passing parameters between manifest and deploy.yml

[chosun41]

basically have two triggers tied to same action, where i am trying to pass the inputs from triggers to the action. right now the action doesn't recognize the value of these trigger arguments.

followed the pattern on this site.

https://github.com/apache/incubator-openwhisk-wskdeploy/blob/master/docs/wskdeploy_triggerrule_trigger_bindings.md#triggers-and-rules

also this is what it says as far as my packages
when i run "bx wsk package list"

packages
/adam-johnson-sandbox_walmart-watering-dev/walmart_watering private
/adam-johnson-sandbox_walmart-watering-dev/Bluemix_walmart-watering-dev-db_wsk private

can't attach yamls so stored in zip file the manifest and deploy.yml files
yamls.zip

[pritidesai]

Once the trigger is defined as alarm type, the trigger inputs are not propagated to actions:

I modified manifest to:

    triggers:
      meetPerson:
        feed: /whisk.system/alarms/alarm
        inputs:
          name: string
          place: string
          children: integer
          height: float

deployment to:

            inputs:
              name: Elrond
              place: Rivendell
              children: 3
              height: 1.88
              cron: "0 7 29,30 6 *"

wsk activation returns:

        "result": {
            "details": "You have 0 children and are 0 m. tall.",
            "greeting": "Hello,  from "
        }

instead of:

        "result": {
            "details": "You have 3 children and are 1.88 m. tall.",
            "greeting": "Hello, Elrond from Rivendell"
        }

[pritidesai]

the same behavior is seen with wsk CLI:

wsk trigger create my-alarm-trigger-1 --feed /whisk.system/alarms/alarm --param name Priti --param place Home --param cron "* * * * *"

Creating rule:

wsk rule create my-rule-1 my-alarm-trigger-1 hello_world_package/hello_world_triggerrule

Fire trigger:

wsk trigger fire my-alarm-trigger-1

Result had no name and place assigned:

wsk activation get 1b150c7339ab4074950c7339ab40741a ... "result": {
            "details": "You have 0 children and are 0 m. tall.",
            "greeting": "Hello,  from "

V/S Non Feed Trigger:

wsk trigger create my-no-alarm-trigger --param name Priti --param place Home

Creating rule with:

wsk rule create my-rule-2 my-no-alarm-trigger hello_world_package/hello_world_triggerrule

Fire trigger and check the result:

            "details": "You have 0 children and are 0 m. tall.",
            "greeting": "Hello, Priti from Home"
        }

[pritidesai]

Confirmed with @beemarie that it does work through IBM Cloud Functions UI.

[csantanapr]

@pritidesai @beemarie

With alarm feed you need to use the parameter trigger_payload

For example:

wsk trigger create my-alarm-trigger-1 --feed /whisk.system/alarms/alarm --param cron "30 2 * * *" --param trigger_payload "{\"name\":\"Priti\",\"place\":\"Home\"}"

More info in the alarm docs:
https://github.com/apache/incubator-openwhisk-package-alarms#firing-a-trigger-on-a-time-based-schedule-using-cron

[pritidesai]

thanks @csantanapr I talked to @dubee and tried the same with trigger_payload without any success:

Trigger create with:

wsk trigger create locationUpdate --param name Odin --param place Asgard

Creates parameters under Parameters section in UI

But when I create alarm trigger with:

wsk trigger create periodic --feed /whisk.system/alarms/alarm --param cron "*/2 * * * *" --param trigger_payload "{\"name\":\"Odin\",\"place\":\"Asgard\"}"

doesnt show any parameters in UI

[pritidesai]

It does show payload on trigger with:

wsk trigger get periodic
   "response": {
        "result": {
            "config": {
                "cron": "*/2 * * * *",
                "name": "periodic",
                "namespace": "",
                "payload": {
                    "name": "Odin",
                    "place": "Asgard"
                }
            },

[jasonpet]

the action should also show the trigger_payload. It will be under a param called payload though just as it shows for trigger get.

[pritidesai]

@jasonpet nope action doesn't show such parameter, also, @dubee referenced couple of issues from CLI repo ...