[Feature request / UX Discussion] Support enforcers should work in all modes

[erispe]

Version

PrusaSclier-2.3.0-alpha3

Operating system type + version

Windows 10

Behavior

So this is a request to rethink how Support Enforcers work in regards to the different support modes. The single sentence summary is that a support enforcer should always enforce supports, even if support mode is set to None, because that is what it's name implies. (If the user has enforcers in their scene and wants no supports to show up then they should be disabled by hiding them and setting support mode to None)

I feel like the options "Supports on build plate only" and "Everywhere" or "None" should be the only three options and then you add your support enforcers and blockers on top of that. The "For support enforcers only" becomes redundant. I want I want to be able to use the "Supports on build plate only" together with custom support enforcers, which currently is impossible, and I need to set up a complicated scene in "Supports everywhere" mode where I block everything that's not directly above the build plate.

In summary I think it would be more powerful and cover more use cases if enforcers always work regardless of mode.

[lukasmatena]

A notification will be shown in PrusaSlicer 2.4.0 (an alpha will be released shortly) to inform about having enforcers with supports turned off.

Can we close this issue?

[bubnikv]

no response, closing.-