Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
105 lines (70 loc) · 11 KB

CONTRIBUTING.md

File metadata and controls

105 lines (70 loc) · 11 KB
Raw

Contributing to Elasticsearch Machine Learning Core

We love to receive contributions from our community — you! There are many ways to contribute, from writing tutorials or blog posts, improving the documentation, submitting bug reports and feature requests or writing code which can be incorporated into the Elastic Stack itself.

We enjoy working with contributors, note we have a Code of Conduct, please follow it in all your interactions.

Bug reports

If you think you have found a bug in ml-cpp, first make sure that you are testing against the latest version of the Elastic Stack - your issue may already have been fixed. Please be aware that the machine learning code is split between the ml-cpp, elasticsearch and kibana repos. If your bug is related to the UI then the kibana repo is likely to be a more appropriate place to raise it. And if it's related to the backend REST API then the elasticsearch repo is likely the most appropriate place.

Before opening a new issue please search the issues list on GitHub in case a similar issue has already been opened. It is very helpful if you can prepare a reproduction of the bug. In other words, provide a small test case which we can run to confirm your bug. It makes it easier to find the problem and to fix it.

If you run into a problem that might be a data related issue, something where you can't clearly say it is a bug - for example: "Why is my anomaly not found?" - we encourage you to contact the team via our Discuss forums before opening an issue.

Important note: It really helps if you provide a data samples that describe any issues found. If you do provide any data samples, then please make sure this data is not in any way confidential. If the data is subject to any license terms, please ensure that there are no restrictions on its usage or redistribution and that attribution is clearly made.

Feature requests

If you find yourself wishing for a feature that doesn't exist, you are probably not alone. There are bound to be others out there with similar needs. Open an issue on our issues list on GitHub which describes the feature you would like to see, why you need it, and how it should work.

Similar to bugs, enhancements related to the UI should be raised in the kibana repo, and enhancements related to the backend REST API should be raised in the elasticsearch repo.

Contributing code and documentation changes

If you have a bugfix or new feature that you would like to contribute to ml-cpp, please find or open an issue about it first. Talk about what you would like to do. It may be that somebody is already working on it, or that there are particular issues that you should know about before implementing the change. We enjoy working with contributors to get their code accepted. There are many approaches to fixing a problem and it is important to find the best approach before writing too much code. The process for contributing to any of the Elastic repositories is similar. Details for individual projects can be found below. If you want to get started in the project, a good idea is to check issues labeled with help wanted. These are issues that should help newcomers to the project get something achieved without too much hassle.

Fork and clone the repository

You will need to fork the repository and clone it to your local machine. See the Github help page for help.

Submitting your changes

Once your changes and tests are ready to submit for review:

  1. Test your changes

    Run the test suite to make sure that nothing is broken. See below for help running tests.

  2. Sign the Contributor License Agreement

    Please make sure you have signed our Contributor License Agreement.

    1. We are not asking you to assign copyright to us, but to give us the right to distribute your code without restriction. We ask this of all contributors in order to assure our users of the origin and continuing existence of the code. You only need to sign the CLA once.
    2. If you provide any data samples as part of unit tests or otherwise, then please make sure these do not contain confidential information. If data is subject to any license terms please ensure this attribution is clearly stated.

  3. Rebase your changes

    Update your local repository with the most recent code from the main ml-cpp repository, and rebase your branch on top of the latest master branch. We prefer your initial changes to be squashed into a single commit. Later, if we ask you to make changes, add them as separate commits. This makes them easier to review. As a final step we will squash all commits when merging your change.

  4. Submit a pull request

    Push your local changes to your forked copy of the repository and submit a pull request. In the pull request, choose a title which sums up the changes that you have made, and in the body provide more details about what your changes do. Also mention the number of the issue where discussion has taken place, eg Closes #123. See more information about pull requests below

Then sit back and wait. There will probably be discussion about the pull request and, if any changes are needed, we would love to work with you to get your pull request merged into ml-cpp.

Please adhere to the general guideline that you should never force push to a publicly shared branch. Once you have opened your pull request, you should consider your branch publicly shared. Instead of force pushing you can just add incremental commits; this is generally easier on your reviewers. If you need to pick up changes from master, you can merge master into your branch. A reviewer might ask you to rebase a long-running pull request in which case force pushing is okay for that request. Note that squashing at the end of the review process should also not be done, that can be done when the pull request is integrated via GitHub.

Working with the ml-cpp codebase

Repository: https://github.com/elastic/ml-cpp

  1. Set up a build machine by following the instructions in the build-setup directory
  2. Do your changes.
  3. If you change code, follow the existing coding style.
  4. Write a test, unit tests are located under lib/{module}/unittest
  5. Test your changes (make test)

Pull Requests

Every change made to ml-cpp must be held to a high standard, Pull Requests are equally important as they document changes and decissions that have been made. You Know, for Search - a descriptive and relevant summary of the change helps people to find your PR later on.

The followings lists some guidelines when authoring pull requests. Note, try to follow this guideline as close as possible but do not feel bad if you are unsure, team members can help you.

  1. PR title summarizes the change, short and descriptive.
    1. Use prefixes for quick categorization:
      1. [X.Y] Branch label if backport PR, if omited the PR only applies to master. Note, backport PR's are done after master PR, further explanation can be found below [#backport]
      2. [ML] mandatory prefix, to be consistent with other repositories
      3. [FEATURE] If your pull requests targets a feature branch, this prefix helps as a filter
  2. A detailed summary of what changed. Some hints:
    1. Keep it short but do not ommit important details. Usually we squash and merge, write what you would write as commit message of the squashed commit, later you can reuse what you wrote.
    2. A link to each issue that is closed by the PR (e.g. Closes #123) or related (Relates #456)
    3. Further information if necessary, maybe you want to share a screenshot, list open Todo's, describe your thought process, etc.
    4. Optional: List of backport PR's, other related PR's
  3. Label the PR, not all might apply:
    1. :ml mandatory label, to be consistent with other repositories.
    2. >type Type of the PR, e.g. >bug, >refactoring, >enhancement, >test.
    3. vX.Y Versions that PR should be applied to, a PR on master should always contain all backport versions as well, a backport PR should only have one corresponding version.
    4. >non-issue if the PR is not important for the changelog, e.g. a bugfix for an unreleased feature
    5. affects-results If the PR is expected to have a significant impact on results(QA test suite), e.g. changes of scoring. Be aware that changes in terms of memory consumption can indirectly lead to significant result changes.
    6. discuss If your PR suggests a change for which you'd first like to discuss regarding its functional changes before going deep into actual implementation details (e.g. you change a default)
    7. WIP lets potential reviewers know, that you haven't completed the PR yet and you are still working on further changes, lets reviewers know to maybe wait a bit until you finalized the PR.
    8. review Try to find reviewers for your change, github has some suggestions, however if unsure or you know the reviewer is very busy, review marks the PR as free to grab for review. Still, PR's are open to anyone to comment.

Backport

Any development usually starts with an implementation on master, therefore any PR starts with a PR against master. Depending on the type we then decide about backport branches, features usually get backported to the active release branch, e.g. 6.x, bugfixes might get backported to concrete release branches, e.g. 6.1. If unsure about the versions to backport to, it can be discussed on the master PR.

A backport starts right after merging the PR on master, please open backport PR's immediately after merging to master, even if you intend to merge backports a little later (e.g. to wait/analyse QA results). This helps to ensure that backports do not get lost. Rules for Backport PR's:

  1. Prefix the title with [X.Y] and the mandatory [ML], e.g. [6.3][ML] Store expanding window bucket values in a compressed format.
  2. Link to the originating PR in the description, you do not need to repeat the description as discussions should exclusively happen on the master PR.
  3. Backports do not need a review, however if you had to do further changes (merge conflicts, compiler specialities) it's advised to let the adjustments get quickly reviewed.
  4. Label the PR with >backport and the corresponding version of this backport, the full set of labels remain on the master PR. If the master PR is classified as >non-issue also add the >non-issue label due to CI checks.

Although it might look simple, always wait for CI to confirm that changes are sound to avoid unnecessary build breaks.