Post-Judging QA

[PaperParachute]

1. Please post feedback about specific findings on the relevant issue in this repo.
2. More general feedback for the judge can be shared here.

The judge for this contest is @MarioPoneder .

Reminders

• Please keep your comments as fact-based as possible.
• C4 judges have final authority in determining validity and severity.
• You are welcome to start new discussions here!
• Please link to specific issues wherever relevant.

Thank you!

[mcgrathcoutinho]

Hi @MarioPoneder, thanks for the quick judging on this one.

I have left my comments on #402

Thank you for your time.

[MarioPoneder]

Answered in comments

[romeroadrian]

Hi @MarioPoneder, I left some comments in the following issues, thanks for double checking these.

• Max withdrawable calculation is incorrect in asD contract #360 (comment)
• User is taken less fees when selling tokens in batch #362 (comment)
• Users will lose rewards when buying new tokens if they already own some tokens #9 (comment)

[romeroadrian]

Left more comments here #360 (comment) 🙏

[MarioPoneder]

Answered all in comments, also awaiting sponsor input.

[romeroadrian]

Thanks. Left more comments here:

• User is taken less fees when selling tokens in batch #362 (comment)
• Users will lose rewards when buying new tokens if they already own some tokens #9 (comment)

[MarioPoneder]

Answered again

[MarioPoneder]

Dear Wardens!
It was a pleasure judging this contest.

Some points to consider:

• The deadline for this post-judging QA is 2023-12-02 12:00 UTC.
  Please respect that, later comments cannot be considered.
• I am out of office over the weekend, so please don't be worried if I don't provide an answer to your comments before Monday or Tuesday.
• Please tag me in this discussion thread if you commented on an issue, otherwise I could miss it.
  Therefore, it's not necessary to tag me on the comment itself.
• Feel free to point out inconsistencies and unfairness.
  I gave my best to be strict but fair, nevertheless we are humans with different views/opinions and tend to make mistakes.

Kind regards,
0xTheC0der

[d3e4]

@MarioPoneder I left comments on #25, #104, #228, #292 and #498.

[MarioPoneder]

Answered in comments

[ustas-eth]

Hey @MarioPoneder! Thanks for judging this contest!

I've left a comment: #151 (comment)

[MarioPoneder]

Answered in comments of primary issue

[shealtielanz]

Heyy @MarioPoneder
#412
thank you for your time.

[MarioPoneder]

Answered in comments

[bart1e]

Hi @MarioPoneder, thank you for judging this contest.
I would like to ask to take a look at the comment I have added at #270. Thank you.

[MarioPoneder]

Answered in comments

[osmanozdemir1]

Hi @MarioPoneder
Thank you for your hard work and super fast judging 💯
I left a comment on #313 and I'd be glad if you could take a look when you have time
Thanks

[MarioPoneder]

Answered in comments!

[Aamirusmani1552]

Hi @MarioPoneder
Thank you for judging this contest.
I left a comment on #295. Please have a look at it.
Thanks

[MarioPoneder]

Answered in comments!

[kazantseff]

Hey @MarioPoneder
I've left a comment: #261

[MarioPoneder]

Answered in comments

[cryptostaker2]

Hi @MarioPoneder,
I left a comment on #433.

Thanks for your time!

[MarioPoneder]

Answered in comments

[Bauchibred]

Hi @MarioPoneder, thanks for judging, left a comment on #276.

[MarioPoneder]

Answered in comments

[SovaSlava]

Hi @MarioPoneder, thanks for judging, left a comment on #451

[MarioPoneder]

Answered in comments