diff --git a/EWD998.tla b/EWD998.tla index 5da2fbfd..620a6ec6 100644 --- a/EWD998.tla +++ b/EWD998.tla @@ -161,6 +161,37 @@ Next == Spec == Init /\ [][Next]_vars +\* We haven't checked anything except the TypeOK invariant above, which does + \* not say anything about termination detection. What we could do, is to + \* re-state and check the same theorems Stable and Live that we checked for + \* AsyncTerminationDetection -- copy&paste is acceptable with specs after all! + \* On the other hand, this is not exactly what we want to check; we don't want + \* to check that (an amended) Stable and Live hold for EWD998. What we + \* really care about is that the module EWD998 *implements* the high-level + \* specificiation AsyncTerminationDetection (ATD). + \* With TLA, implementation is (logical) implication. To state that some spec + \* I implements a higher-level specification A is formally expressed as + \* I => A . This is equivalent to saying that the behaviors defined by I + \* are a subset of the behaviors defined by A . However, what if I declares + \* additional variables that don't exist in A ? For spec EWD998 , the + \* variables color, token, pending do not appear in ATD . This is where + \* the sub-scripts we added to the various temporal formulas in ATD start to + \* make sense. Recall that [][A]_v is equivalent to [](A \/ v'=v) . This + \* formula is true of behaviors in which variables - not appearing in [A]_v - + \* change in any way they want, as long as the variables in v remain unchanged, + \* or a A step happens. In fact, [A]_v does not say anything about variables + \* not appearing in it; the formula does not "care" about those variables. For + \* EWD998 and ATD , the module ATD allows the module EWD998 to specify + \* anything "in line" with ATD . + \* Remember that an A step above is just an action-level formula. The + \* identifier A of its definition is just a syntactic element to make specs + \* more readable. In other words, when we say A step above, we talk about + \* the formula (the right-hand side of A == foo). Thus, the A step of ATD + \* can be a B step of EWD998 provided that B is a step permitted by A . +\* TODO State that EWD998 implements ATD . In other words, that the formula + \* TODO Spec of EWD998 implies the formula Spec of ATD . Know that + \* TODO the exclamation mark ! is the namespace separator in TLA. + ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- HasToken ==