Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Jul 13, 2023. It is now read-only.

The whole aws-sdk is required, but not actually needed #2569

Closed
Fodoj opened this issue Mar 4, 2018 · 1 comment
Closed

The whole aws-sdk is required, but not actually needed #2569

Fodoj opened this issue Mar 4, 2018 · 1 comment

Comments

@Fodoj
Copy link

Fodoj commented Mar 4, 2018

It seems to be that requiring complete aws-sdk is not really needed. It's required here: https://github.com/thoughtbot/paperclip/blob/master/lib/paperclip/storage/s3.rb.

The problem with it is that it will include all AWS SDK libraries. Take a look at Gemfile.lock:

    aws-sdk-resources (3.12.0)
      aws-sdk-acm (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-alexaforbusiness (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-apigateway (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-applicationautoscaling (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-applicationdiscoveryservice (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-appstream (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-appsync (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-athena (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-autoscaling (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-autoscalingplans (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-batch (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-budgets (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cloud9 (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-clouddirectory (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cloudformation (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cloudfront (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cloudhsm (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cloudhsmv2 (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cloudsearch (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cloudsearchdomain (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cloudtrail (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cloudwatch (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cloudwatchevents (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cloudwatchlogs (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-codebuild (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-codecommit (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-codedeploy (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-codepipeline (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-codestar (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cognitoidentity (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cognitoidentityprovider (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-cognitosync (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-comprehend (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-configservice (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-costandusagereportservice (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-costexplorer (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-databasemigrationservice (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-datapipeline (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-dax (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-devicefarm (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-directconnect (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-directoryservice (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-dynamodb (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-dynamodbstreams (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-ec2 (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-ecr (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-ecs (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-efs (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-elasticache (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-elasticbeanstalk (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-elasticloadbalancing (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-elasticloadbalancingv2 (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-elasticsearchservice (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-elastictranscoder (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-emr (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-firehose (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-gamelift (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-glacier (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-glue (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-greengrass (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-guardduty (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-health (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-iam (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-importexport (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-inspector (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-iot (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-iotdataplane (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-iotjobsdataplane (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-kinesis (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-kinesisanalytics (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-kinesisvideo (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-kinesisvideoarchivedmedia (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-kinesisvideomedia (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-kms (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-lambda (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-lambdapreview (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-lex (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-lexmodelbuildingservice (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-lightsail (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-machinelearning (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-marketplacecommerceanalytics (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-marketplaceentitlementservice (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-marketplacemetering (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-mediaconvert (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-medialive (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-mediapackage (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-mediastore (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-mediastoredata (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-migrationhub (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-mobile (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-mq (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-mturk (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-opsworks (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-opsworkscm (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-organizations (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-pinpoint (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-polly (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-pricing (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-rds (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-redshift (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-rekognition (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-resourcegroups (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-resourcegroupstaggingapi (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-route53 (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-route53domains (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-s3 (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-sagemaker (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-sagemakerruntime (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-serverlessapplicationrepository (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-servicecatalog (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-servicediscovery (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-ses (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-shield (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-simpledb (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-sms (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-snowball (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-sns (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-sqs (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-ssm (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-states (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-storagegateway (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-support (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-swf (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-transcribeservice (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-translate (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-waf (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-wafregional (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-workdocs (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-workmail (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-workspaces (~> 1)
      aws-sdk-xray (~> 1)

I didn't dig too much into Paperclip source code, but it seems to be that just requiring aws-sdk-s3 should be sufficient.

What do you think? I can submit a PR with the fix.

@sidraval
Copy link
Contributor

sidraval commented Mar 9, 2018

#2481 Took care of this 👍

@sidraval sidraval closed this as completed Mar 9, 2018
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants