[CERT-TEST-FAILURE] - TC-S-2.2- Test failed

[Ashwinigrl]

Feature Area

Area:Scenes

Test Case

TC-S-2.2

Reproduction steps

1. Execute the below mentioned command to put DUT into a commissionable state : ./chip-all-clusters-app
2. Once DUT reach the commission able state sent below mentioned command on TH. : ./chip-tool pairing onnetwork 1 20202021
3. Once after successful pairing provide the below commands:

Precondition Steps for adding a Group:
./chip-tool groupkeymanagement key-set-write '{"groupKeySetID": "0x01a1","groupKeySecurityPolicy": 0, "epochKey0":"a0a1a2a3a4a5a6a7a8a9aaabacadaeaf","epochStartTime0": 1110000,"epochKey1":"b0b1b2b3b4b5b6b7b8b9babbbcbdbebf", "epochStartTime1": 1110001,"epochKey2":"c0c1c2c3c4c5c6c7c8c9cacbcccdcecf", "epochStartTime2": 1110002 }' 1 0

[1718021039.147785][36873:36875] CHIP:DMG: StatusIB =
[1718021039.147861][36873:36875] CHIP:DMG: {
[1718021039.147938][36873:36875] CHIP:DMG: status = 0x00 (SUCCESS),
[1718021039.148015][36873:36875] CHIP:DMG: },

./chip-tool groupkeymanagement write group-key-map '[{"groupId": "0x0001", "groupKeySetID": "0x01a1", "fabricIndex": 1}]' 1 0

[1718021089.747735][36877:36879] CHIP:DMG: StatusIB =
[1718021089.747812][36877:36879] CHIP:DMG: {
[1718021089.747912][36877:36879] CHIP:DMG: status = 0x00 (SUCCESS),
[1718021089.747981][36877:36879] CHIP:DMG: },

./chip-tool groups add-group 0x0001 Gp1 1 1

[1718021104.970199][36883:36885] CHIP:DMG: Received Command Response Data, Endpoint=1 Cluster=0x0000_0004 Command=0x0000_0000
[1718021104.970377][36883:36885] CHIP:TOO: Endpoint: 1 Cluster: 0x0000_0004 Command 0x0000_0000
[1718021104.970667][36883:36885] CHIP:TOO: AddGroupResponse: {
[1718021104.970734][36883:36885] CHIP:TOO: status: 0
[1718021104.970846][36883:36885] CHIP:TOO: groupID: 1
[1718021104.970948][36883:36885] CHIP:TOO: }

Send AddScene command to DUT with invalid ExtensionField (Invalid attribute ID for given cluster).
Here AttributeID 0x4011 is Invalid ID from Color Control Cluster

Actual Outcome:

./chip-tool scenesmanagement add-scene 0x0001 0x01 1000 "scene name" '[{"clusterID": "0x0300", "attributeValueList":[{"attributeID": "0x4011", "attributeValue": "0x01"}]}]' 1 1

[1718021138.581350][36889:36891] CHIP:DMG: Received Command Response Data, Endpoint=1 Cluster=0x0000_0062 Command=0x0000_0000
[1718021138.581539][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: Endpoint: 1 Cluster: 0x0000_0062 Command 0x0000_0000
[1718021138.581880][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: AddSceneResponse: {
[1718021138.582027][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: status: 0
[1718021138.582090][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: groupID: 1
[1718021138.582200][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: sceneID: 1
[1718021138.582252][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: }

Expected Outcome:

./chip-tool scenesmanagement add-scene 0x0001 0x01 1000 "scene name" '[{"clusterID": "0x0300", "attributeValueList":[{"attributeID": "0x4011", "attributeValue": "0x01"}]}]' 1 1

[1718021138.581350][36889:36891] CHIP:DMG: Received Command Response Data, Endpoint=1 Cluster=0x0000_0062 Command=0x0000_0000
[1718021138.581539][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: Endpoint: 1 Cluster: 0x0000_0062 Command 0x0000_0000
[1718021138.581880][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: AddSceneResponse: {
[1718021138.582027][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: status: 133
[1718021138.582090][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: groupID: 1
[1718021138.582200][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: sceneID: 1
[1718021138.582252][36889:36891] CHIP:TOO: }

Bug prevalence

Whenever I do

GitHub hash of the SDK that was being used

c158260

Platform

raspi

Anything else?

As per the specification, In Add Scene Command If the ExtensionFieldSetStructs list is formatted invalid according to the ExtensionFieldSetStruct structure definition, then the status SHALL be INVALID_COMMAND in the AddSceneResponse,
But in current SDK the Status Response is "SUCCESS"

Step that require review:
Test step 8f

Reference log:
TC-S-2.2(DUT).txt
TC-S-2.2(CNTRL).txt

Spec References:

• https://github.com/CHIP-Specifications/connectedhomeip-spec/blob/master/src/app_clusters/Scenes.adoc#926-effect-on-receipt

Test Plan References:

• https://github.com/CHIP-Specifications/chip-test-plans/blob/master/src/cluster/scenes.adoc#tc-s-2-2-primary-functionality-with-dut_server