random/levelup.ogg
c7c9e86e3ccc55ea2312a498aef861def771d8cf  ./newsound/damage/fallbig2.ogg
f76d4efd860b599200e96401b2485cc83c1ec21e  ./newsound/damage/fallbig1.ogg
6094b6620f2d1f2d19869a2e6498a52b1a265738  ./newsound/damage/fallsmall.ogg
4e1651a728b394e054aaa24e3070e7dae849f14d  ./newsound/damage/hurtflesh2.ogg
4b49dd9329b254e38f17166b7daa51a758a25f94  ./newsound/damage/hurtflesh3.ogg
e40695b47209c3b4bbdc3496b38959d097c6afbc  ./newsound/damage/hurtflesh1.ogg
647c46f5704b3be0b7159961e1bc51721a33dfd5  ./newsound/mob/skeletonhurt3.ogg
00b1a23c84bc7f7377de973040b2dd336670bb8f  ./newsound/mob/cow2.ogg
f7e8ae3a771d50ed827772b75c50958393b621e1  ./newsound/mob/skeletonhurt1.ogg
087e5fa84e7c961778397a0d938bde1e49dd3beb  ./newsound/mob/slime3.ogg
ca1b7de8bb9ce92f2f044c6a98c99d7bf92b7184  ./newsound/mob/slime4.ogg
87eceaa08df660cd1d4dadf7d1c64a6f7125dacb  ./newsound/mob/cowhurt3.ogg
d49ab3ceb3f6212d64580f0d906fa9880a674c6d  ./newsound/mob/slime1.ogg
e0bba792682878ee208a54184df9e2e8044f2815  ./newsound/mob/cow4.ogg
0f3a7e5a20119853986d2cfae22ca3a46926ac76  ./newsound/mob/skeletonhurt4.ogg
be0be76687eab152334a35fdb76e6ab4455bfaef  ./newsound/mob/cowhurt2.ogg
2c849f4b6ec1cf084ac84d57ec90779266b23ae8  ./newsound/mob/cowhurt1.ogg
f75617763129506ae7220ed16cdff7a8084eebb3  ./newsound/mob/cow3.ogg
525700bc06b6f0f8afc3fb542977cef617196ccf  ./newsound/mob/slime2.ogg
24bae598320bf757fd6937a93f135f5cdba206ba  ./newsound/mob/slime5.ogg
a795e9a7721927282befc085e4e397a6379e3004  ./newsound/mob/skeletondeath.ogg
1298f4526580c8f10812253e7d9130ce4afc3a1e  ./newsound/mob/cow1.ogg
a12f98ac001492ff596b5da9e6297b3be98f9149  ./newsound/mob/skeletonhurt2.ogg
99dc14908ec25fd5628fd98ad214acb59fedfb0f  ./pe/humble.png

Practically, if these were hosted on the new server, this would have to be accessible:
http://resources.download.minecraft.net/7c/7c5b628070ce191762b972fc3a58d57bc10a628a (/streaming/mellohi.mus)

And that's simply not there...

In contrast, this is accessible:
http://resources.download.minecraft.net/ff/ffab3dd5dcf0264f1520d9d98268f9971c71480d

Mojang would have to put these on the new server.

[QuImUfu]

exactly my results, you beat my by seconds :D

[Fixer-007]

Has this problem for 1.2.5 too, it worked before.

[peterix]

This should now be fixed.

[Fixer-007]

I did a quick test with new beta 1.7.3 and release 1.2.5 instances and sounds worked for me, thanks a lot :)