Radial Menu is full

[bhousel]

For closed ways, the radial menu is full.

The addition of the Reflect commands pushes the menu to 8 items, which is really too many.

The radial menu was already problematic, and it's something we've put off dealing with, but now we really should do something about it.

ccing @samanpwbb for advice

Not looking to bikeshed, but in absence of concrete suggestions or help, I'll probably just change it to be a wider circle, or a fixed menu someplace.

Also tooltip placement on the left side of the menu is broken:

prior discussion
#2145
#1994
#548
#226

[bhousel]

one option

[samanpwbb]

I think we should opt for a more conventional menu, with visible text labels:

I also suggest that we show this menu on right click, which solves the problem of this thing being obtrusive while you're trying to select / move / edit features.

I would recommend against moving the menu to a set position, since many of the actions depend on cursor position.

[bhousel]

Cool @samanpwbb I like it..

[bgirardot]

@samanpwbb I like it too, much easier for new mappers to understand and discover functionality.

[kepta]

I tried to work on this issue. The context menu looks good. Here is the demo:

@samanpwbb As you can see the tooltip is bit of a problem. Personally I don't think I have ever seen a tooltip for right click menus. What do you think ?

[bhousel]

This is awesome @kepta!
I think the tooltip is ok, but defer to @samanpwbb's opinion.

My thinking on the tooltip is - even if it's not perfect, it's better than before where tooltips could show up really anywhere around the radial menu and even on top of it.

[slhh]

@kepta The visual impression doesn't really associate the tooltip to a specific menu item. If the hover styling of the menu item were more visible, this would likely become clear. Maybe the hover styling of the item should include the text label area too.