Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Elaborating on the Gridcoin wikipedia page (without changing wikipedia) #271

Open
grctest opened this issue Jan 20, 2025 · 4 comments
Open

Comments

@grctest
Copy link
Contributor

grctest commented Jan 20, 2025

Gridcoin has a wikipedia page unlike most cryptocurrency: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gridcoin

Updates to Gridcoin's history there seem to end at 2017, but there's plenty of things that have happened which aren't mentioned, such as:

It also follows quite a different format from other cryptocurreny wiki pages

  • Most have sections: History, Design, Usage, Achievements/Milestones
  • Most don't delve into past software vulnerabilities

Re The whitelist/greylist system & the wikipedia entry opening:

"Gridcoin (abbreviation: GRC) is a cryptocurrency which rewards volunteer computing performed on the BOINC network.[1][4][5][6] Originally developed to support SETI@home,[7] it has also been used for research in other areas."

Compared to the Gridcoin.us intro:

"Gridcoin is an open source cryptocurrency (Ticker: GRC) that rewards volunteer computing for science through the BOINC platform and Folding@home."

There is no singular 'BOINC network', there's a mutually developed platform which anyone can use to run their own BOINC project; there isn't centralized control over any such network.

Gridcoin also doesn't reward all BOINC based volunteer computing, but rather a subset of projects which are voted onto a whitelist. This concept is missing from the wiki, as is the current BOINC project whitelist contents.

Gridcoin is mentioned as open source on its main website intro, but not in the intro on its gridcoin wiki entry. Bitcoin has mention of open source code in its introduction.


Re the software vulnerability section:

"An exploit was demonstrated in August 2017 that revealed the emails of Gridcoin users and allowed the theft of other users work. The research team disclosed the vulnerability to the developers in September 2016, and the patch for the vulnerability was released in March 2017 with version 3.5.8.7, however the implementation of the fix introduced other issues.[10]"

IIRC They did not in fact disclose the vulnerability properly, they sent an email to an unmonitored address, then it was publicly disclosed before the fix was in place, no?

What other issues were introduced by the fix? Surely commentary about march 2017 code is inconsistent with 2025 code? Thus the wiki shouldn't end the sentence on "the fix introduced other issues." without elaborating?

Bitcoin for example also had vulnerabilities, yet their wiki doesn't mention this at all.

@barton2526
Copy link
Member

barton2526 commented Jan 20, 2025

Do not touch the wikipedia page. All edits are being reverted by an anti-crypto Wikipedia moderator. We have been warned that making further edits to the page may result in its removal entirely.

Gridcoin is mentioned as open source on its main website intro, but not in the intro on its gridcoin wiki entry. Bitcoin has mention of open source code in its introduction.

This is an example of something that the moderators reverted. Check the history.

https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Gridcoin&action=history

@jamescowens
Copy link
Member

@grctest @barton2526 is right on this. I tried to update it a couple of years ago and got my face kicked in by that moderator. Sure wish we could fix this...

@grctest
Copy link
Contributor Author

grctest commented Jan 20, 2025

Understood, I know that wikipedia's editing system is highly contentious - I had heard about moderation requiring a high degree of sourcing for changes.

Worth talking through the errors and missing information in here at least, to let the record show and if in the future we're allowed to make changes there'll be proper contents that meets wikipedia's standards to use.

As it stands it's missing a lot of information, includes errors and misleads people with regards to the future of Gridcoin after 2017, IMO.

@jamescowens
Copy link
Member

We should write up how we want the page to actually look. I agree. Worth the effort. Isn't there a crypto wiki that this would be valuable for that is not associated with wikipedia?

@grctest grctest changed the title Possible updates to the Gridcoin wikipedia page? Elaborating on the Gridcoin wikipedia page (without changing wikipedia) Jan 24, 2025
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants