Incorrect IDs generated?

[IngwiePhoenix]

Hello!

I was setting up a relay and encountered the problem that writing my notes and alike to that relay returned a lot of "bad id" errors: hoytech/strfry#49 (comment)

As I am not very familiar with the Nostr protocol's depths, all I can do is share as much as I know.

I spent some time posting and reacting through Nostrid by logging in with my Private Key (nsec...). Some people even responded to me and such - meaning that somehow, somewhere my notes do get delivered and work.

But when I attempt to use the Upload All button, I can see the events being sent in, but also rejected for having a bad id.

As you can see in the linked issue, Hoytech attempted re-hash an example event I copied from the logs and got an entirely different ID.

Anything I can do or configure to make this work?

Thanks!

EDIT: Forgot to mention; I am using Version: 1.33.1+282fe274 from the MSIX package.

[lapulpeta]

I replied in the other issue because it has more details, but I'll leave this open just in case the problem is on this side.

[lapulpeta]

Can you try this release to see if it works?

[IngwiePhoenix]

Nope, no dice. I did not change my timezone this time, keeping with my standard European/Berlin one.

Logs from strfry as before:

Jun 22 16:26:12 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:26:12.390 (144207.642s) [Ingester 0      ]INFO| [312] dumpInEvent: ["EVENT",{"id":"021a2a617414be2caafbce9ae3e644ff9337b6cecea66fafee4e932de373cdcc","pubkey":"5e336907a3dda5cd58f11d162d8a4c9388f9cfb2f8dc4b469c8151e379c63bc9","created_at":1687090450,"kind":5,"content":"","tags":[["e","e0e993b7ec2f54d7fd9dc5e688a1e27c2f77df28b0d8a95ad473324b5682045f"]],"sig":"1a88da3708975a355f0dfa33ad070dfb4d2af9e7a8cc845877efe2f2792cb5c665ebd9745028eb15c065def54b4281732a71e81aa192f0d5793d8e7f22930836"}]
Jun 22 16:26:12 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:26:12.395 (144207.646s) [Ingester 0      ]INFO| Rejected invalid event: bad event id
Jun 22 16:26:12 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:26:12.395 (144207.647s) [Ingester 0      ]INFO| [312] dumpInEvent: ["EVENT",{"id":"028173756d15b376732274442384d05304d2a28b049ad783905f8e3688263897","pubkey":"5e336907a3dda5cd58f11d162d8a4c9388f9cfb2f8dc4b469c8151e379c63bc9","created_at":1686836407,"kind":3,"content":"{\"wss://relay.nostr.band/\":{\"read\":true,\"write\":false},\"wss://nos.lol/\":{\"read\":true,\"write\":true},\"wss://nostr.ingwie.me/\":{\"read\":true,\"write\":true},\"wss://relay.snort.social\":{\"read\":true,\"write\":true}}","tags":[["p","d3916f42beae421694ce03938c32f4f71f967b05068b01d713b461165bdd6446"],["p","4ac24d2ee822a34a9881eff526bf71f39704419837e4c14b34642d82e111ed39"],["p","c43bbb58e2e6bc2f9455758257f6ba5329107bd4e8274068c2936c69d9980b7d"]],"sig":"aad56ec1e412957cd4c0b2c653061c51ab3330493cba41f66ad2e3472068f4e167d4ff1cc21be73399e972f6383b2beae924b21621efe4361284140d57e65f97"}]
Jun 22 16:26:12 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:26:12.395 (144207.647s) [Ingester 0      ]INFO| Rejected invalid event: bad event id
Jun 22 16:26:12 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:26:12.395 (144207.647s) [Ingester 0      ]INFO| [312] dumpInEvent: ["EVENT",{"id":"0bc534823aa6c247766d598ad42cc0726911b183145340887a26e3bccd2cf28c","pubkey":"5e336907a3dda5cd58f11d162d8a4c9388f9cfb2f8dc4b469c8151e379c63bc9","created_at":1686759536,"kind":7,"content":"+","tags":[["e","caeb5711dc51a534b1b599c4b34820262003d7e8367f91dff51d84dc07021672"],["p","89d1ce9164f1f172daaa9c784153178cb1dec7912bf55f5dc07e0f1dabe40e6c"]],"sig":"9b1e2d07682f8e14658c78124537ae2bd9d4851cc1c988075ef043071200b6f0cd167bc35661511dd4da292ac3b6148c976d12be694aae2819f7fdc5b85832dc"}]
Jun 22 16:26:12 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:26:12.395 (144207.647s) [Ingester 0      ]INFO| Rejected invalid event: bad event id
Jun 22 16:26:12 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:26:12.397 (144207.649s) [Ingester 0      ]INFO| [312] dumpInEvent: ["EVENT",{"id":"12cfc8cd9463965d01d214f0e9a932fd346546bf37b5a85997b7f3ff27593b49","pubkey":"5e336907a3dda5cd58f11d162d8a4c9388f9cfb2f8dc4b469c8151e379c63bc9","created_at":1686761901,"kind":7,"content":"💯","tags":[["e","425a6615756ff6385fb043976095fd7cea2f51cb55032318c545bb3f096be305"],["p","3f770d65d3a764a9c5cb503ae123e62ec7598ad035d836e2a810f3877a745b24"]],"sig":"0377dc12281e1115b4707bed7ee49f69b9af127cadfb6f91fc5c02fe1415e0a6519c8fb5e0d47d3a931a64e81d232500e0676ebca9f1038837d46637636ee461"}]
Jun 22 16:26:12 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:26:12.397 (144207.649s) [Ingester 0      ]INFO| Rejected invalid event: bad event id
(... it continues quite a way down, been very active! ...)

[IngwiePhoenix]

BTW, reported version is Version: 1.33.1+282fe274.

I did install the MSIX, it auto-opened the app, and that is what I used to test.

[lapulpeta]

Hm it seems like you're still running the old version. Can you try this one?

[IngwiePhoenix]

Had to re-install it; Windows complained about the installed version being equal. So I opted to un-install my current version, re-install, re-add my key and add my own relay then.

After that:

Jun 22 16:49:42 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:49:42.725 (145617.977s) [Ingester 2      ]INFO| [317] dumpInEvent: ["EVENT",{"id":"021a2a617414be2caafbce9ae3e644ff9337b6cecea66fafee4e932de373cdcc","pubkey":"5e336907a3dda5cd58f11d162d8a4c9388f9cfb2f8dc4b469c8151e379c63bc9","created_at":1687090450,"kind":5,"content":"","tags":[["e","e0e993b7ec2f54d7fd9dc5e688a1e27c2f77df28b0d8a95ad473324b5682045f"]],"sig":"1a88da3708975a355f0dfa33ad070dfb4d2af9e7a8cc845877efe2f2792cb5c665ebd9745028eb15c065def54b4281732a71e81aa192f0d5793d8e7f22930836"}]
Jun 22 16:49:42 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:49:42.725 (145617.977s) [Ingester 2      ]INFO| Rejected invalid event: bad event id
Jun 22 16:49:42 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:49:42.728 (145617.980s) [Ingester 2      ]INFO| [317] dumpInEvent: ["EVENT",{"id":"04140e9c0a9f77743ec1b4a8a472bf186d0d987dc97a8fb94b04eeef3a4fc9f0","pubkey":"5e336907a3dda5cd58f11d162d8a4c9388f9cfb2f8dc4b469c8151e379c63bc9","created_at":1687416384,"kind":6,"content":"","tags":[["e","fae8c173a8ae237f2d40b4dc04e29c191a8fd3db7abc28ba583da4cd508215d9",""],["p","9f381ea908656fc50413dbb87790b237311b7ef8a11073901285c5c4fa074f90"]],"sig":"41f7d5ebeb972338ca8db90a3140464b5f8a0efce96e9388615bb128b05d41d018f0415c63e775172711d7046726761e94e4a222a59c9cb38b47004b77b328ca"}]
Jun 22 16:49:42 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:49:42.728 (145617.980s) [Ingester 2      ]INFO| Rejected invalid event: bad event id
Jun 22 16:49:42 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:49:42.731 (145617.983s) [Ingester 2      ]INFO| [317] dumpInEvent: ["EVENT",{"id":"2c0978924a391f1c058cd701683d1baf39372aaee188e954e6e2bd935f6d5d1b","pubkey":"5e336907a3dda5cd58f11d162d8a4c9388f9cfb2f8dc4b469c8151e379c63bc9","created_at":1687416817,"kind":6,"content":"","tags":[["e","2ba6c0a8cf40dc3baefb090b4dd0300ac55792d11f3d426d11ca26f6f1c3829d",""],["p","9936a53def39d712f886ac7e2ed509ce223b534834dd29d95caba9f6bc01ef35"]],"sig":"6236e1f7f120d59c2729d9961c5d5adc58dc355e686ce848dc0218edecd7b9bdf2471af2d951a0af972782256da79139ccbc1f97035b0f5a7c31ef6a226eb853"}]
Jun 22 16:49:42 birb strfry[1199665]: 2023-06-22 16:49:42.731 (145617.983s) [Ingester 2      ]INFO| Rejected invalid event: bad event id

Reported version: Version: 1.33.2+f70c8c77

[lapulpeta]

Would it be possible for me to look into your database? Maybe you can make a clean installation and create a disposable account and try to push some events to your relay. I'd like to see if the events are stored OK. The database should be located here C:\Users\[username]\AppData\Local\Packages\[guid]\LocalState\Nostr.sqlite.db.