diff --git a/internal/cli/prompts_custom_text.go b/internal/cli/prompts_custom_text.go
index 6f30a368d..bdb82e46e 100644
--- a/internal/cli/prompts_custom_text.go
+++ b/internal/cli/prompts_custom_text.go
@@ -217,9 +217,12 @@ func downloadDefaultBrandingTextTranslations(prompt, language string) map[string
 			return nil
 		}
 
-		selectedPrompt := allPrompts[0][prompt].(map[string]interface{})
-
-		return selectedPrompt
+		for _, value := range allPrompts {
+			_, ok := value[prompt]
+			if ok {
+				return value[prompt].(map[string]interface{})
+			}
+		}
 	}
 
 	return nil
diff --git a/test/integration/fixtures/update-ul-prompts-login.json b/test/integration/fixtures/update-ul-prompts-login.json
new file mode 100644
index 000000000..473b4e0c5
--- /dev/null
+++ b/test/integration/fixtures/update-ul-prompts-login.json
@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
+{
+  "login": {
+    "pageTitle": "Log in | ${clientName}",
+    "title": "Welcome",
+    "description": "Log in to ${companyName} to continue to ${clientName}.",
+    "separatorText": "Or",
+    "buttonText": "Continue",
+    "federatedConnectionButtonText": "Continue with ${connectionName}",
+    "footerLinkText": "Sign up",
+    "signupActionLinkText": "${footerLinkText}",
+    "footerText": "Don't have an account?",
+    "signupActionText": "${footerText}",
+    "forgotPasswordText": "Forgot password?",
+    "passwordPlaceholder": "Password",
+    "usernamePlaceholder": "Username or email address",
+    "emailPlaceholder": "Email address",
+    "editEmailText": "Edit",
+    "alertListTitle": "Alerts",
+    "invitationTitle": "You've Been Invited!",
+    "invitationDescription": "Log in to accept ${inviterName}'s invitation to join ${companyName} on ${clientName}.",
+    "logoAltText": "${companyName}",
+    "showPasswordText": "Show password",
+    "hidePasswordText": "Hide password",
+    "wrong-credentials": "Wrong username or password",
+    "invalid-email-format": "Email is not valid.",
+    "wrong-email-credentials": "Wrong email or password",
+    "custom-script-error-code": "Something went wrong, please try again later.",
+    "auth0-users-validation": "Something went wrong, please try again later",
+    "authentication-failure": "We are sorry, something went wrong when attempting to login",
+    "invalid-connection": "Invalid connection",
+    "ip-blocked": "We have detected suspicious login behavior and further attempts will be blocked. Please contact the administrator.",
+    "no-db-connection": "Invalid connection",
+    "password-breached": "We have detected a potential security issue with this account. To protect your account, we have prevented this login. Please reset your password to proceed.",
+    "user-blocked": "Your account has been blocked after multiple consecutive login attempts.",
+    "same-user-login": "Too many login attempts for this user. Please wait, and try again later.",
+    "no-email": "Please enter an email address",
+    "no-password": "Password is required",
+    "no-username": "Username is required"
+  }
+}
diff --git a/test/integration/fixtures/update-ul-prompts-mfa-push.json b/test/integration/fixtures/update-ul-prompts-mfa-push.json
new file mode 100644
index 000000000..7f5a77af9
--- /dev/null
+++ b/test/integration/fixtures/update-ul-prompts-mfa-push.json
@@ -0,0 +1,64 @@
+{
+  "mfa-push-welcome": {
+    "pageTitle": "Install the application | ${clientName}",
+    "title": "Secure Your Account",
+    "description": "In order to continue, install the ${appName} app via the app store from your mobile device.",
+    "androidButtonText": "Google Play",
+    "buttonText": "Continue",
+    "iosButtonText": "App Store",
+    "pickAuthenticatorText": "Try another method",
+    "logoAltText": "${companyName}"
+  },
+  "mfa-push-enrollment-qr": {
+    "pageTitle": "Scan the code to log in using a push notification | ${clientName}",
+    "title": "Secure Your Account",
+    "description": "Scan the QR Code below using the ${appName} app on your mobile device.",
+    "pickAuthenticatorText": "Try another method",
+    "buttonText": "Continue",
+    "logoAltText": "${companyName}",
+    "enrollment-transaction-pending": "You must scan the QR code with the ${appName} app on your mobile device."
+  },
+  "mfa-push-enrollment-code": {
+    "pageTitle": "Copy the code to log in using a push notification | ${clientName}",
+    "buttonText": "Continue",
+    "altText": "Secure code to copy",
+    "copyCodeButtonText": "Copy Code",
+    "instructions1": "Open the ${appName} app on your phone and tap \"+\" button.",
+    "instructions2": "Select Add account manually",
+    "instructions3": "Copy & paste this code to that screen",
+    "title": "Trouble scanning?",
+    "logoAltText": "${companyName}"
+  },
+  "mfa-push-success": {
+    "pageTitle": "Device registration successful | ${clientName}",
+    "title": "You're All Set!",
+    "buttonText": "Continue",
+    "description": "We’re redirecting you to ${clientName} now. If you’re not redirected automatically, you can manually redirect yourself below."
+  },
+  "mfa-push-challenge-push": {
+    "pageTitle": "Accept the push notification to log in | ${clientName}",
+    "title": "Verify Your Identity",
+    "description": "We’ve sent a notification to the following device via the ${appName} app:",
+    "buttonText": "I've responded on my device",
+    "pickAuthenticatorText": "Try another method",
+    "rememberMeText": "Remember this device for 30 days",
+    "resendActionText": "Resend",
+    "resendText": "Didn't receive a notification?",
+    "enterOtpCode": "Manually Enter Code",
+    "separatorText": "OR",
+    "logoAltText": "${companyName}",
+    "challenge-transaction-pending": "You must accept the notification via the ${appName} app on your mobile device.",
+    "polling-interval-exceeded": "We have not received a confirmation, please slow down.",
+    "too-many-push": "We have received too many notification requests. Wait a few minutes and try again.",
+    "transaction-not-found": "Your enrollment transaction expired, you will need to start again.",
+    "mfa-push-verify-transaction-pending": "We have not received a confirmation, please try scanning the code again.",
+    "mfa-push-verify-authenticator-error": "We couldn't verify the enrollment. Please try again later.",
+    "mfa-push-challenge-authenticator-error": "We couldn't send the notification. Please try again later.",
+    "transaction-rejected": "Notification rejected"
+  },
+  "mfa-push-list": {
+    "pageTitle": "List of available devices | ${clientName}",
+    "backText": "Go back",
+    "title": "Registered Devices"
+  }
+}
diff --git a/test/integration/test-cases.yaml b/test/integration/test-cases.yaml
index 255573f57..9d2d003ac 100644
--- a/test/integration/test-cases.yaml
+++ b/test/integration/test-cases.yaml
@@ -710,3 +710,11 @@ tests:
         display_name: "Integration Test Updated Organization"
         branding.colors.page_background: "#AA1166"
         branding.colors.primary: "#00FFAA"
+
+  update universal login branding prompts (login):
+    command: cat ./test/integration/fixtures/update-ul-prompts-login.json | auth0 ul prompts update login
+    exit-code: 0
+
+  update universal login branding prompts (mfa-push):
+    command: cat ./test/integration/fixtures/update-ul-prompts-mfa-push.json | auth0 ul prompts update mfa-push
+    exit-code: 0