App Store publication issues when using Carthage

[makoni]

There're few issues with publishing to App Store if you add Ably through.

Tha app builds and runs but when you're making an archive and upload it to App Store it won't be validated. Errors while validating:

iTunes Store Operation Failed
CFBundleIdentifier Collision. There is more than one bundle with the CFBundleIdentifier value 'com.facebook.socketrocket.ios' under the iOS application 'myApp.app'.

iTunes Store Operation Failed
CFBundleIdentifier Collision. There is more than one bundle with the CFBundleIdentifier value 'com.remyvirin.msgpack' under the iOS application 'myApp.app'.

iTunes Store Operation Failed
CFBundleIdentifier Collision. There is more than one bundle with the CFBundleIdentifier value 'org.stenerud.KSCrash' under the iOS application 'myApp.app'.

iTunes Store Operation Failed
This bundle Payload/myApp.app/Frameworks/Ably.framework/Frameworks/SocketRocket.framework is invalid. The Info.plist file is missing the required key: CFBundleVersion.

iTunes Store Operation Failed
This bundle Payload/myApp.app/Frameworks/SocketRocket.framework is invalid. The Info.plist file is missing the required key: CFBundleVersion.

iTunes Store Operation Failed
Invalid Bundle. The bundle at 'myApp.app/Frameworks/Ably.framework' contains disallowed nested bundles.

iTunes Store Operation Failed
Invalid Bundle. The bundle at 'myApp.app/Frameworks/Ably.framework' contains disallowed file 'Frameworks'.

Is there a chance in will be fixed?

Here's how signing screen looks like:

[funkyboy]

@makoni Thanks for reporting this.
Which version of the SDK are you using?

[makoni]

I use latest Xcode 9.2 with iOS 11 SDK

[funkyboy]

@makoni That's also good to know.

I was asking about the version of the Ably SDK :)
What's your Cartfile like?

[makoni]

github "ably/ably-ios" == 1.0.11

I had the same issues with github "ably/ably-ios" ~> 1.0

[funkyboy]

Thanks. What version of Carthage are you using? (carthage version in the terminal)

[makoni]

0.28.0

[funkyboy]

Is your app including an App Extension by chance?

[makoni]

No, just iOS app without extensions

[makoni]

Here's how my Carthage build folder looks like if it can help:

[funkyboy]

There's a duplication on the file system but likely there's also one in the Xcode project.

In the General tab what's "Linked Frameworks and Libraries" like?

[makoni]

Like in README screenshot:
https://github.com/ably/ably-ios/blob/master/Examples/Images/linked-frameworks.png

[funkyboy]

Can you please get rid of the Carthage build folder and anything related to Carthage in the project, and then run carthage update --no-use-binaries?

[makoni]

I made an empty Xcode project which you can use to reproduce all issues. Just change bundle id and team to yours and try to archive and validate:

ablyTest.zip

[funkyboy]

Will try now. Thanks.

[funkyboy]

@makoni The solution (workaround?) I found is to delete this folder.

Not ideal, but at least you can submit your app :)
Will keep this issue open because it needs investigation.

Thanks for your help so far!

[funkyboy]

If you hit the SocketRocket missing CFBundleVersion value just add this to the SocketRocket Info.plist.

[funkyboy]

As for the SocketRocket error I sent a PR here: facebookincubator/SocketRocket#559

[funkyboy]

I created a separate issue for the "SocketRocket missing CFBundleVersion" problem here

[funkyboy]

@makoni This is now fixed in version 1.0.12

[bhargavbajani]

@funkyboy
A duplicate framework issue is happening in latest version >= 1.2.16

[bhargavbajani]

@makoni can you reopen this?

[makoni]

@makoni can you reopen this?

Unfortunately there's no reopen button. Try to open a new issue