Inconsistent Location in AWS.S3.ManagedUpload callback

[fedot]

AWS.S3.ManagedUpload callback may get Location property with url which has URI encoded pathname (/ replaced by %2F) if it's a multi-part upload.

This is response for a 6mb file upload:
s3.upload(params).send(...)

{
  "Location": "https://stream-upload-tests.s3.amazonaws.com/stream-uploads%2Fkokoko.gif",
  "Bucket": "stream-upload-tests",
  "Key": "stream-uploads/kokoko.gif",
  "ETag": "\"e05220150932565fe8ccef113eed2d8a-2\""
}

This is response for uploading same file but with only one part:
s3.upload(params,{partSize: 10 * 1024 * 1024, queueSize:1}).send(...)

{
  "ETag": "\"0a2ac29f85722128c5a55ababd53106a\"",
  "Location": "https://stream-upload-tests.s3.amazonaws.com/stream-uploads/kokoko2.gif",
  "key": "stream-uploads/kokoko2.gif",
  "Key": "stream-uploads/kokoko2.gif",
  "Bucket": "stream-upload-tests"
}

[chrisradek]

@fedot
Thanks for reporting this. This inconsistency is happening because the multi-part upload returns the location URI encoded, whereas when the uploader does a putObject (single part) upload, we generate the Location ourselves.

We'll have to see what format the other SDKs return Location as, but we should be able to at least make it consistent across all upload calls.

[ovaillancourt]

Hi! Just wanted to mention that we've noted the same issue.

We're working around it by rebuilding the url from the Bucket and Key parts of the response as those are consistent.

[lock]

This thread has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. Please open a new issue for related bugs and link to relevant comments in this thread.