Can't acquire connection from pool #113
Comments
|
Hi async with engine.acquire() as conn:
await conn.execute("SELECT 1;")I think it is more likely issue with transaction. |
|
Hi! Thanks for feedback. I have modified the code as following: but the problem persists I provide a load of 120 concurrent requests during 10 minutes and after a while the service hangs again. In aiopg logs I see something like this: ... and then the service hangs... |
|
Note that pool maxsize is 10 connections as set by default. If I increase the maximum pool size, load test has been passed |
|
It seems to me, when pool size goes to max limit size another connections does not return to pool and aiopg can`t acquire new connection from the pool or something like this. |
|
From logs, I see you still do inserts... I suspect that connection stuck in unknown state due to transaction error or so, I may be wrong. |
|
If U wish U can run this code with pool max size = 10 (by default) and provide load about 120 concurrent requests during some time and see that insert has stopped and service hangs.... The point is, when I increase max pool size e.g. to 1000 the load test has been passed |
|
May be it is not the problem and I can set max pool size veeeeeery long, but I wonder why the service hangs on small pool size. |
|
If I press KeyboardInterrupt I get this |
|
I think the question should be "is it possible to get another connection from pool if previous not returned yet"? |
|
I have some like this issue. It was print before error: |
|
the current pool implementation does not have a timeout, and you can deadlock it easily if you acquire two connections in a nested manner attaching an easier test script to reproduce import asyncio
import logging
import aiopg.sa
logger = logging.getLogger()
CONN_STRING = 'postgresql://test:[email protected]/aiopg_test'
async def create_engine(pool_size):
return await aiopg.sa.create_engine(
CONN_STRING,
maxsize=pool_size
)
async def q2(engine, task_id):
logger.debug('starting task {}'.format(task_id))
async with engine.acquire():
logger.debug('acquired conn task {}'.format(task_id))
pass
logger.debug('released conn task {}'.format(task_id))
async def q1(engine, task_id, nested):
logger.debug('starting task {}'.format(task_id))
async with engine.acquire():
logger.debug('acquired conn task {}'.format(task_id))
if nested:
await q2(engine, task_id)
async def main(concurrency, iterations, pool_size, nested, loop):
engine = await create_engine(pool_size)
for n in range(iterations):
print('iteration={n}'.format_map(locals()))
tasks = [asyncio.ensure_future(q1(engine, i, nested), loop=loop) for i in range(concurrency)]
await asyncio.wait(tasks, loop=loop)
if __name__ == '__main__':
import argparse
parser = argparse.ArgumentParser()
parser.add_argument('-c', '--concurrency', type=int, default=10)
parser.add_argument('-i', '--iterations', type=int, default=10)
parser.add_argument('-p', '--pool-size', type=int, default=10)
parser.add_argument('-n', '--nested', action='store_true')
args = parser.parse_args()
loop = asyncio.get_event_loop()
logging.basicConfig(level=logging.DEBUG, format='%(funcName)s %(lineno)d: %(message)s')
loop.run_until_complete(main(args.concurrency, args.iterations, args.pool_size, args.nested, loop=loop))not nested, everything ok python test_pool.py -c 1000nested, if concurrency is higher than pool size it deadlocks |
|
related to #16 |
|
This is good news. We will look forward to the completion of the task #16 , but it is open from 2014 :-) |
|
task #16 it is not really needed, see this comment #125 (comment) as of that comment, we might even consider closing this current issue as invalid @jettify |
|
Use |
|
@mpaolini how can be rewritten your code above to solve the problem with nested, if concurrency is higher than pool size? |
|
For your case just pass already acquired connection to |
|
Of course it solves, but what about nested connection acquiring as @mpaolini said, is it possible? |
Hi!
I have got the problem with aiopg when acquiring new connection from pool. I have used a simple code for this:
Then I provide a load of 100 concurrent requests and after a while the service hangs. It seems to me that aiopg can not get another connection from the pool, because when I increase the maximum pool size load test has been passed
I have used the following:
aiopg-0.9.2
psycopg2-2.6.1
SQLAlchemy-1.0.12
tornado-4.3
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: