[[email protected]] APQ registration causes "addProtobufError called before startTiming!"

[vanwalj]

I'm using apollo-server-lambda to serve a GraphQL Application in an AWS Lambda and apollo-client with apollo-link-persisted-queries so I can benefit from "persisted queries" feature

Upgrading to 2.12.0 broke the persisted queries requests, the server is now returning a 500 error whenever a client make a request using the persisted query extension

Here is a query exemple

{"operationName":"Themes","variables":{},"extensions":{"persistedQuery":{"version":1,"sha256Hash":"abc5e6f7d2b18d51853698b172c002b7866af0cab36178a6867b8f0f92a61a60"}}}

And here is the server response

{"errors":[{"message":"[internal apollo-server error] addProtobufError called before startTiming!","extensions":{"code":"INTERNAL_SERVER_ERROR"}}]}

Rollbacking apollo-server-lambda to 2.11.0 fixed the issue

[trevor-scheer]

Thanks for the report @vanwalj. Can you please provide a reproduction? We'll start looking into this today but anything helps.

[abernix]

Seems related to #3627, which recently seems to have resurfaced #3627 (comment) and was still present in 2.11.0.

[abernix]

Looking into this now!

[abernix]

I tried to reproduce this, deploying all the way to Lambda using serverless (the precise instructions are in our documentation, the only change I made was providing an ENGINE_API_KEY within the environment: property of provider within the serverless.yml).

However, I was unable to re-create this using [email protected] with Apollo Graph Manager enabled.

To move forward, we'll need much more precise reproduction steps (e.g. is this via POST, GET, directly invoked Lambda payload?, and as many details as you can provide!), as nothing would seem to have changed in the 2.12.0 release that would triangulate to the manifestation you're seeing here.

[vanwalj]

Thank you @trevor-scheer and @abernix for your investigations, I will try this week to isolate the problem on my side so we can reproduce it, I'll keep you updated!

Thanks again!

[abernix]

Happy to re-open this if you're able to provide a reproduction, but I'm going to close it for now.