You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
I am experiencing poor downscaling quality when using Hardware-based encoding (NVENC). Using an Nvidia graphics card to encode produces what seems to be a nearest neighbor downscale, which for downscaling from an HD or 4K panel, looks very bad.
The expected behavior is for the PC to downscale the rendered image in such a way that it adds a kind of supersample anti aliasing effect. Something like a Bilinear, Bicubic, or Area downscale for example.
Screenshots (Integer upscaled to 4K for easier viewing on modern screens)
NVENC P4:
Software x264 Ultrafast:
PC Settings
Host: Sunshine v0.23.1
OS: Windows 10 Home; Version 22H2 (19045.4780)
Browser: Google Chrome; Version 128.0.6613.114 (64-bit)
CPU: Intel i7-1165G7 @3-4.7Ghz (thermal limited)
GPU: ASUS Dual RTX 3070 (Non-LHR) (Desktop GPU connected via M.2 PCIe adapter) / Driver: 560.94
RAM: 16GB Quad-Channel LPDDR4 @4,267Mhz
As an aside, 800px "HoriHD" content does not really work on software or hardware based encoding with Sunshine either. Ideally, we could stream 800x240 (800x225 16:9) at 30 or 60fps with a nice supersample downscale filter on hardware encoding, but for now the best results I have been able to get are 400x240 / software encode as "HoriHD" content is not scaled to a 1:2 Pixel Aspect Ratio (what the 3DS Screen uses).
800px software encode
800px hardware encode
Both screenshots resolve to an 400x240 1:1 PAR in an 800x240 area from luma's capture, but IRL it looks squished vertically compared to 400x240 streams. I don't have a good way of representing that with luma's capture, though.
I am experiencing poor downscaling quality when using Hardware-based encoding (NVENC). Using an Nvidia graphics card to encode produces what seems to be a nearest neighbor downscale, which for downscaling from an HD or 4K panel, looks very bad.
The expected behavior is for the PC to downscale the rendered image in such a way that it adds a kind of supersample anti aliasing effect. Something like a Bilinear, Bicubic, or Area downscale for example.
Screenshots (Integer upscaled to 4K for easier viewing on modern screens)
NVENC P4:
Software x264 Ultrafast:
PC Settings
Host: Sunshine v0.23.1
OS: Windows 10 Home; Version 22H2 (19045.4780)
Browser: Google Chrome; Version 128.0.6613.114 (64-bit)
CPU: Intel i7-1165G7 @3-4.7Ghz (thermal limited)
GPU: ASUS Dual RTX 3070 (Non-LHR) (Desktop GPU connected via M.2 PCIe adapter) / Driver: 560.94
RAM: 16GB Quad-Channel LPDDR4 @4,267Mhz
3DS/Stream settings
Hardware: RED-001 (New Nintendo 3DS XL, USA Region)
OFW: 11.17.0-50U
CFW: "Polari3DS" v1.1 https://github.com/Alexyo21/Polari3DS/releases/tag/1.1.0
Stream: 400x240, 60fps, 8000kbps. NVENC Quality setting is P4.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: