-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 2.6k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Git for windows crashed in Windows 10 latest build (14251.1000) #627
Comments
Same problem here :-( |
Same problem here, error module is ntdll.dll, exception code: 0xc0000005 |
People. Please read our issue reporting guidelines and improve this report accordingly. Anything else will only result in major frustration on all sides, and that is not what anybody would possibly want. |
I also get this problem when using git command. It crashes git. I also get Segmentation fault inside the git program. |
@paladox and you also do not list precise version informations as well as a precise account (preferably with a copy-paste of the output) of what you did. Really, please read the issue reporting guide lines. It is really frustrating to receive so incomplete information. |
Sorry. When running git --version I get Segmentation fault because of git command being faulty in the latest windows 10 insider build as of 27/01/2016. Also I am running 2.7.0 64-bit. |
@dscho All I do is start git bash from the windows start button then in git bash I do this command git to test it. And returns Segmentation fault. |
Did you try cmd, what commands crash, etc etc etc etc etc |
yes. As soon as I enter git in cmd running as admin it brings up the crash dialog for git for windows. Also when starting git ui I get this error popup cannot determine git version: child kild: segmentation violation git gui requires git 1.5.0 or later. |
What happens when you run |
When I run net use /? it brings up the Net Command has stopped working. |
I'm having the same issue in Running installed or portable
Running
Git-gui also fails to start with:
Running
|
Running Windows 10
|
same here: Windows 10 Pro Insider Preview x64 build if the WER reports are of any use, I can provide them privately.
|
Same issue here
|
Same issue here, but probably due to this Windows build in my opinion (Windows 10 Pro Insider Preview x64 build 14251.rs1_release.160124-1059). Git 2.7.0 x32 or x64 is completely broken, unable to run Git (the installer is also failing when trying to call git). Git 2.6.2 works locally, but I cannot pull or push (git-remote-https was unable to start correctly error code 0x0000142). net use /? is also crashing on my machine. Looking at this windows build changelog: ... |
@sailro I restarted several times (before reinstall and after) no luck. I installed |
It was brought to my attention by @onovotny that you should be able to workaround this issue by installing an earlier version of Git for Windows:
|
Seems like 2.6.2 also works. |
@onovotny 2.6.2 works locally but crash with network actions (pull/push). I will try 2.6.1 then 1.9.x |
@onovotny 2.6.1 crash also with network actions (pull/push) |
awesome! isn't it great to be on beta OS code :) FWIW, there is a note in the release notes that things may crash in this build due to changes in the memory manager. I would expect this to be fixed in the next build or two; I doubt there's really any need to fix anything in Git. |
I love that :(. After next release I will opt out |
So now the Q is what's the latest version that works? :) |
We have to rollback to the 1.9.x generation with msysgit |
Or us VS 2015 with LibGit2 to do network ops, at least until the next build ;) How about a PowerShell script that wraps LibGit2 to do push/pull/fetch? |
I rolled back to prevous build and now git works. |
Just as a point of reference, I'm running GFW 3.0.11.2 on Win10 14251.rs1_release.160124-1059 on a Surface Pro 3 and I am not seeing any issues. |
Hello there,
I didn't get access to build 14256 yet, did anybody already have? For those experiencing this issue and who really needs Git daily, a (maybe better) workaround than the suggested by Microsoft on the known issues (rollback to the previous build) is to use another git client that is independent of "Git for Windows", such as GitKraken . Regards, |
Yes, I do ;-) Seriously, you need to be prepared for things to break when you are on any kind of early access program. The entire point is to catch breakages early there. You will most likely find that Git for Windows is not the only application affected by the memory management issue, so eventually you will have to roll back anyway instead of keeping fire-fighting. |
Apologies to the interruption to dscho's day with this notification, but I just wanted to say thank you for the patch. I'm still on 14251 but as soon as I get access to 14256 I'll switch to the slow ring. If it makes you feel any better Microsoft also broke VirtualBox with this release. Those are the only two problems I've seen so far. |
Build 14257 has just landed on the Fast Ring - https://twitter.com/GabeAul/status/695034380524216320 |
For me Jenkins with git is now working, only there is still a issue with git desktop: trace: built-in: git 'clone' '--progress' '--recursive' '--' 'https://github.com/810/Kunena-Forum.git' 'Kunena-Forum' So you can't send any PR |
@810 can you confirm this is working with Git for Windows 2.7.x - I'm planning to update GitHub Desktop to this version very soon, and don't quite have access to the latest Fast Ring build... |
im running Git Desktop 3.0.12.0 But i have a response, from a microsoft edge program manager, and he said that the fix isn't in the new release. But he has to double check the issue now |
@810 GitHub Desktop is using Git 2.5.3 for some operations - are you able to install Git for Windows 2.7.0 (can be installed alongside) and see that a clone succeeds? |
with 2.7.0 the same: fatal: Unable to find remote helper for 'https' |
Ok cool, so we're not completely fixed yet. Thanks for confirming my suspicion. |
@810 after discussing with more people as they've updated to 14257, I don't believe this is a general issue with the new release but something specific to your setup (as you could reproduce it across different versions of Git for Windows). Please open a new issue with a Minimal, Complete, and Verifiable example to help us understand the issue you're seeing. |
@SeanBlader apologies accepted. But please note that you are not interrupting my day. You are probably referring to my earlier unfortunate outbreaks when I was really struggling to get this bug fixed as soon as possible or at least to provide a work-around, and all I got for trying were remarks that seemed to be designed to make me feel bad for my efforts. I am certain you understand! |
@810 @shiftkey this sounds like something deleted @810 can you look for the file If it is not there, is it possible that some overzealous anti-virus in your setup quarantined it? If it is there, could you open a Git Bash and try to run $ git remote-https
error: remote-curl: usage: git remote-curl <remote> [<url>] If it does not show that, could you use the Dependency Walker to see whether there are any DLL files that (sorry, I did not find a way to copy & paste this as text). Another approach might be to look whether |
Update: I believe that this issue is related to top-down DLL loading. VirtualBox had similar issues: https://www.virtualbox.org/ticket/10128. When I set those registry entries accordingly, Git for Windows starts failing again, even with build 14257. |
I can confirm that setting AllocationPreference as described causes mingw-w64-x86_64-git-2.7.0.2.57599f7-1 to crash with segmentation fault. |
Hmm. According to the release notes of VirtualBox 4.2.2, issue 10128 was fixed with the note
But the commit with the message
is particularly unhelpful: mirror/vbox@e1f2bde So it sadly seems that we cannot imitate their fix. |
C:\Users\jelle\AppData\Local\GitHub\PortableGit_c7e0cbde92ba565cb218a521411d0e854079a28c\mingw32\libexec\git-core File is there
Just windows defender
fatal: 'remote-https' appears to be a git command, but we were not able to execute it. Maybe git-remote-https is broken?
i see some html. so that worked. I tried uninstalling git everywhere and installing again, same issue |
@810 hmpf. It does not really look as if your problem matches the title of this ticket. So let's avoid utter confusion and can I please have a new ticket for your issue? |
Back to this ticket:
I found the culprit, and it has nothing to do with the reported crash in 14251. So let's stop here: a new Insider Preview has been released to the Fast Track, and Git for Windows works without any patch, so there was nothing Git for Windows had to fix. |
dscho: That's awesome! Thanks for you hard work, this issue does not affect me, but I follow development of this project closely and I am very grateful for your efforts :) |
Hi,
I got Git crash immediately running under latest insider build of 14251.1000. I knew its arguable about the "latest" one, but please help. Thank you.
Git for Windows version 2.7.0.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: