diff --git a/ChangeLog.rst b/ChangeLog.rst
index 91b64eb9b1..f554416eff 100644
--- a/ChangeLog.rst
+++ b/ChangeLog.rst
@@ -10,6 +10,9 @@ Security notice
   log/print tokens, you will now have to explicitly log the ``token`` field of
   the ``SocialToken`` instance.
 
+- Enumeration prevention: the behavior on the outside of an actual signup versus
+  a signup where the user already existed was not fully identical, fixed.
+
 
 0.63.3 (2024-05-31)
 *******************
diff --git a/allauth/account/forms.py b/allauth/account/forms.py
index e391a88cb9..3c7415787c 100644
--- a/allauth/account/forms.py
+++ b/allauth/account/forms.py
@@ -381,10 +381,8 @@ def try_save(self, request):
             # Don't create a new account, only send an email informing the user
             # that (s)he already has one...
             email = self.cleaned_data["email"]
-            adapter = get_adapter()
-            adapter.send_account_already_exists_mail(email)
+            resp = flows.signup.prevent_enumeration(request, email)
             user = None
-            resp = adapter.respond_email_verification_sent(request, None)
             request.session[flows.login.LOGIN_SESSION_KEY] = EmailVerificationStage.key
         else:
             user = self.save(request)
diff --git a/allauth/account/internal/flows/signup.py b/allauth/account/internal/flows/signup.py
index 4396184f47..14fcd4c193 100644
--- a/allauth/account/internal/flows/signup.py
+++ b/allauth/account/internal/flows/signup.py
@@ -1,3 +1,5 @@
+from django.contrib import messages
+from django.http import HttpRequest, HttpResponse
 from django.urls import reverse
 
 from allauth.account.adapter import get_adapter
@@ -5,6 +7,19 @@
 from allauth.utils import build_absolute_uri
 
 
+def prevent_enumeration(request: HttpRequest, email: str) -> HttpResponse:
+    adapter = get_adapter(request)
+    adapter.send_account_already_exists_mail(email)
+    adapter.add_message(
+        request,
+        messages.INFO,
+        "account/messages/email_confirmation_sent.txt",
+        {"email": email, "login": False, "signup": True},
+    )
+    resp = adapter.respond_email_verification_sent(request, None)
+    return resp
+
+
 def send_unknown_account_mail(request, email):
     signup_url = get_signup_url(request)
     context = {
diff --git a/allauth/account/tests/test_signup.py b/allauth/account/tests/test_signup.py
index 4f4f21fc8d..63b77b86c1 100644
--- a/allauth/account/tests/test_signup.py
+++ b/allauth/account/tests/test_signup.py
@@ -310,6 +310,7 @@ def test_prevent_enumeration_with_mandatory_verification(
     assert resp.status_code == 302
     assert resp["location"] == reverse("account_email_verification_sent")
     assertTemplateUsed(resp, "account/email/account_already_exists_message.txt")
+    assertTemplateUsed(resp, "account/messages/email_confirmation_sent.txt")
     assert EmailAddress.objects.filter(email="john@example.org").count() == 1
 
 
diff --git a/allauth/socialaccount/internal/flows/signup.py b/allauth/socialaccount/internal/flows/signup.py
index a5666303a1..c57b73e0bc 100644
--- a/allauth/socialaccount/internal/flows/signup.py
+++ b/allauth/socialaccount/internal/flows/signup.py
@@ -5,6 +5,7 @@
 from allauth import app_settings as allauth_settings
 from allauth.account import app_settings as account_settings
 from allauth.account.adapter import get_adapter as get_account_adapter
+from allauth.account.internal.flows.signup import prevent_enumeration
 from allauth.account.utils import (
     assess_unique_email,
     complete_signup,
@@ -75,9 +76,7 @@ def process_auto_signup(request, sociallogin):
             # address. Instead, we're going to send the user an email that
             # the account already exists, and on the outside make it appear
             # as if an email verification mail was sent.
-            account_adapter = get_account_adapter(request)
-            account_adapter.send_account_already_exists_mail(email)
-            resp = account_adapter.respond_email_verification_sent(request, None)
+            resp = prevent_enumeration(request, email)
             return False, resp
     elif app_settings.EMAIL_REQUIRED:
         # Nope, email is required and we don't have it yet...