diff --git a/perma_web/perma/templates/email/admin/registrar_request.txt b/perma_web/perma/templates/email/admin/registrar_request.txt
index 18c86e951..d7e348b36 100644
--- a/perma_web/perma/templates/email/admin/registrar_request.txt
+++ b/perma_web/perma/templates/email/admin/registrar_request.txt
@@ -1,3 +1,4 @@
-A new library account request from {{ name }} ({{ email }}) is awaiting review and approval.
+A new library account request from pending registrar, named {{ name }} (at {{ email }}) is awaiting review and approval.
+Requesting user's email:  {{ requested_by_email }}
 
 http://{{ host }}{{ confirmation_route}}
diff --git a/perma_web/perma/tests/test_views_user_management.py b/perma_web/perma/tests/test_views_user_management.py
index 468d03c91..2e3c0cf0e 100644
--- a/perma_web/perma/tests/test_views_user_management.py
+++ b/perma_web/perma/tests/test_views_user_management.py
@@ -1009,18 +1009,21 @@ def check_lib_user_labels(self, soup):
         email_label = soup.find('label', {'for': 'id_a-email'})
         self.assertEqual(email_label.text, "Your email")
 
-    def check_lib_email(self, message, new_lib):
+    def check_lib_email(self, message, new_lib, user):
         our_address = settings.DEFAULT_FROM_EMAIL
 
         self.assertIn(new_lib['name'], message.body)
         self.assertIn(new_lib['email'], message.body)
+
+        self.assertIn(user['email'], message.body)
+
         id = Registrar.objects.get(email=new_lib['email']).id
         approve_url = "http://testserver{}".format(reverse('user_management_approve_pending_registrar', args=[id]))
         self.assertIn(approve_url, message.body)
         self.assertEqual(message.subject, "Perma.cc new library registrar account request")
         self.assertEqual(message.from_email, our_address)
         self.assertEqual(message.recipients(), [our_address])
-        self.assertDictEqual(message.extra_headers, {'Reply-To': new_lib['email']})
+        self.assertDictEqual(message.extra_headers, {'Reply-To': user['email']})
 
     def check_lib_user_email(self, message, new_lib_user):
         our_address = settings.DEFAULT_FROM_EMAIL
@@ -1120,7 +1123,7 @@ def test_new_library_submit_success(self):
                           success_url=reverse('register_library_instructions'))
         expected_emails_sent += 2
         self.assertEqual(len(mail.outbox), expected_emails_sent)
-        self.check_lib_email(mail.outbox[expected_emails_sent - 2], new_lib)
+        self.check_lib_email(mail.outbox[expected_emails_sent - 2], new_lib, new_lib_user)
         self.check_lib_user_email(mail.outbox[expected_emails_sent - 1], new_lib_user)
 
         # Not logged in, submit all fields including first and last name
@@ -1136,7 +1139,7 @@ def test_new_library_submit_success(self):
                           success_url=reverse('register_library_instructions'))
         expected_emails_sent += 2
         self.assertEqual(len(mail.outbox), expected_emails_sent)
-        self.check_lib_email(mail.outbox[expected_emails_sent - 2], new_lib)
+        self.check_lib_email(mail.outbox[expected_emails_sent - 2], new_lib, new_lib_user)
         self.check_lib_user_email(mail.outbox[expected_emails_sent - 1], new_lib_user)
 
         # Logged in
@@ -1150,7 +1153,7 @@ def test_new_library_submit_success(self):
                           user=existing_lib_user['email'])
         expected_emails_sent += 1
         self.assertEqual(len(mail.outbox), expected_emails_sent)
-        self.check_lib_email(mail.outbox[expected_emails_sent - 1], new_lib)
+        self.check_lib_email(mail.outbox[expected_emails_sent - 1], new_lib, existing_lib_user)
 
     def test_new_library_submit_failure(self):
         '''
diff --git a/perma_web/perma/views/user_management.py b/perma_web/perma/views/user_management.py
index 88e189780..e1828a238 100755
--- a/perma_web/perma/views/user_management.py
+++ b/perma_web/perma/views/user_management.py
@@ -1235,12 +1235,12 @@ def libraries(request):
         request_data = request.session.get('request_data','')
         user_form = None
         if not request.user.is_authenticated():
-            user_form = UserForm(prefix = "a")
+            user_form = UserForm(prefix="a")
             user_form.fields['email'].label = "Your email"
         if request_data:
-            registrar_form = LibraryRegistrarForm(request_data, prefix ="b")
+            registrar_form = LibraryRegistrarForm(request_data, prefix="b")
         else:
-            registrar_form = LibraryRegistrarForm(prefix ="b")
+            registrar_form = LibraryRegistrarForm(prefix="b")
 
     return render(request, "registration/sign-up-libraries.html",
         {'user_form':user_form, 'registrar_form':registrar_form})
@@ -1484,14 +1484,21 @@ def email_registrar_request(request, pending_registrar):
     Send email to Perma.cc admins when a library requests an account
     """
     host = request.get_host()
+    try:
+        email = request.user.email
+    except AttributeError:
+        # User did not have an account
+        email = request.POST.get('a-email')
+
     send_admin_email(
         "Perma.cc new library registrar account request",
-        pending_registrar.email,
+        email,
         request,
         'email/admin/registrar_request.txt',
         {
             "name": pending_registrar.name,
             "email": pending_registrar.email,
+            "requested_by_email": email,
             "host": host,
             "confirmation_route": reverse('user_management_approve_pending_registrar', args=[pending_registrar.id])
         }