diff --git a/snuba/utils/health_info.py b/snuba/utils/health_info.py
index baeb00b965..fc80e74fac 100644
--- a/snuba/utils/health_info.py
+++ b/snuba/utils/health_info.py
@@ -107,10 +107,10 @@ def get_health_info(thorough: Union[bool, str]) -> HealthInfo:
     payload = json.dumps(body)
     if status != 200:
         metrics.increment("healthcheck_failed", tags=metric_tags)
-        logger.error(f"Snuba health check failed! Tags: {metric_tags}")
-
-    if status != 200 or down_file_exists:
-        logger.info(payload)
+        if down_file_exists:
+            logger.error("Snuba health check failed! Tags: %s", metric_tags)
+        else:
+            logger.info("Snuba health check failed! Tags: %s", metric_tags)
 
     metrics.timing(
         "healthcheck.latency",