Devmode should be recognizing compile-only and runtime-only dependencies

[aloubyansky]

Gradle supports compileOnly and runtimeOnly classpath dependencies. However, at this point our devmode support does not allow isolating compileOnly dependencies from the runtime classpath.
And isolate the runtimeOnly classpath from the compile classpath.

fyi @stuartwdouglas

[stuartwdouglas]

Maven has the same thing (provided = compileOnly, runtime=runtimeOnly).

I actually just ran into an issue caused by this with my reagument PR, we are resolving provided deps which includes graal svm, which includes a bundled old version of ASM.

If I get time today I might make an attempt at this based on your PR for the 'test dep leakage' issue.

[aloubyansky]

I thought about Maven and provided opening this issue too. It's not the same. provided is (mis)used for that. But what provided means is "use the dependency for compilation only, it will be provided at runtime by the environment". In that case we should be including provided for running the app. I am not sure the promise is the same for compileOnly in Gradle.

[stuartwdouglas]

I don't think we should be supplying 'provided', otherwise from the point of view of Quarkus it is the same as 'compile'.

We also use provided for artifacts that we expect substrate VM to provide, which definitely should not go into the app.

[aloubyansky]

You are right, I was just thinking the same. So, yes, we should not included provided.

[FWest98]

We are running into this issue, where we'd like to have some dependencies as compileOnly in Gradle, but Quarkus doesn't like this in dev mode...

[aloubyansky]

As provided in Maven? Keep in mind that provided dependencies are added to the test runtime classpath by Maven itself (and Quarkus too).

[FWest98]

I use Gradle as follows:

compileOnly("foo.bar")
testImplementation("foo.bar")

For non-Quarkus projects, this works perfectly fine. However, when trying to run the tests in the Quarkus project, I get:

Execution failed for task ':project:quarkusGenerateCode'.
> Could not resolve all dependencies for configuration ':project:quarkusProdCompileOnlyConfiguration'.
   > Could not find com.fasterxml.jackson.dataformat:jackson-dataformat-yaml:.
     Required by:
         project :project

[aloubyansky]

Could you please create a new issue and attach a reproducer? Thanks

[FWest98]

Turns out I was running into #39073, so a different issue than this.