Multiple views sticky state

[gilsmdt]

Hi,

I've have this setup

1. Primary view (sticky + DSR)
2. Secondary view (sticky + DSR)
   2.1 nested view
3. getting into state A in primary view
4. getting into state B in primary view
5. getting into state C.C1 in secondary view
6. getting into state C.C2 in secondary view

for some reason when changing to state C2 in secondary view the state in Primary view is changed.
Is this a bug or it's not supported to have sticky views in multiple views?

[gilsmdt]

Hi,

I've checked it with version 0.13 and it works fine.
Something changed on 0.14 that causes this issue.

[jsniffen]

Adding my plunker with the same problem. Version 0.13 does not have this issue.

http://plnkr.co/edit/6ZQscNVqlNhzaqCwRyrp?p=preview

[winniehell]

I made a similar example before finding this issue.

Select

• Bacon
• Jellyfish
• Garlic
• Spam
• Octocat

in that order and you'll end up with I like Bacon with Octocat! though Spam is selected.

0.0.14 does not work: http://plnkr.co/edit/8GLYjQ?p=preview
0.0.13 works: http://plnkr.co/edit/FKCRwK?p=preview

[christopherthielen]

@winniehell both plunks behave the same for me, unless I'm misunderstanding something.

[winniehell]

Strange, this is how it looks for me in Firefox:

0.0.13

0.0.14

[winniehell]

It is important to have the exact same order as I have written it above for the bug to appear. This works for example:

• Bacon
• Garlic
• Spam
• Jellyfish
• Octocat

[vellotis]

I ran into the same bug. Before I found this issue report I made this plunker.

At the same time v0.0.13 works without issues for my plunker.

[asoesilo]

+1 in v0.0.14. It works after I switch back to v0.0.13.

[christopherthielen]

dupe #212

[christopherthielen]

@winniehell I believe I have a fix for #217 which fixes your plunker:

http://plnkr.co/edit/uu5EQFUEcKrwKnuuqrZv?p=preview

Also, it's interesting to note that I can't get your plunker to fail using Chrome. Using Firefox, it fails just like you describe.

[christopherthielen]

@vellotis your plunker is fixed by removing the "sticky: true" on the .one and .two substates. Sticky states must have a unique named ui-view to plug into. If you need one/two to be sticky as well, create named ui-views for them.

http://plnkr.co/edit/55eg8Ln5bp3YDswWgThu?p=preview

[christopherthielen]

@juliansniff With a little tweak, your plunker is solved with the fix for #217

Multiple sticky states cannot "share" a named view (in your plunk, they're both trying to use 'main' named view). I pulled the sticky state up to a parent state, then made home and about as children to the parent sticky state.

http://plnkr.co/edit/3aYRAwsZ53RAXtA1VXeE?p=preview

[vellotis]

I played around with your improved plunker. It still misbehaves. Modified the order of these links: http://plnkr.co/edit/rxsFx0WPxbbu4Yz0WSfD?p=preview

[christopherthielen]

@vellotis sorry, I needed to plug in the new 0.0.15-pre2 with the fix for #217 for your plunk as well

http://plnkr.co/edit/Lvud4PKb27T2qYURVKCK?p=preview

[christopherthielen]

@vellotis ping, can you confirm please?
Everyone else can you read my comments? I think this issue is ready to be closed.

[vellotis]

@christopherthielen Sry. I confirm that it is working and you can close the issue.

[gilsmdt]

Looks good on the plnkr.
I'll test it after the weekend on our code and verify.

Thanks for handling it.

[christopherthielen]

Closing as fixed.