Error select entities from csv vr_71

[Desmoyo]

Description

When I installed the new version 23.3 the day the new version 23.3 came out, the Select of the csv vr_71 disappeared from HA, they start with Mc1 to Mc3 and some more depending on the type of circuit. I can search for that device and I have a response, I can see movement in mqttExplorer but they are not added in HA, my mqtt-hassio is always the same, I have not touched anything, if I go back to version 23.2 the devices appear again, What can happen?

Actual behavior

All vr_71 select devices disappear

Expected behavior

That those select from vr_71.csv do not disappear or can be included in HA

ebusd version

current source from git

ebusd arguments

version: '3' services: ebusd: container_name: ebusd restart: unless-stopped image: john30/ebusd:latest privileged: true environment: - EBUSD_SCANCONFIG=full - EBUSD_CONFIGPATH=/ebusd/ebusd-configuration/ebusd-2.1.x/en #ebusd/ebusd-configuration/devel/en - EBUSD_ACCESSLEVEL=* - EBUSD_DEVICE=ens:192.168.88.252:9999 - EBUSD_MQTTHOST=192.168.88.85 # - EBUSD_MQTTVAR=filter-direction= - EBUSD_MQTTPORT=1883 - EBUSD_MQTTUSER=xxxxxxxx - EBUSD_MQTTPASS=xxxxxx - EBUSD_MQTTJSON= - EBUSD_LATENCY=0 - EBUSD_MQTTINT=/ebusd/mqtt-hassio.cfg - EBUSD_UPDATECHECK=on - TZ=Europe/Madrid # - EBUSD_LOGAREAS: all - EBUSD_POLLINTERVAL=5 # - EBUSD_MQTTHOST: mqtt volumes: # - /docker/ebusd/:/ebusd/ebusd-configuration/ebusd-2.1.x/en - /docker/ebusd/:/ebusd - /etc/localtime:/etc/localtime:ro

Operating system

Debian 12 (Bookworm) / Ubuntu 22-23 / Raspberry Pi OS 12 (including lite)

CPU architecture

x64

Dockerized

latest

Hardware interface

adapter 5 via Ethernet

Related integration

MQTT Home Assistant via mqtt-hassio.cfg

Logs

29 22:32:02.237 [aviso de actualización] recibió actualización-escritura vwzio SetMode QQ=10: auto;0.0;-;-;1;0;0;0;0;0
2023-12-29 22:32:02.526 [aviso de actualización] recibido escribir vr_71 SetActorState QQ=10: -;-;-;off;off;off;-;-;-;-;-;-;00 00
2023-12-29 22:32:02.776 [aviso de actualización] recibido escribir vr_71 Mc1FlowTempDesired QQ=10: apagado;0.0;encendido;-100
2023-12-29 22:32:03.018 [aviso de actualización] recibido escribir vr_71 Mc2FlowTempDesired QQ=10: on;33.0;on;15
2023-12-29 22:32:03.366 [aviso de actualización] enviado encuesta-lectura basv0 z2Name1 QQ=31: Planta
2023-12-29 22:32:03.536 [aviso de actualización] recibido escribir vr_71 Mc3FlowTempDesired QQ=10: apagado;0.0;encendido;-

[john30]

what do you mean with the "Select of the csv"?
please provide an ebusd logging of around 1 minute since start for both versions

[Desmoyo]

¿A qué te refieres con la "Selección del csv"? proporcione un registro de ebusd de aproximadamente 1 minuto desde el inicio para ambas versiones

Hello @john30 , I don't want to say the csv section, I'm referring to the entities with writable option selection from the csv vr_71, I don't know if I explain myself, I'll give you a photo, all of those do not appear with the latest version 23.3, there's no way that HA catches them and they are lost and there are readings and they can be polled

[john30]

still dont get your point. please pick one concrete example (instead of that many) in order to track it down. then check the mqtt messages for the particular one in the definition and value part so that it will be comparable

[Desmoyo]

Todavía no entiendo tu punto. Elija un ejemplo concreto (en lugar de tantos) para poder localizarlo. luego verifique los mensajes mqtt para el mensaje en particular en la parte de definición y valor para que sea comparable

I just want to say that with the latest version of ebusd 23.3 all the entities of the vr_71 device disappear from HA and mqtt Explorer continues reading them without problem, but they do not update their state and remain unknown in HA. I have installed version 23.2 and they already work but with version 23.3 they disappear from HA.

[john30]

if thats the case then please check the HA logging and also check the discovery messages for potential differences. you didn't forget to adjust the HA integration settings as needed, right? also there were some adjustments to the integration file: 23.2...23.3#diff-4952dade4072db5f6f477603bb2c18fa861198bc099ac7f746e00fb9a853c297

[jan666]

I have the same problem, see #1357

I started with 23.3 and was unable to to the VR 70 values working. Found this ticket, downgraded to 23.2 and they are there.

[john30]

see #1357 (comment)
anyway, such messages could be sent as passive read instead to discovery. I'll check if that's feasible

[jan666]

An option to send em read only would be nice, too. I just want to log it (to make something like https://romal.de/2023/12/25/home-assistant-mit-ebusd/)

[kromosomX]

It would be great if all multi field write messages would be treated as read-only. VR71 and VR70 units get updated very often (every couple of seconds) and are therefore very useful as read only for reading important information (pump on/off, desired flow temperature, mixer status).

Also as a quick and dirty workaround you can:

1. set all writable fields as readable in configuration file 26.vr_71.csv (w->r)
2. restart ebusd
3. wait until the sensors appear in homeassistant/senos/ or just wait couple of minutes
4. set all fileds changed in step 1. back to readable
5. restart ebusd

But if you restart HA you have to do it all over again.

This could all be simplified by simply automating the generation of discovery messages for homeassistant but I don't know how to do it... yet.

[jan666]

It would be great if all multi field write messages would be treated as read-only. VR71 and VR70 units get updated very often (every couple of seconds) and are therefore very useful as read only for reading important information (pump on/off, desired flow temperature, mixer status).

Also as a quick and dirty workaround you can:

1. set all writable fields as readable in configuration file 26.vr_71.csv (w->r)
2. restart ebusd
3. wait until the sensors appear in homeassistant/senos/ or just wait couple of minutes
4. set all fileds changed in step 1. back to readable
5. restart ebusd

But if you restart HA you have to do it all over again.

This could all be simplified by simply automating the generation of discovery messages for homeassistant but I don't know how to do it... yet.

I just tried it and it works. Too bad we have to change it back to w to really get the data. Would be a nice workaround if it just worked with r in the csv

[john30]

should work in passive mode I think, so try with "u" instead of "w" or "r"

[jan666]

should work in passive mode I think, so try with "u" instead of "w" or "r"

Maybe I miss something. I did this:

-w,,SetActorState,,,,,"01",R1,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R2,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R3,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R4,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R5,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R6,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,S7,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,
-w,,Mc1FlowTempDesired,,,,,"0200",FTStatus,,onoff,,,,FTDesired,,temp1,,,,MixerStatus,s,onoff,,,,MixerMovement,s,percents,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
-w,,Mc2FlowTempDesired,,,,,"0201",FTStatus,,onoff,,,,FTDesired,,temp1,,,,MixerStatus,s,onoff,,,,MixerMovement,s,percents,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
+u,,SetActorState,,,,,"01",R1,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R2,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R3,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R4,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R5,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R6,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,S7,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,
+u,,Mc1FlowTempDesired,,,,,"0200",FTStatus,,onoff,,,,FTDesired,,temp1,,,,MixerStatus,s,onoff,,,,MixerMovement,s,percents,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
+u,,Mc2FlowTempDesired,,,,,"0201",FTStatus,,onoff,,,,FTDesired,,temp1,,,,MixerStatus,s,onoff,,,,MixerMovement,s,percents,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

so replacing the "w"s with "u"s. But then ebusd won't start:

2024-11-18 07:00:17.638 [main error] error reading scan config file vaillant/52.vr_70.csv for ID "vr_70", SW0109, HW2903: ERR: missing argument, vaillant/52.vr_70.csv:5: ERR: missing argument, circuit

[john30]

also the default line with "*w" needs to be adjusted to "*u" or duplicated with "*u"

[jan666]

52.vr_70.csv

# type (r[1-9];w;u),circuit,name,[comment],[QQ],ZZ,PBSB,[ID],field1,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field2,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field3,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field4,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field5,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field6,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field7,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment
#,VR_70,VR 70,109 109,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
*r,,,,,,"B523",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
*w,,,,,,"B523",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
*u,,,,,,"B523",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
u,,SetActorState,,,,,"01",R1,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R2,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R3,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R4,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R5,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R6,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,S7,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,
u,,Mc1FlowTempDesired,,,,,"0200",FTStatus,,onoff,,,,FTDesired,,temp1,,,,MixerStatus,s,onoff,,,,MixerMovement,s,percents,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
u,,Mc2FlowTempDesired,,,,,"0201",FTStatus,,onoff,,,,FTDesired,,temp1,,,,MixerStatus,s,onoff,,,,MixerMovement,s,percents,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
r,,SensorData,,,,,"03",S1,,temp,,,,S2,,temp,,,,S3,,temp,,,,S4,,temp,,,,S5,,temp,,,,S6,,temp,,,,ignore,,HEX:3,,,
!include,errors.inc,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

ebusd starts but

2024-11-25 07:51:55.223 [update error] unable to parse update-read vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired from 1052b5230402010150 / 020105: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:00.098 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 SetActorState: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:00.098 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:04.917 [update error] unable to parse update-read vr_70 SetActorState from 1052b523080100ff0014ffff00 / 0101: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:05.165 [update error] unable to parse update-read vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired from 1052b5230402010150 / 020105: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:10.112 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 SetActorState: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:10.112 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:14.923 [update error] unable to parse update-read vr_70 SetActorState from 1052b523080100ff0014ffff00 / 0101: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:15.171 [update error] unable to parse update-read vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired from 1052b5230402010150 / 020105: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:20.123 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 SetActorState: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:20.123 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:25.714 [update error] unable to parse update-read vr_70 SetActorState from 1052b523080100ff0014ffff00 / 0101: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:26.227 [update error] unable to parse update-read vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired from 1052b5230402010150 / 020105: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:30.135 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 SetActorState: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:30.135 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:34.959 [update error] unable to parse update-read vr_70 SetActorState from 1052b523080100ff0014ffff00 / 0101: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:35.244 [update error] unable to parse update-read vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired from 1052b5230402010150 / 020105: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:39.230 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 SetActorState: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:39.230 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:44.934 [update error] unable to parse update-read vr_70 SetActorState from 1052b523080100ff0014ffff00 / 0101: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:45.182 [update error] unable to parse update-read vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired from 1052b5230402010150 / 020105: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:49.242 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 SetActorState: ERR: invalid position
2024-11-25 07:52:49.242 [mqtt error] decode vr_70 Mc2FlowTempDesired: ERR: invalid position

and no more updates in HASS. So I guess this won't work?

[john30]

my bad, "*uw" it needs to be of course

[jan666]

52.vr_70.csv

# type (r[1-9];w;u),circuit,name,[comment],[QQ],ZZ,PBSB,[ID],field1,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field2,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field3,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field4,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field5,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field6,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field7,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment
#,VR_70,VR 70,109 109,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
*r,,,,,,"B523",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
*uw,,,,,,"B523",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
u,,SetActorState,,,,,"01",R1,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R2,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R3,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R4,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R5,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R6,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,S7,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,
u,,Mc1FlowTempDesired,,,,,"0200",FTStatus,,onoff,,,,FTDesired,,temp1,,,,MixerStatus,s,onoff,,,,MixerMovement,s,percents,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
u,,Mc2FlowTempDesired,,,,,"0201",FTStatus,,onoff,,,,FTDesired,,temp1,,,,MixerStatus,s,onoff,,,,MixerMovement,s,percents,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
r,,SensorData,,,,,"03",S1,,temp,,,,S2,,temp,,,,S3,,temp,,,,S4,,temp,,,,S5,,temp,,,,S6,,temp,,,,ignore,,HEX:3,,,
!include,errors.inc,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

2024-11-27 06:51:40.156 [main error] error reading scan config file vaillant/52.vr_70.csv for ID "vr_70", SW0109, HW2903: ERR: missing argument, vaillant/52.vr_70.csv:5: ERR: missing argument, circuit

[john30]

you need to change both, the default and the line with the message

[jan666]

Ok, I think I finally got it :)

# type (r[1-9];w;u),circuit,name,[comment],[QQ],ZZ,PBSB,[ID],field1,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field2,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field3,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field4,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field5,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field6,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment,field7,part (m/s),datatypes/templates,divider/values,unit,comment
#,VR_70,VR 70,109 109,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
*r,,,,,,"B523",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
*uw,,,,,,"B523",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
uw,,SetActorState,,,,,"01",R1,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R2,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R3,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R4,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R5,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,R6,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,,S7,,UCH,0=off;20=on,,
uw,,Mc1FlowTempDesired,,,,,"0200",FTStatus,,onoff,,,,FTDesired,,temp1,,,,MixerStatus,s,onoff,,,,MixerMovement,s,percents,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
uw,,Mc2FlowTempDesired,,,,,"0201",FTStatus,,onoff,,,,FTDesired,,temp1,,,,MixerStatus,s,onoff,,,,MixerMovement,s,percents,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
r,,SensorData,,,,,"03",S1,,temp,,,,S2,,temp,,,,S3,,temp,,,,S4,,temp,,,,S5,,temp,,,,S6,,temp,,,,ignore,,HEX:3,,,
!include,errors.inc,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

thanks for your patience.