Proposal: reverse continue

[lloeki]

Your proposal

Here's a simplistic piece of code:

# test.rb
def foo(a, b)
  a.x = nil if b == 5
end

a = Struct.new(:x).new(10)

10.times do |i|
  foo(a, i)
  puts a.x + i
end

It has a bug and will crash when i is 5:

$ ruby test.rb
10
11
12
13
14
test.rb:9:in `block in <main>': undefined method `+' for nil (NoMethodError)

  puts a.x + i
           ^
	from <internal:numeric>:237:in `times'
	from test.rb:9:in `<main>'

We can do this:

$ rdbg test.rb        
[1, 10] in test.rb
=>   1| def foo(a, b)
     2|   a.x = nil if b == 5
     3| end
     4| 
     5| a = Struct.new(:x).new(10)
     6| 
     7| 10.times do |i|
     8|   foo(a, i)
     9|   puts a.x + i
    10| end
=>#0	<main> at test.rb:1
(rdbg) break 9 if: a.x == nil    # command
#0  BP - Line  /Users/loic.nageleisen/test.rb:9 (line) if: a.x == nil
(rdbg) record on    # command
Recorder for #<Thread:0x000000010292b0c8 run>: on (0 records)
(rdbg) continue    # command
10
11
12
13
14
[4, 10] in test.rb
     4| 
     5| a = Struct.new(:x).new(10)
     6| 
     7| 10.times do |i|
     8|   foo(a, i)
=>   9|   puts a.x + i
    10| end
=>#0	block {|i=5|} in <main> at test.rb:9
  #1	Integer#times at <internal:numeric>:237
  # and 1 frames (use `bt' command for all frames)

Stop by #0  BP - Line  /Users/loic.nageleisen/test.rb:9 (line) if: a.x == nil
(rdbg) step back    # command
[replay] [4, 10] in test.rb
[replay]      4| 
[replay]      5| a = Struct.new(:x).new(10)
[replay]      6| 
[replay]      7| 10.times do |i|
[replay]      8|   foo(a, i)
[replay] =>   9|   puts a.x + i
[replay]     10| end
[replay] =>#0	block {|i=5|} in <main> at test.rb:9
[replay]   #1	Integer#times at <internal:numeric>:237
[replay]   # and 1 frames (use `bt' command for all frames)
(rdbg) step back    # command
[replay] [1, 10] in test.rb
[replay]      1| def foo(a, b)
[replay] =>   2|   a.x = nil if b == 5
[replay]      3| end
[replay]      4| 
[replay]      5| a = Struct.new(:x).new(10)
[replay]      6| 
[replay]      7| 10.times do |i|
[replay]      8|   foo(a, i)
[replay]      9|   puts a.x + i
[replay]     10| end
[replay] =>#0	Object#foo(a=#<struct  x=nil>, b=5) at test.rb:2
[replay]   #1	block {|i=5|} in <main> at test.rb:8
[replay]   # and 2 frames (use `bt' command for all frames)
(rdbg) 

And there we find the line that caused our bug.

Sadly many a time the code is much more sizeable and complex, and it's not that easy to go back step by step.

I would like to propose possible usage:

break 9 if: a.x == nil
record on
continue
# <= breakpoint hit
break if: a.x != nil           # or `break a.x=`
continue back                  # or `reverse continue`
# <= lands on line 3

break 9 if: a.x == nil
record on
continue
# <= breakpoint hit
watch a.x
continue back
# <= lands on line 3

break 9 if: a.x == nil
record on
continue
# <= breakpoint hit
step back until a.x != nil             # or `reverse until a.x != nil`
# <= lands on line 3

Both would automate going from the issue occurence back until a specific condition is met.

Additional context

Inspired by rr's reverse-continue and watch -l