Failed to boot a 4.1.0 partition-based emunand

[jejer]

Copy the bug report form Atmosphere: Atmosphere-NX/Atmosphere#1128

Bug Report

What's the issue you encountered?

Both hekete and fusee-primary failed to boot a 4.1.0 partition-based emunand emunand.
Got a black screen after Nintendo Switch Logo.
But a file-based emunand boots fine which created from the same sysnand.
And after reboot to hekete from the file-based emunand 4.1.0, the partition-based emunand 4.1.0 could be booted successfully.
After upgrade the partition-based emunand to 10.1.0, it boots ok.

How can the issue be reproduced?

Create a partition and emunand using hekate from sysnand 4.1.0.
This partition-based emunand always fail to boot.
Tested on two different brands of SD cards.

System Firmware Version

4.1.0

Environment?

• What bootloader (fusèe, hekate, etc) was Atmosphère launched by: hekate and fusee-primary
• Official release or unofficial build:
  • Atmosphère 0.14.1
• Do you have additional kips or sysmodules you're loading: No
• Homebrew software installed: ChoiDujourNX

Additional context?

RCM Exploitable Switch
Auto RCM disabled
Caffeine used to boot into RCM
incognito applied on sysnand
SD cards are fat32 formatted

[m4xw]

This is a nonsensical issue.
Raw based can't be broken if file based works.

[m4xw]

@jejer What happens if you rename your Nintendo folder (the emuMMC one)?

[jejer]

wow, after rename "E:\emuMMC\RAW1\Nintendo" to "E:\emuMMC\RAW1\Nintendo2" the emuMMC boots success!

[m4xw]

Probably only till a reboot, but means @CTCaer was right

[jejer]

What is the root cause, do you need to check my "E:\emuMMC\RAW1\Nintendo2"?

[m4xw]

Probably smth is up with the patching

[jejer]

yep, after N creates a new Nintendo folder, reboot goes back to a black screen.

[m4xw]

@jejer got exFAT support installed on the system?

[jejer]

No exFAT support installed.

[m4xw]

Can you try with it installed?
I wonder if both variants are broken or just the no exFAT one.
That will tell me if both need fixes or just one

[m4xw]

The actual nintendo path patches are identical, we might got something mixed up.
b9ac428
44ecdb4

[jejer]

sure, can I just update to the same 4.1.0 with exFAT?

[m4xw]

yep

[jejer]

exFAT doesn't help, it boots to the same black screen.
Remove Nintendo directory makes the boot pass.

Both fat32 and exFAT file system on SD fail to boot for exFAT supported emuMMC.

[m4xw]

Thanks

[roostercactus]

Hi, same behavior on sysnand 4.0.1. After setting up fat32 emunand (4.0.1) on a partition I get the black screen after the Switch logo. To fix it's the same as well. Power off, delete the emunand Nintendo folder, power on...now boots (only once though, if you don't upgrade firmware you have to delete the Nintendo folder on every reboot). I updated emunand to 8.1.0 and now it's fine. Just wanted to let you know of another firmware version where this behavior is observed. Workaround is easy though, so it's not a big deal (as long as you know about the workaround! It took me 2-3 days of futzing around before I found this issue). Thanks so much for this software, it's great.

[jejer]

Tried again with hekate 5.6.5 and atmosphere 1.2.5.
The rename/remove Nintendo workaround doesn't work anymore.

After removing Nintendo, have to use atmosphere 0.19.2 with fusee-primary.bin as a middle version to boot and update the emummc from 4.1.0 to 13.1.0.

[Bidino]

I just mod with latest Atmosphere 1.2.6 + hekate v5.7.0 + Nyx v1.2.0 ecc on FW 13.2.1.
SD-based emunand is KO
file-based emunand is OK
Removing the folder every restart is OK (not praticable)

Is there any fix or workaround I miss?
Thank you

Additional tests: reboot various times (injecting fusee.bin) result in OK or KO in a randomic way (!?)